Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

Very cute for a big boot, but very limited arch support. Tread doesn't seem too all weather. Returned because I needed something to walk long distance in.

love these boots! cuter than the picture and very true to size and width, comfy! Very happy!

We are going to China in Dec. and temperatures will be freezing. My feet are unhappy in most shoes and I tried several pairs of boots before ordering these, and I think they will be great. I am narrow with a high arch and ordered my regular size. I added a firm but lightweight arch support and wore medium socks and after several hours of walking with these boots in the house they were great in every way: comfortable, warm, and with a good gripping sole. High recommendation!

Cute, warm, and a bit small... I have real trouble finding womens shoes that fit my long/wide feet. This is especially true for outdoorsy type shoes. It seems that manufacturers often think that women with long and wide feet should just buy mens shoes for outdoors activities... but I dislike the drab colors. These Columbias came close to working.. they are pretty cute even with the drab grey color. My daughter complimented me with them on as I tried them around the house. But alas, within 15 minutes my big toe was pressing against the front, and the sides of my feet tingling from the tight fit. So, they will be returned (3rd in a row). For someone they fit, they're light, nice looking, and seem very warm and comfy.

I was looking for a lightweight, reliable winter boot. This one fits the bill. Cute, comfortable, warm and solid on my feet. I took the advice of previous buyers - perfect fit. Looking forward to wearing them!

These boots are awesome! When I bought them, I tried them on, they fit, so I put them back in the box to save for a January trip to New York. I am in New York now (Jonas 2016) and we have had snow ever since we got here. I have worn them for the last three days - all day, walking miles each day. They never rubbed a blister, they never made my feet hurt, and my toes never got cold. My feet normally stay cold because I have Raynaud's disease. I highly recommend them and am very glad I bought these. I will say, however, that I bought them online somewhere else and paid less - but they are definitely worth the full price!

I love these boots! They are warm and comfy. I usually wear a 6.5, and I ordered them in a 7 - they have a nice roomy toe area so they fit thick socks. I have problem feet (wide flat feet and arch pain) and these are nice and cushy, like wearing combat slippers. I also have wider calves, so I like that they lace up and can fit over or under pants/leggings. I will be testing them in snow during the east coast blizzard coming this weekend! I also purchased the Columbia Minx Mid II Omni-Heat and I prefer these - I purchased both pairs in the same size and these definitely feet true to size while the Minx feel too small.

These boots are amazing - I live in Boston and these are great for commuting. They keep my feet warm and dry in typical New England weather. I have a pair of hardcore boots to wear during unusually horrible weather (mostly just blizzards) that are heavy and clunky and not at all cute. These are a great compromise, they are really cute, were immediately comfortable and keep my feet nice and warm.

These boots are great! They are very comfortable and look fashionable too. They lace up on me a lot tighter than they look in the photo and they make my feet look nice and small. They are warm and do not let the wet in.

Wanted to share how comfy these boot are! I put them on the first day and didn't take them off for 5 hours. Very comfortable, I did decide to go a half a size up after reading some of the other reviews. Even though I don't wear thick socks with the boots, I just wear thin cotton socks I feel like they fit perfectly. Highly recommend them for cold weather and snow.

These are gorgeous boots! In fact, I love them so much, I ordered a pair for my mom for Christmas. She will love them too! They are very fashionable and keep my feet warm at high school football games in Pennsylvania.

Love these boots! I'm a size 12 and these were first winter boots I have tried that fit comfortably and with room to wear winter socks. Large enough space for your toes ?? I have the extra long second toe, and many times, that precludes me from shoes, boots, sandals from fitting correctly. I'm only returning because I live in SoCal and my needs are more for Apr s ski boots or for some snow conditions when I head to the mountains. These boots would have been great for trekking the cold/snowy winter campus I went to as a college student in Michigan, however, can't say how warm they would keep my feet - seem like they would do the job.

Sizing recommendation up front: Suggest ordering up a 1/2 size for socks or a whole size if you want to add your own insoles or like thick socks. Arch support: be advised these don't have outstanding arch support. Order full size up if you need arch support or want to add inserts of your own. I hate thick, scratchy socks so I wear thin socks and ordered a 1/2 size up and still have comfortable wiggle room. I wanted boots that were warm and dry for rain and snow and didn't want anything too heavy or chunky. These fit the bill. We've had a wet and cold winter so far and these haven't let me down. Bonus: they are as cute as winter boots can ever be-I've received compliments every time I've worn them.

I have worn these boots daily since they arrived. I find them as comfortable and warm as slippers. However, like slippers, there is little arch support. We have not had any significantly bad weather since I got them so cannot attest to their waterproof status. I ordered a size 9, which is what I usually wear, and there is plenty of room for warm socks.

Comfortable, warm, so far have been waterproof. Was really happy they had them in 10.5, I have such a hard time finding shoes that fit well . Ready for the snow in Chicago in winter!

Outstanding boot! Buy, buy, buy. :) They're snug, warm, comfortable, easy on and off, great look. I get compliments all the time. I love, love, LOVE Columbia products!

Stylish, warm and waterproof. Easy to slip on and off for a quick trip outside with the dogs. Kept my feet warm in the snow, and tread is great for walking on ice. Look great with my skinny jeans on dry autumn days.

Love these boots! Sat through a football game that was FREEZING and my feet were the only part of me that stayed warm. Comfortable! Little bit slippery.

I am so pleased with these boots! I like to try footwear on before I purchase but it is difficult to find snow boots in Texas. I took the advice of the reviewers and ordered a half size larger than my normal size and these boots are perfect! They are extremely comfortable and very easy to take on and off. They are cute looking and will be perfect for our winter trip to Wyoming.

Zappos sent me (in record time!) six pairs of boots that I thought might work for me. Four of them had soles so rigid that my heels lifted up when I walked. The fifth had laces that stopped about two inches below the tops of the boots. Fortunately, the Ice Maiden boots by Columbia fit perfectly and I had none of the issues that I experienced with the other boots. I am SO delighted that Zappos will take back the five pairs of boots that didn't work out!!

I love this boot. I had to return for a half size bigger but love the boot. Not too bulky for. Y 5' stature. Highly recommended!

Very comfortable, true to size! Can't wait to see how they hold up in a NY winter.

Because of the other reviewers, I ordered 1/2 size larger. Glad I did, lots of room for toes and thick socks. Really cute and warm, waterproof, too.