Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

The size was true. I wear a 8.5 to 9 in regular shoes and I ordered a 9. My problem is I wore once in 20 degree weather and my feet were immediately cold. There is no cushioning in the soles and the boots are still. My feet hurt the entire time. The no cushioning in the soles may have contributed to how cold my feet were.

I didn’t get my refund after cancellation this order ?

Basic. Rather frumpy for street wear.

They feel heavy, cardboardie & cheap. No roll to walking in them. Badly trimmed "fur" around the top. Sending back!

I hated these boots except for the color- they felt too light and cheap and looked on par quality-wise with Walmart

I hated these boots - they felt too light and cheap and looked on par quality-wise with Walmart

Total disappointment here. I have another pair of cold/wet weather boots by Columbia which are the exact same size and fit perfectly, with thick socks. These are so cute, but just do not fit. They are going back.

These were so narrow! Despite super-thin socks the front half of each foot went numb after a few minutes of sitting in a chair while wearing them --- I didn't even take a step in these. I'd ordered a half-size larger after reading the reviews, which resulted in the length feeling like my normal shoe size. The toe area was roomy but the snugness at, and just behind the widest part of my foot, was problematic. They fit my full calves comfortably and were extremely lightweight. I asked Zappos to send me a return label, which took 10 business days to arrive. The boots got back to them in a much shorter time and my purchase price was credited back to my account in two business days. The entire process, from placing my order to the refund hitting my account, took about 3 weeks.

Too difficult to get your foot into the boot

i am not able to leave accurate review as these boots are NOT WARM .. the tag says insulated to -25 degrees and after a3-40- minutes on a non snowy 38 degree day my toes were freezing, even tho i had thermal tights AND warm socks on .. they should not be sold as warm and insulated .. maybe my pair is faulty . all i know is that my toes are frozen .. they are comfortable which is something i usually can;t say but completely disappointed and glad customer service was so helpful

I really wanted to like these boots as the price is amazing but they are too big and clunky and they squeak.

Uncomfortable boot..ordered 10-1/2...too short and there is no arch support...I would order an 11 but since there is no arch support I wont...thanks Zappos for your great delivery!

These boots are garbage. I wore them in the snow in Colorado. Not only were they not warm at all, but they also bled brown dye all over the place. I left a trail of dye through the snow and into our room. Terrible purchase.

I returned these boots after trying them on. If I laced them snugly the top of the boot folded in on itself and made painful pressure points on the top of my foot. If I loosened the laces so that this didn't happen, my heel came out of the heel cup and into the shaft with each step. I have narrow feet and high arches, but I'm not sure if this was why.