Customer Reviews Cobb Hill Petra

LOVE-the best fitting shoe ever! I literally put them on right out of the box- by far the best and most comfortable shoe I have ever had! I just may order another pair for back up.

This shoe is adorable. There is a seam in the insole under the ball of my foot that I was afraid would be problematic for me, but after a day of wearing them to work and walking 1 1/2 miles home, they've stayed comfortable. Now, I want one in every color.

This is a beautiful leather shoe. It is stylish and very comfortable. I ordered a wide in my regular shoe size, 8.5, but it is too big.

Just got them. Seem comfortable

Strap is too short to completely cover the rough velcro strip, even in the "Wide" option. I am returning the shoes for this reason

Too big, but very nice shoe.

I have pronation in my feet. These shoes didn't have enough arch support. Also, the heels slipped when I walked. They'd be great for someone without foot issues. They are well-made and would go well with skirts.

I have very hard to fit feet and this shoe probably comes as close to a good fit as any I have worn for a long time. Seems pretty comfortable and gpes with about anything

A little grandma-ish IMO but still a solid Mary Jane. I have a wider foot the medium accommodated. Can wear barefoot with powder or very thin sock.

comfortable but need more height

I’ve had these several years and they’re pretty good, though they went from smart enough for church with some outfits to too casual looking as they got broken in. I guess it’s the finish that doesn’t hold up as well as I’d like. That really wouldn’t be an issue if they’d offer a dressier version. Then I could have these for casual and a comfortable pair that’s nicer for dressier days. That would be great.

Fits great. Comfortable and well made. But even though I am relatively old, I am not as old as I hope to some day be, and so hope to find something more youthful looking for right now. I think the brown color adds to the mature woman look. I am immature.

the material feels cheap and stiff, older versions of the same shoe are much better quality

This is an attractive casual shoe to wear with slacks. I was looking for a shoe with a strap because I have narrow feet with a very narrow heels. The toe box is roomier than I need although the size 11 length is good. To keep my feet from sliding around, I installed foam shoe liners. It was a reasonable solution since it is becoming harder and harder to find shoes in narrow widths.

I had high hopes for these shoes based on the reviews. Alas, too tight for my bunion and the toe box fit at a funny place at the top of my foot. Tye were nice looking shoes but had to go back.

Nice shoes- leather is very soft. I bought a 9 1/2 W, but they were way too long, like at least 1/2 size, could be a trip hazard if I kept them. Width was good. The insoles were nice and soft with some arch support.

Shoe fits although the leather is a bit stiff. I'm not crazy about the style but it's a practical summer and early fall shoe for my hard to fit feet.

Cute shoes, but they aren't narrow enough for my feet. Side to side they are, but not narrow enough from the sole of my feet to the tops. I guess I would say my feet are thin (like a flat pancake!). Too bad. I liked the shoes.

These are cute shoes and appear well made, however the right shoe caused my foot to roll inward. There was not an obvious manufacturing defect and I don't usually have this problem with shoes, but this definitely made these shoes uncomfortable.

Fit and size are perfect.

I tried these in a store and wanted to buy them. Very cute and comfortable. But.....the strap cam up shorter than what I would have liked it to be. That is, when I strapped it to the velcro, it barely even secured onto the velcro ? which did not feel secure enough. I had never before tried the mary jane style but now I know that maybe my arch is a bit higher than normal.

Leather is more stiff than I need. The shoes rubbed on the outside of my big toes. Color and design are very nice.