Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

When I received my boots I was at ahhhhh! The fit was perfect and I would recommend people to shop at zappos.com. I wouldn't change using them. I am looking for my next purchase now.

I received these boots the other day and was really pleased with how cute and comfortable they were. I ordered .5 size larger than what I normally wear and that was definitely a good decision. When I wear them with thick socks they aren't too tight but when wearing them without they aren't too big. Perfect. They didn't come up as high on the calf as I was expecting, but that's okay. I can't give a review on how they are actually in the cold and snow, but the other reviews say that these boots worked out well in the elements.

I live in Rural Montana and love Zappos for delivering right to my porch.... Always quick service....for these boots I hope the snow doesn't fly too soon but I will be loving these boots when it does :) Have worn them around the house , feel,good! I am always a 9.5 in shoes and I ordered a 10 and am thankful to the other reviewers for suggesting that.... A cute boot!

I needed a pair of boots to replace another pair from a well known outdoor apparel company that literally fell apart this past winter. After doing a bit of research I chose the Columbia Ice Maiden II. They are comfortable and stylish and easy to slide on with a normal weight pair of socks. I think I am going to be very comfortable this winter in these boots for dog walking and getting to work . The tread seems like it will grip well in icy conditions , heavy snow, and cold which we can experience during a typical New England winter.

Light in weight, very comfortable and warm. Fits my orthotics well and can wear with a thin or thick sock and still comfortable. Thumbs up for me!

Boots run true to size. I generally wear a 9.5, and I ordered these boots in a 9.5. I have just enough toe room to wear thick socks, though the boots will fit great with thick or normal socks. The boot is a little bulkier than what I thought it would be, but they are still attractive enough, especially for snow boots and the price. Seems like these boots will be great to walk through heavy snow during winter, though I haven't yet worn them in icy/snowy conditions.

Love them- durable, cute & comfy. They are a bit clunky- not too clunky but sometimes they are too warm in the winter. Def waterproof though which is an advantage in the pac now! :)

I absolutely love these! They are comfortable and very warm! They are also cuter in person. I ordered a half size larger because I knew I'd be wearing thick socks. They fit perfectly with the thick socks! They keep my feet warm and dry in the rain and snow. I ordered the brown and would order them again!

I love these boots! Warm, comfortable, and cozy. Maybe a little big but I wear thick socks with them and no problem. Nice looking, too.

I could not possibly recommend these boots more! They are absolutely the best. They are cute, comfortable, and waterproof. They are exactly the boots that I needed. I am plus size so I have wide calfs, they fit no problem. The face that they come in half sizes is great, because I am a true 10½ and wide footed. I have worn these since November, in every weather condition in Michigan that you can imagine. My feet are comfortable and warm all day. I wear them all day long in the office. I love these boots!

Very comfortable and very warm. I wanted a boot that would go with anything and wasn't too over the top with varying colours and textures. I really like the style of these boots and they fitted within my price range. I have large calves, so I needed a boot that laces rather than zips. The laces are long with room to wrap around your ankles. If I want to funk it up a little, I change the laces to store bought 45" or 60" red or purple laces. Or whatever color I feel like!

Very comfortable, I've had no problems walking in them for any length of time. They keep my feet quite warm as well. I haven't had any problems with the arch support that others have commented about either.

These boots are easy to "break in" and comfortable all day long! They withstand weather and puppies too.

These boots are perfect for my Xmas trip to Sun Valley, Id., where it gets down to -20 at night. They are comfortable, and fit great using my orthotics (taking the foot bed out of the boot first). Great style, as well. I ordered 9.5, although I wear a 9, to allow for thicker socks.

I love this boot! I was not sure what to expect but after the temperature dropped below freezing I was able to put these to use. I work outdoors and these are so comfortable, warm and very cute! (Bonus!) I used the size chart and measured with socks, ordered the 8's and threw in some arch supports after reading reviews stating they needed it. I have walked miles and stood for hours in the cold and my feet were the happiest part of me, comfy and warm!

These boots were more comfortable than I expected them to be. I ended up wearing them all day instead of trading them out for my shoes when indoors. And they looked cute besides. I'd buy them again!

These boots were wonderful: light weight, easy to put on and take off, lovely. Unfortunately, while the length was true to size, I decided I needed a wider width, which wasn't available in these boots. So, if you wear a true 8.5 B, they would be great.

They are very comfortable, and fit perfectly, the only thing is that there isn't much arch support so I'll have to get gel insoles.

I am writing a review of this pair of snow boots in mid-October, so I am not fully qualified (yet) to comment on their performance. But for what it may be worth -- coming out of the box they appear nicely designed, tough, extraordinarily lightweight (given their anticipated performance as waterproof winter boots), and really cute as the dickens. If they end up leaking and drafty once the dreaded polar vortex returns to Chicagoland, I promise to return to this space and write something scathing. But for the time being, I would assume the best. And come on, it's Columbia Sportswear, I've never had an item from them perform poorly. Fit/comfort is fine, slightly large to accommodate big socks but not sloppy large; I'd be careful though if you need a lot of arch support.

They fit true to size; I ordered a half size larger to fit my thickest socks, and they are perfect. Have not had the chance to try them in the snow yet though, so no news on their waterproof-ness. They are, however, very light, toasty, and comfortable. I wore them around my apartment to test them out and I didn't want to take them off!

I normally wear size 10. Bought 10.5 just in case. Glad I did. Haven't had a chance to wear them yet since it's still warm. They are comfy from when I tried them on. And I purchased the grey ones and they are cute, picture doesn't do them justice.

I bought these boots for my daughter-in-law, who lives in Colorado. She loves them! She said they're very stylish & will come in really, really handy when the snow starts falling.

Just too short in the left toe box for comfort.

These boot were fine except the toe box was a little too tight for my bunions. The boots I kept had a wider toe box and were more flexible feeling. These were very warm…. Even warmer than the ones I kept. They would be good for people who have normal feet!