Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Tinsley

Great fit, and excellent for both rainy days and for a bolder shoe look. Came relatively quickly as well!

These are classy clean cut rain boots. They do feel a teeny bit snug so I would probably buy a half size up if needed. I wear the Wide fit and they're a bit snug on the toe/bunion region.

Very nice looking boots, but the rubber is very stiff the shoe is narrow. I can tell they will rub the sides of my feet so I decided to return them.

I ordered wide and sized up based on other reviews and this boot was too big. So I reordered in my normal size (9) but also with the wide width and it's perfect. Even though my foot is a normal width, it was necessary to get wide. The opening at the top is a little narrow and scrapes against my leg if I'm not wearing long socks which can be a little irritating. The boots also have a curious odor that smells like bananas? I assume this will wear off.

Nice design but short and narrow. Could have doe wit half size larger.

The toe box was narrower than expected. Will not keep this pair of shoes.

I usually fit a 7W in Sam Edelman Shoes, but these were so much smaller than I was expecting. I might try again later and order a full size up. If you're planning to wear with thick socks, definitely order up.

If you're a half-size, order one side up, not down, especially if you are going to wear socks. The shoe is cut narrow, so I ordered a wide width, and it fit well. Shoe is on the stiff side, as it's not leather and will not give, but stylish and perfect for rainy days. Easy to get on and off, as it's not a high boot.

Fit is off by just a bit. I’m not sure if this a new version, but I have an older pair, same exact style/color, and it is completely different in fit. I will say they will stretch out and I will stick with them as I love how they go with just about anything!

A little stiff but look and feel good!

I opted for these over the similar J Crew boot because of the slimmer, less clunky profile and the narrower ankle opening. They were about equally comfortable for a rain boot. They fit snugly, but not uncomfortably so, and slip on and off with no problem because there's a stretchy elastic gusset on the side - maybe that's a recent change in response to all the complaints that they were extremely difficult to pull on and off? Plus, a narrower top allows less rain to run into the boot when I'm wearing a skirt or dress rather than pants.

I purchased these shoes because I wanted a fashionable, low rain boot that wasn't too expensive. To me, these boots had everything I was looking for in looks and cost. They are not the most comfortable shoe in my collection; perhaps a more expensive shoe would be more comfortable. The toe box of these boots are narrow, so the tops and sides of my toes bump up against the boots. That is saying something because I have pretty narrow feet. I have worn the boots with regular ankle socks and my foot is at least able to fit in the boots. Not sure I could fit my foot in the boots with chunky socks. Despite being tight on my toes, I have worn my boots a couple of times and have not received any blisters, which I consider a win so I will be keeping them. I am usually a size 8.5 but ordered them in a size 9. I am glad I decided to order a half size up. I don't think I would enjoy them a full size up.

I’ve had my boots for 2 years and they still look great. The boots fit well & are comfortable. I really like the style. The material is different. I’m not sure what it is, but it’s the reason for 4 stars under overall.

I have wide feet and really was looking forward to this. I went half a size up and ordered the W but still was not comfortable.

Seems like a good shoe to wear in the rain and still stay stylish, but these weren't the ones for me. It was a little narrow and difficult to put on even though I don't have wide feet.

I’m normally an 8/8.5 with a slightly wider foot, and I ordered these in a size 8W at the end of 2017. They were a bit too tight on the top of my foot but I didn’t realize until I’d worn them outside, so I ended up keeping them. They eventually got more comfortable, but after a almost 2 years of wear one shoe ended up with a giant hole in the bottom of the sole, making them no longer wearable. I walk a lot and wore these often, and the hole seemed like it came from normal wear and tear so I won’t blame the shoe for that. I just ordered them again (this time in a size 9M) and look forward to another 1-2 years of wear.

I? purchased these shoes for my daughter. she loves them very much. they are comfortable and especially not as heavy as other boots she has owned in the past. very low-keyed and stylish.

Stylish rain boot. Think I will choose this one over my bulky ones on most days. Wish they had half sizes. Had to return the 6 for a 5, and I’m hoping the size 5 isn’t too small. I’m normally a 5.5 and a 6 for pointy or sometimes European shoes. This matte boot is perfect style-wise. I like the narrower foot in the front since I have a bit more narrow feet (maybe average), and my current rain boots look huge on the toe area (not super cute). I definitely recommend trying these out as an alternative to the clunky rain boot. Won’t work for massive puddles because they are shorter. As far as comfort, that is to be determined since I haven’t worn them for an extended period of time. Style-wise though, they are fantastic. They look like leather boots from far away and don’t look cheap.

Loved the look of these boots, more stylish than the usual rain boots. Nice matte finish. Ordered a size up so I could wear thick socks, which worked out fine. However, even the W width is not a true wide but not so narrow that I couldn't wear them comfortably. Wore them for hours in pouring rain and my feet stayed dry throughout.

I like these booties... Like, Not LOVE. Couple things to point out: 1 - I bought Wide width even if I wear normal width since I wear them with regular socks (not winter socks, not just leggings. 2 - The shaft can be restricting. I wish it was a tad looser. Not a deal breaker. 3 - I walked 3 miles in them, and was surprised I was fine, except where the top of the shaft hit my leg, it got a little bit chafed. Just a little. Again, not a deal breaker.

At first I thought these shoes were too narrow when I tried them on. I was about to leave for a trip to Dublin and was looking for boots to walk around in that were waterproof as it was going to rain the entire time so I kept them. They ended up being perfect. Walked around for 3 days in them and had no problems!

I love the look of these boots. My only complaint is that the insole slips up behind my heel after about 20 minutes of walking. I wish it were better attached to the base of the shoe. Super cute and fun to wear in the rain!

Overall pleased with the functionality of this shoe. We have had so much rain in LA this winter and I got these shoes as an alternative to my very high rain boots. These shoes will keep your feet try in the rain, trust me, I stepped in several deep puddles. You do need to wear high socks with them and tucking your jeans inside can be challenging if they're not skinny jeans. These are pretty comfortable for rain boots as long as you're wearing high socks so they don't rub.

I initially ordered a 12 (my normal size) and it was tiny. Both too narrow and too small in length. The size up is perfect though. Can’t wear them with heavy socks, but they’re perfect for everyday wear. They look very cute too.