Customer Reviews KEEN Presidio MJ

These are my go to everyday shoes. I love the grey and black, which makes them a little more versatile. I also love the little pink detail. I have very high arches and the first time that I wore them I was concerned that the top part of the toe box was going to really hurt the top of my foot. But after a few wears they have eased up and I wear these all day, everyday with no issues at all. I split my time between working in a casual office and stay at home mom. I find these perfect for both. I feel a little more stylish at the playground over plain sneakers, and I can run around and up play structures without issues. They are cute enough, but I do find myself wondering if there is a bit of an old lady element about them. But I am happy. I am between a 7½-8, usually more 8. The 7½ fits my wide feet well.

Excellent shoes. I got them to replace a similar pair of Keens I bought a few years ago. I wear them every day.

Super adorable shoe and definitely order a 1/2 size down though. I'm sending back mine for a smaller pair. But love, love this shoe! Thanks Keen!

I usually order up a half size in Keens, but found the 8 1/2 way too large, even with moderately thick socks. I plan to reorder an 8; hopefully that will work better because I did like the shoes.

I was looking for a good looking and supportive walking shoe for a trip up to Canada and Upper New England States. I saw the Keen shoes and read reviews. I love this pair, however they run large. I usually wear an 8 1/2 M. I finally got a 7 1/2M. They fit great. Seem to run wide, so I wore them all week on my trip. Lots of walking up and down hills. Nice style,not a white athletic shoe!I love Zappos return policy. I did return 2 pairs looking for the right fit. So easy to print up label for Free return.

I bought these for my daughter who was finally able to wear shoes after two ankle surgeries. She needed something sturdy but wanted something a little girly (she is 39) she didn't want an old lady shoe! This shoe fit the bill and she says they are comfortable and stylish. She wears them all the time!

The casual Keen shoe with a dressy touch -- I wear these with skirts and dresses. Teaching high school is tough on my feet, but then, too, I like to look nice. I ordered these in red and know that I'll look good and be comfortable at the same time.

I LOVE this MJ, I've been wearing Keen MJ's for years and they are always super comfortable from day one. Some just look better on my feet and this is one of them.

The fit and size were just right. I returned them only because I had an older pair of Keens that were very similar in style. I wasn't crazy about the lighter colored toe "bumper," and thought it detracted a little from the otherwise snappy, cute style.

These were too big for me but otherwise seemed very comfortable and worth exchanging for a smaller size.

These shoes seem very well made and the color is as pictured - a nice neutral. Sadly, the medium width did not accommodate my large bunion, so must return them. Thank you so much for your excellent selection of shoes and your great return policy.

I LOVE Keen shoes and have several pairs that are similar to these. For me, the 7 is a little small (with socks) and the 7.5 a little big but since they are a Mary Jane style they work well. If they are like my previous Keens, they will wear like iron and stay comfy!

As stated in other reviews, the toe area felt right, although being new, a little tight, but the heel feels wide. My foot slips out. Wearing then barefoot now, hoping when the weather turns cold, and I wear them with socks, the heel fit will be better. Love the arch support. Will wait to see how they feel after wearing for awhile before I order another pair. Wish I could find a store that sells them to try on first!

I am still unsure about this shoe. Rather clunky for a MJ. Way too big in heel. Color is odd. Not black, gray or blue.

I was so excited to receive my Presidio MJ. I have a pair of the Presidio "lace up" style that I have loved for years and they have never disappointed me and just keep going. I have received many, many compliments on them. When I opened my box with my MJ's the quality made my heart sing with their beauty. The color, however, called Canteen/Cornstalk caught me off guard. From the picture I thought I was seeing kind of a sandy beige and these were dark brown! Brown is not a color that I wear--problem. Then I tried them on and I loved the feel of the foot bed and the outside of the shoes was stunning. I tried to buckle the straps and had a difficult time getting the little metal piece into their holes--my husband had to do it in the end. Once they were on I could not find a good hole to use to fit my foot. Whatever I tried it was either too tight or too loose. I was so DISAPPOINTED when the realization set in that I couldn't keep them due to the color and the strap problem. I will say they made their trip back to Zappo's quickly and my refund was applied in full just as fast. Thank you Zappo's--not your fault. They are nice shoes--fit?

Very comfy. Maybe a little wider at the toes than most, but gives you lots of toe room

I love the look of these shoes and solid sole. Unfortunately they are too wide and inflexible, slipping on my heel when I walk. I am returning.

I wear a 6.5 or 37 almost always, and, in this brand I have the lace up Presidios in 37 and they fit with only minimal heel slippage. I have a narrow ankle. I tried these mary janes in black in the 6.5 and the heel came right out it was so loose. I even tried going down a size but there was still too much slippage and my toes were just a little too tight. I find that with a 6.5 size, sometimes these Euro shoes that are a 6.5/7 are a little too big. Too bad about these, because if the heel was better I think they would have been perfect. I see other reviewers also have this issue. Maybe the company should think about offering narrow heels.

This is the shoe I wear at work. It’s a great product, but it’s long and wide. Wiggle room is not a bad thing when you spend most of your days on your feet, because they swell. But the heel feels very wide too, which makes me feel like I swim in it. My feet are not wide, but definitely not narrow. Good shoe, not the best fit. Wish I could wear the same type of socks that I wear in my Keen hiking boot. :-) Still on the hunt for the perfect cute supportive flat.

These are funky cool and cute! I almost didn’t order because of the buckled strap - I HATE to buckle shoes. But there’s an elastic band on the ‘shoe’ side of the buckle, so I can slide them on and off without using the cursed buckle. Yay! Best of all, they feel great underfoot.

I want to love this shoe, but can't. I have a pair in red, size 7.5, that's just too short. But with the 8s, my heel is just swimming in this shoe. It's a shame, because the wide toe box is a perfect solution for my bunion, and the insoles are supportive and well-padded (and also removable to accommodate orthotics) but I just can't find a pair of Keen's Mary Janes that fit. I have the Presidio lace-ups in an 8.5 that work because I can tighten enough for the heel to stay put.

I love these shoes but I had to order 3 times to get the correct size. I wear a size 7 with no socks and 7.5 with socks. I first ordered this shoe in a 7.5 but it was too big so I returned that pair and order a size 7. That was also too big with socks so I returned that pair and ordered a size 6.5 which finally ft perfectly with socks. I have a very wide foot and the medium width is nice and roomy for my foot so they would never work for someone with a narrow foot. Another review mentioned that it slips on the heel and it does some but a back of heel cushion fixed that issue. I have a high arch and the arch support is excellent. The generous toe box and excellent arch support made it worth it to me to fix the heel issue but I gave it only 4 stars overall because it requires extra effort to make it work perfectly.

Used these for my New York City walking vacation. Good looking shoe. Tough wearing. Looks brand new even after many many miles of walking. Good support.

Overall these run large and wide. I stand all day long at work and they are not nearly as comfortable as my Dansko's, but of all the shoes I have tried they would probably come in second to Dansko's. They are well made. I will probably only wear these on shorter shift days as they just don't hold up to a full eight hours on my feet.

Bought these to replace a similar style from Keen that I got years ago. Roomy toe box. Heel slips a little, but tightening the strap helps with that. Top cuts into top of foot just a little, but that will go away with wear. Same thing happened with older model. Love the rubber toe protection and thick soles. Glad I found this style again.