Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

While these are very cute boots, the toe box is not wide enough for me especially on the right foot, where I have a bunion. The position of stitching also where my foot bends at the base of the big toe only irritates it. Had to return.

These are super cute, warm, and comfortable!!! After reading other reviews, I was worried about getting the right size but they just ran a little small, maybe a half size. I am normally an 8N and I ordered the 8.5M and they fit great with room for warm socks. I can see that the width might be an issue for some but if your foot is narrow at all, these are great!

My wife just opened the gift and loves them! They fit well and are comfortable. Time will tell about the durability.

These boots are warm, comfortable and cute! I bought a pair. Two of my friends bought these too, we all sized UP 1/2 size. Now they are comfortable with thick socks and a more supportive insole.

I loved the way these boots looked, but they are not for someone who needs a wide toe-box. Was so sad to have to return them.

These are a lot cuter than I expected them to be. I got the ruby color. They are very warm and have good grip on the bottom. The only problem is that I have a bunion on one foot and it is rubbing against the top of the boot. Otherwise, they are very comfortable.

These were so narrow! Despite super-thin socks the front half of each foot went numb after a few minutes of sitting in a chair while wearing them --- I didn't even take a step in these. I'd ordered a half-size larger after reading the reviews, which resulted in the length feeling like my normal shoe size. The toe area was roomy but the snugness at, and just behind the widest part of my foot, was problematic. They fit my full calves comfortably and were extremely lightweight. I asked Zappos to send me a return label, which took 10 business days to arrive. The boots got back to them in a much shorter time and my purchase price was credited back to my account in two business days. The entire process, from placing my order to the refund hitting my account, took about 3 weeks.

Whenever i buy any winter boots, they are always too tight so i bought a full size bigger than my shoe size and these are perfect. I love the feel of them when i walk and they are not tight at all.

These looked really cute on screen, but just looked odd right out of the box because they seemed too short on me even though I'm only 5'4". I still tried them on but decided immediately to return them because I felt unbalanced walking on them. I don't know if the soles are uneven or what, but wearing these boots felt a little like wearing ice skates - like the sides of each soles were shorter than the middle part, so that each foot wobbled from side to side as I walked.

Nice

I bought a pair of these for my daughter for Christmas and she absolutely loves them. She wears a 6.5 and the boots fit perfectly and are so adorable. Since my daughter lives in another country, I decided to order a pair for myself in size 8. We can be twins on occasion. Again, perfect fit. I've already walked all over Chicago in them and they are super comfortable and plenty warm on a cold winter day. The picture of the Shale/Dark Raspberry in the listing doesn't really show that the quilted part of the boot is ever so slightly purple compared to the gray of the rest of the boot. It's very subtle but definitely a purple tone. I love that color combo but just wanted to make sure buyers are aware that dark raspberry does have a purple cast. The faux fur is just at the collar of the boot but the interior of the boot feels so soft and cozy that I had to double-check that the fur didn't go all the way in. So comfortable! My daughter, who lives in a much colder clime, has been wearing her boots to walk to work everyday and thinks they're awesome. She leaves them on all day! I highly recommend this boot and the price is great!

Love these boots, and, my husband thinks they are very stylish!! I was looking for a boot to keep my feet warm and cozy while walking our dogs in drizzly Pacific Northwest winter weather and ordered two pair to try: the Columbia Ice Maiden and the Ugg Knesset boot. I liked how the Kness boot was ankle high, had a cushy insole, and a defined heel...however it was a little cramped on my cranky bunions. The Ice Maiden doesn't have enough arch support (as mentioned by other reviewers) as I need but replacing the insole with another solved that problem nicely. I generally wear size 8-8.5, ordered an 8 in this boot and it fits perfectly with enough room to wear a bit thicker sock if I choose. The final choice was determined by the beautiful red color, warmth and waterproof quality of the Ice Maiden.

I just got these boots. They LOOK good. I haven't tried them out yet. I need boots that will allow me to walk over a mile to work and then wear all day long in and outside of buildings. These books seem to fit the bill. They aren't too heavy. And they look like they will be comfortable to walk in. I am a little worried about them letting in dampness at the tongue. But time will tell. I ordered half-a-size up and the boots fit nicely with thick socks.

I haven’t actually worn these outside but like others say, loved them the minute I put them on. So glad to have warm, waterproof affordable boots for when the snow comes!

After trying 5 or 6 different pairs of snow boots (including, LL Bean, Sperry, Sorel), I finally came across these and they are extremely comfortable. Most of the others were so uncomfortable that I didn't want to walk in them for 5 minutes, let alone all day. I haven't worn them in the cold yet, but I feel like they are going to be just fine. I normally wear a size 9, which is what I ordered and they fit great.

Great looking boot. I normally wear a 10N/S this runs short. I also ordered a the same boot in 10.5 and it fits great with 2 heavy sock. I gave a 4 star rating as it runs short. These are a keeper and look forward to wearing them in the snow.

These are cute, comfortable, and toasty! I got my regular size since I don't plan to wear extra thick socks with them and the fit is perfect.