Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Tinsley

Sized up after reading the reviews but the 9 was too big and I have to return them. I wear a size 8 so I am sure the 8 would've fit better, however, they are very thin and flimsy as well. very cute and stylish though.

Loved the style but these run at least 1 size too small and very narrow. Returning for something different.

Great for going to work on a rainy day.

They fit, but it takes a good tug to get on. They are comfortable once on. I bought the matte finish because I wear these on congested urban streets, and these don’t show the scuffs and dirt. They’re not fancy, but they do the job of keeping my feet dry. Reasonable price.

cute rain bootie. runs small, I recommended ordering one size up.

Make sure to read the reviews. They saved me. Bought half size up based on reviews and they fit perfectly. I got he matte black and they look like regular booties (besides the whole rain boot look)

They are very stylish for rain boots, but the edge of the rubber around the top of the boot shaft is somewhat sharp, causing uncomfortable rubbing. Rubber is somewhat thin.

Very cute and comfortable but they run a little small. I'm normally a 9 but the 9s were too small so I exchanged them for a 10 which fits perfectly.

They run a little narrow and aren't very comfortable for me. They are very pretty though

I loved these! Been looking for a good quality not too expensive chelsea rain boot and these didn't disappoint. They look like normal chelsea boots but are obviously totally waterproof! Plus since they're rubber they don't require too much breaking in! I will say that it's very important to try them on first because there was a part that kind of pinches the top (outside by pinky toe) of my foot but it's sort of going away. Obviously if it's pouring the tops of your long socks coudl get wet but your toes will be dry! They also fared really well in muddy conditions and I just rinsed/wiped them off and good as new! I'm normally a 7.5 and my feet aren't actually wide enough for me to need to buy wide shoes but they're kind of wide because of my bunions, so I got an 8. I also got the 7s to try on but returned them because they only fit if I was barefoot and even then were too tight - would have loved to see a half size or maybe I should've tried the 7 wide, but oh well!

style is like a 90's shortie boot with very sleek fit. does NOT fit like a rain boot, and so form fitting that only a trouser sock could be worn with it. not very good traction on sole - could be slick in the rain? If you intend to wear socks with the boot, I would recommend sizing up 1/2 size. Narrow fit from the toe box to the toes.

Too narrow at the toe

My feet are slightly narrower-than-average and are typically a true 8.5 however I purchased these boots in both 8 and 9 and found the 8 to be a perfect fit while I was wearing normal spots crew socks and the 9 was too big.

I am a 7.5 and bought both an 8 and a 7. The 7 was a little tight and the 8 was too big. Ended up keeping the 7 in hopes that they stretch slightly. They are pretty narrow.

This is a cute rain bootie, but unfortunately the sizing was off for me. I'm usually a 7.5, so I ordered a 7 and an 8. The 8 was too big, slipping off my heel when I walked, and while the 7 fit better, it was too snug. So they had to go back. Re the style - very cute, but I would've preferred a pointer / less rounded toe.

I love these boots. Great rain boots and I often get compliments from them! Very true to size, I recommend them!

These boots are great! The material looks more like faux-leather than rubber - very stylish and attractive for everyday wear. The ankle is more narrow than I expected, which is good for fitting the boot under my pant legs. However, it's difficult to tuck pants into the boots unless they are skinny/leggings. They are surprisingly comfortable, though the sole/lining slides around a bit. I may have to glue it down.

I wear 8WW (when I can find them) and tried this in a 9. I found them just a bit snug, though for anyone with medium or narrow feet, they would be just fine. They fit OK once I took out the insole, though they are less comfortable... I'm fine with anything as long as my toes and bunion aren't squished! The style is also attractive and appropriate to wear throughout the day in the office.

The sole is a little thin - it's not terrible, but if you need to walk long distances in these, definitely consider an insole. Overall they're fantastic for this price -- durable, warm with thick socks, and very attractive for rain boots (I wear them on dry days all the time and no one notices). Run small and narrow - order a full size up.

I really like these shoes, very cute and great for staying stylish while you have to wade through icy puddles in NYC. Only downsides are that the shoe lining under the foot has not stayed put and that the toe area is narrower than expected.

Looks really nice. Quality isn't great, but when worn with socks the flaws aren't noticeable (socks/hosiery are a must). Fit perfect right out of the box (4W got a 5) even with heavier socks. My biggest compliant, the ankle is very narrow but the pull tab is not. As a result, my jeans/pants don't fit in the boot and they don't fit over.

These are such stylish boots, but they are narrower than predicted. I am normally a 7.5, so I ordered a size 7 because I read in another review that 8 may be too large. 7 was perfect for my feet when not wearing socks. It gets a little tight with winter socks, so I'm going to keep them, but get thinner socks.

I bought these rain boots to replace my old hunter boots. I think they are great rain boots for wet urban commuting. So far, they are keeping my feet dry!

I'm sad to return these, they're really cute & only a bit narrow.. but the soles collect hair big time. I work with dogs, so in no time I'm going to be slipping & skating in these.

Stylish look but way too narrow for me. Also, the cut was too high and rubbed on my leg which was uncomfortable. Sadly, had to return.