Customer Reviews Lucky Brand Emmie

Very nice shoe, but unfortunately too narrow and too small in the toebox. People with wide feet, beware! This is not the shoe for you.

The toe region of this shoe is odd. When I first put them on, they felt large. Soft like slippers, but large. The material above my four smaller toes gapped and creased, yet my big toe was near the tip/end of the shoe, so they are technically the right length. There is too much material around the arch of the foot too. I can feel it when I walk and it bunches under my arch. I wear a 7½ and have relatively thin feet, and they are not attractive. They re too wide and make my foot look odd. They are very soft and comfortable, almost like slippers. Very soft sole-no arch support and not much padding between the bottom of your foot and the ground. I ordered the brown and they're the perfect color, but just an odd fit so they are going back.

Based on the reviews, I was hoping to walk in these flats all day without discomfort. Wrong. First point of pain was the heel. Of course I ended up with a blister. This was easily solved with some heel padding. Wore them again, and wrong again. Second point of pain was across the width of my foot and my big toe. Because of the padding, my foot was pushed to the edge. The pain across my foot surprised me because I have narrow feet. When I tried these on the 7 was too loose so I went with 6.5. Now they are at the cobbler being stretched. I hope this solves most of my problems because is it difficult to find a clean, reasonably priced pair of black flat without junk (aka rhinestones) on them. Hence the three stars.

I'll sacrifice quite a bit of comfort for a cute shoe, but these have an airtight synthetic liner (vinyl, maybe?). Wearing them for even an hour is pretty much unbearable. Back they go!

I was disappointed in this shoe. It came highly recommended by a friend, but they're sloppy and carry little in the way of arch/heel support. I usually wear an 8.5 or 9, and the 9 feels on the short side. After a few hours I'm ready to kick these off.

This shoe is very pretty - featherlight and graceful. It looks quite "Audrey Hepburn" with a capri pant. Simple and sweet. Unfortunately, I had to pass them up...they weren't as soft as I'd hoped, and felt snug across the toes. The circular heel is cute but makes them unstable. I knew I'd regret them the first long walk I took in them.

I bought these flats in the color mandarin which is very nice, not too bright. The shoe is very flimsy though being made with fabric with no arch support. I purchased the Seychelles brand orange flat instead. They are better made with support.

You'll get more cushion and arch support from just about any other shoe. Might be better with an insert. The shoe stays on, but the sides grip pretty tightly and have a tendency to cause blisters.

These hurt my feet a lot! Rubs on my pinky toes and heels. Also the back of them sticks out funny. I won't wear them unless I have extra moleskin in my pocket and am wearing long pants that cover the back.

Be careful when ordering the Mandarin color flat! It is NOT leather, it is fabric. The description here is not clear so I ordered it thinking it was leather. Good things returns are easy.

Runs a bit small; felt very flat also almost worse than walking barefoot. Cute otherwise!

True to what others are saying - they run small. Also there are gold thread running through the stripe - not a fan of gold but they are cute shoes!

Nice plain black leather shoes. The back of the shoe bit into my heel though.

These ballet flats are super cute, but very uncomfortable. The heel is a raised circle (look at the bottom view), so it made my arch sag downward since there is zero support. Also, the back of the shoe dug into my heel and was very painful.

Don't get me wrong these flats are very cute but for some reason I wore these flats for about 30 minutes and my heels were in pain. This was just simply walking through an airport and by the time I got to the gate for my flight I was in so much pain. I took my shoes off and noticed the back of the shoes cut into both of my heels. I'll try wearing band-aids next time to see if that helps. I just have had bad experiences with flat shoes. I always wear pumps or wedges and never have an issue but when it comes time to wearing flats they hurt the back of my heels. I don't think their is a design flaw in these shoes it must be my feet. I'm 5' 6" and weigh 105 pounds so it's not like I'm cramming my foot into shoes that don't fit. Other than the cuts on my heels these shoes are very cute and would go with just about anything. They are probably the cutest pair of basic black flats I've seen. I haven't worn them since but if I do I'll be sure to wear band-aids on my heels and bring a pair of pumps just in case.

Super cute, but uncomfortable. The elastic sides made this very uncomfortable to walk in as they dug into the sides of my feet. I wish they had worked for me, but they had to be returned.

This flat is very gold/shimmery and has a pinkish tone to it. It is extremely uncomfortable, which is why I am returning it. Just wearing it one day to the office (very minimal walking) I got a blister on my heel and one on my pinkie toe. They are very thin so don't expect any arch support. They are also pretty roomy without feeling too big.

I purchased the shoe in the champagne color to replace a pair of Steve Madden rose gold flats I'd loved for years - the color was close enough. I don't generally wear the stretchy ballet flat type of shoes, and these don't necessarily convince me to wear more. The metallic leather looks cheap/thin where it bunches. This might have been fixed by ordering a half or even whole size smaller than I normally wear. The heel is the oddest part of the shoe, in that its so small, my heel doesn't sit on the heel of the shoe. It makes for an awkward, fidgety fit. Again, maybe would have been fixed with a smaller size, but still the heel is only slightly larger than a silver dollar. However I like the color and versatility of the shoes, so I kept them. I've found Lucky shoes to be generally uncomfortable but cute and well built - these are no exception.

I had major problems with the heel slipping up and down. I thought maybe they were too big, but my toes felt cramped, so I don't think I could have gone down a size. Also, they didn't breathe so after an hour or so the feet were wet which caused even more slipping. It's too bad because they were very cute!

Comfortable, cute, and seem true to size. A few other reviews complained that the material is low quality and I would agree. The cheap material makes them squeak if I wear them without nylons. If they were higher quality I would by multiple colors.

Tight, tiny, weird heel. The rubber under the heel is a strange round piece that hurts when you step. Very tight and narrow too. My feet are slightly smaller than an 8, but that's what I always get. Well, this 8 was too small. Disappointed.

These shoes are super cute, but I didn't find them very comfortable. I always order a size 10, but my big toes really hurt after wearing these so maybe I need a half size bigger. Overall I was disappointed.

These are OK. They have a goldish shimmer to them and are a little on the peach side. I am not sure if you can tell that by the photo. They also feel a little short. My toes jam into the front but going a size bigger would slip of my feet everywhere else.

Love the rose cream color, which was exactly what I wanted in a neutral ballet flat to wear with brown, gold, and camel. However, these are not very comfortable to walk or stand in for a long period of time. I can feel the concrete beneath my heel each time I take a step, so I probably need to add some gel inserts. The leather looks relatively cheap and I could see creases from bending my foot about five minutes in to my first wear. I need to take it easy with these and wear my sturdier, more comfortable flats for days when I'm doing lots of walking.

This is fine. My daughter needed a plain black uniform shoe, and this shoe meets the rechnical requirements. But, it offers very little support and is not comfortable for any extended period. The back elastic is actually a little tight-- such that my daughter needed to go up a half-size.