Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

I'm a 10D & ordered a 10D: They fit in the toebox but were way too wide through the ankle & heel. Sort of Weird

I bought these the end of last year because I wanted a boot that was waterproof and laced up so they could be tight for snowshoeing. I got maybe 1-2 months use out of them. This year I am wearing them for work. By the end of the day my feet are soaked.and not from sweat. I gave them three stars because they are pretty comfy.

I purchased these boots assuming they were the same as the pair I purchased two years ago, that were perfect. These arrived looking the same but one shoe was tighter than the other and took a long time to soften up. I wore these in the lightly heated garage while I produced evergreen winter planters last night during 27 degree weather and the bottoms of my feet were freezing and very uncomfortable even with two pair wool socks on. I didn't have this problem with my last pair. Maybe a faulty pair, maybe someone forgot to put insulation between the foot bed and rubber sole? Just seemed like standing on a cold cement floor in two pair of wool socksnot what I expect from Columbia. Won't buy these again. Not sure if there was a design change but if there was, change it back.

Durable boots but not as cute as i was hoping. These have a wide boot opening, so if you need that these are perfect. Thick materials and strong laces. Comfortable, but feel a little clunky if that makes sense. I bought wide, 9.5 and they fit fine. I'm usually a 9.5 and 10 in certain shoes.

I ordered a 9W since I am usually between a 8.5 & 9, my foot runs a little wide and I thought that I could wear heavier/warmer socks. These boots were pretty, but had no shape within the boot, it felt very boxy. There was absolutely no arch support. I went to the store to exchange for a different size or model; the store had a newer version and I could not even get my foot into the 9 (very narrow). I tried some PFG sneakers and the 8.5 fit, but I did not like the color they had available. I really wanted these winter boots, but they were just not made for my foot.

I was very disappointed that the boots came in very late and was not able to wear it during my ski trip. The boots look good.

Well I just Hoping these boots would do the job, IT DOESN'T HELP!!!I live in the city of Chicago and I get cold FAST, my feet was so cold just walking to the bus stop and mind it's not even a full block to get there. I wear two pairs of socks one thin pair and a thick COLUMBIA sock, I'm thinking that it would do the trick NOPE NOT EVEN!!I HAD TO THAW OUT MY FEET.I SHOULDN'T HAVE TO GO THROUGH THAT AT ALL.Get more WIDE WIDTHS SIZES, TOTALLY NEEDED

I ordered my normal hiking shoe/tennis shoe size, and my toe was rubbing. (I wear a 7.5 sandal but 8 hiking shoe and ordered an 8). Absolutely no arch support. They were cute, but I never got to test out warmth or whether they were waterproof. I returned them.