Customer Reviews KEEN Presidio MJ

Looks and feels great EXCEPT too large.

I'm pleased that Keen continues to provide shoes for women that have decent support that can be worn with dresses as well as pants. Many of the cute flats they've made recently have been so flimsy (Rivington, Sienna) that my feet ached after wearing them. These felt true to size and supported my arches nicely. I hope there will be more similar styles to come, particularly those made with the broad toe area.

My 6 yr old Keene Mary Janes finally needed replacing, and I was thrilled that the same model is being produced. I bought the same size (US 8) and they fit like a charm. I have wide rather square feet so depending on a shoe/ boot style I wear 7.5-8.5. I have worn this model shoe everywhere ...work, casual, dress-up and around the house. The quality of my new pair appears to be up to Keen standards. I hope they make these forever. I also have high arches and these shoes are very comfortable, stylish and last a long time.

I have trouble finding comfortable shoes and these fit the bill. A little stiff, but that will improve over time. Delivery was amazingly fast.

Why on earth did they stop making these? They are doing a huge disservice to those with injuries who need these shoes.

I love the keen presidio Mary Jane. I have a high arch, and this shoe works great. I need a wide width, high arch, high toe box and round toe shoe and this shoe does the trick. They don’t hurt my feet, which is amazing. Most shoes do hurt even after being broken in. The presidio is the best. I bought this MJ in black and silver. Please don’t discontinue this shoe. And love them

I love these Keen Mary Janes. Previously I wore out a pair of these that were a size 7 and to get them to fit I had to wear thick, thick socks. I ordered these in a half size smaller, 6 1/2, and they are perfect. I have wide feet and these are wide enough to be very comfortable. I usually need an orthotic, and while the foot bed is removable, the arch supports in this shoe are very comfortable.

I love Keens and have worn them forever. They last forever too and I haven’t ordered a new pair in a few years. I was worried after reading some reviews that maybe they had changed too much and I wouldn’t like them. The first pair I ordered, I think maybe someone tried them on and stretched them out too much for me so I ordered another pair in the same size and the heel and strap weren’t stretched out and fit me perfectly. What a relief because they are so super comfortable and glad I got them. Thanks Zappos!

This is the most comfortable pair of shoes I have even worn (and I wear other Keens, Merrells, and Clarks)!! They're not so attractive and a bit heavy, but the grey color is great, and they are absolutely like walking on a cloud! I wear SuperFeet insoles with all my other shoes for arch support, but I don't need them in this shoe.

Did not last long for the money

Too wide in the heel. Planned to wear them without socks and my heel kept slipping out even with the strap tight. Otherwise the fit would have been heavenly! Sadly, will need to return. May try the smaller size to see if that works.

Lovely but too wide

I really, really wanted these to work. Because I LOVE the presidio lace-ups both in the leather and in the mesh sport look. But it just doesn't work. Even in a half-size smaller my heel lifts when I walk, even when I buckle the strap so tight it hurts. Oh well, will have to return it. Sadly.

Loved the shoe, but the heel was much too wide and slipped when walking Had to return

I had surgery in June for plantar fasciitis and have had a hard time finding shoes that didn't make my feet hurt. Enter in Keen's, I love this shoe, I've only worn them once to break in before our trip to England but they have made a huge difference in my feet. The only problem is in the toe are, it make my foot swell a little but nothing a little visit to a shoe repair place didn't fix. Totally worth the buy.

The Mary Janes started out as my travel shoes for work -- easy to slip on/off to get through airports and fades into the background at business-casual work meetings. However, I now find that I wear them constantly -- daily. Holds up to Portland's rain and good tread and traction when I hiked through the surprise snow storm in January. I usually wear a 12C. The 12 here runs a bit large (both length and width), but overall very comfortable. I hope that Keens continues to carry size 12s.

I love Keens and this MJ is wonderful. They are very professional looking and I am on my feet all day and they never hurt! Love them!

I love Keens and this MJ has wonderful support and is professional looking to wear everyday at work. I stand all day and my feet never hurt! Love them!

cute and comfy. Great shoe to stand in all day if you have to

Open box wear new shoes all day no problems. The last few times I have had problems with Keen sizing but I read the reviews ordered a 10 instead of 10.5 and fit perfect. Look good and feel good.

I was worried that buying shoes online would not be wise. I have always had to try shoes on in the store, so it was with trepidation that I opened the box when the shoes came. I could not believe how comfortable they were. I wore them to work the next day, and have been wearing them everyday for 2 weeks. I will be ordering others in the future.

Darling, well constructed shoe. A must if you've had foot problems. I've had reconstructive surgery on both feet. Very picky about shoes. These are fabulous, plus they're stylish. Note, if you have skinny feet, these are not for you. Wide toe box and run about a 1/2 size large.

Love this shoe, fit is true to size and comfortable. Not the cutest look but yet very versatile

I bought these 2 years ago, so I know they run large. Bought a half size smaller, and they are perfect. For me they are the perfect shoe for work. I am on my feet all day, and despite bunions and previous surgeries, they are super comfortable. Oh, and the leather uppers are more flexible and textured than last time. It's a good look.

This mj is beautiful and a fabulous alternative to the Presidio tie shoe for occasions not lending themselves to a sneaker! Thank you Keen. and of course, Zappos, for the helpful phone discussions and quick turnaround when needed a different size. My best size in Keen Presidio is 6.5. tie shoe. The mj was too spacious so ordered 6.00. Find I cannot wear with full sock, but need only thin nylon ankle sock, trouser sock anyhow so works out well. The leather and color are exquisite. would encourage future buyers to go for it, keeping in mind I had to reduce a size because the width of the 6.5 was too generous. Other than that, an excellent choice and will probably, budget permitting, order more down the road.