Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

Perfect except for my bunion!!! Not wide enough to be comfortable due to my bunion.... Otherwise I loved the boots!!!

I needed a half size larger which was perfect, particularly with fat socks. These boots don’t have great support so I put my own insert in which did the trick. In the snow my feet stayed warm and dry, they are water proof and high enough no snow managed to get into the boots even in deeper snow. They are exactly what I wanted, and are not heavy despite the sturdy construction.

Great boot, especially for the price point. EXCELLENT service from Zappos!

Fit and size is great. Got my usual size (10W) and there's room for thick socks. The dark raspberry color is actually gray.

The boots are comfortable and I bought them for their waterproof capabilities

One of the rare items that comes 10.5 W to fit my orthotics. Style is ok - it’s more about having a boot for winter that fits.

I love these boots. I wear a 5.5 wide and they were tight. I returned them and order the size 6 wide. I can’t wait for them to get here. The style is current and there are several color choices.

I’m not in great shape, I’ll admit that. I have a sedentary job and I don’t get to work out like I’d like to. My feet are a point of contention always. My right foot is especially bad, and long walks are torture. So I bought these hoping for comfort but not expecting a whole lot. I was wrong. I walked over 5 miles with my 24lb baby strapped to my back on vacation and my shoulders are sore, my back is a little worse for the wear, but my feet? I could have gone 10 more miles in these boots! I want them in a regular shoe now for everyday wear! I didn’t even have to wear them in, they were perfect right off the bat. I highly recommend these!

We tried a similar pair but they were slip on boots and they were too hard for my 10 year old daughter to get on her feet. So I got these with laces. They work great. They are so cute and warm.

Size and fit were great!! Best online shoe purchase I’ve ever made.

Absolutely LOVE them. This is the first pair of boots that have kept my feet warm, even in 6” deep snow on trails and through deeper drifts. They grip pretty well on icy sidewalks and are surprisingly lightweight. I went up half a size from my normal size 10 and they feel just right with athletic socks. I initially went for lower cut boots but I’m very pleased with how easy these are to get on and off. They are plenty comfy, but the insoles pop out easily if you want to replace them with orthotic inserts. The faux fur cuff is cute with leggings and bootcut pants fit easily outside them. If they came in larger sizes I think my husband might buy a pair because I brag about them so much!

These don't quite seem the same quality as some other Columbia products I own, but I am thrilled that they are wide enough to accommodate my giant calves. They are also warm, which is important for Wyoming winters. I haven't test the waterproof quality yet so I will update after our next snow storm. Not great arch support, but the wide size is sufficient for my inserts. They are also light! I think it was a good value and am happy with my purchase.

These snow boots fit like a pair of comfortable tennis shoes. They are very cute and cozy warm. No break in time, and easy to pull on. No more cold feet in the snow. ?

It fits well and looks nice.

Fit is good. We don't have snow - yet. I will test them in the snow for warmth and for being waterproof. Interior is soft and comfy.

These boots are perfect for myself and my daughter. They fit well, are comfortable for walking all day, and keep feet warm. My daughter uses them daily during the winter months at college and I use them for travel which involves plenty of walking in cities. I just bought my daughter a second pair after wearing her first for almost 3 years. The original ones hold up great and look good, just a bit faded because she walks through mud, snow, and rain throughout the year.

I normally wear a 9N and a 9 1/2B boot felt too short so I ordered the 10, which is a bit roomy but easy on and off and very comfortable. They definitely keep your feet warm... it has been 13° here and I wore them on a one mile walk across a frozen lake and I wish my hands had been as warm as my feet! They were good in a slushy driveway and I have worn my Yaktrax on them in icy conditions. And all this in just one week! Definitely a keeper!

Super cute/stylish/functional! They felt true to size in length and a tad slender in width but not narrow. I'm a size 9.5, but ordered up a half size to a 10 to wear with thick socks. There is no side zipper, but the speed laces make them easy to pull on and pull off without having to redo them every time.

These are, hands down, the best snow boots I've ever owned. I'd had my previous pair for over six years, and thought they were keeping my feet warm and dry. Little did I know! These boots are snug, comfortable, and so warm, I don't even need to wear my thick winter socks when I go out to shovel snow. As a bonus, they're super cute! I can't recommend these boots highly enough.

These are gorgeous boots but they run really small - full size small! My daughter got the grey color and was a little hesitant as the descriptive color included "raspberry." However, we saw no trace of a pink/raspberry color in the boot. They are a stunning grey boot with a light grey fur. Very attractive and comfortable if you order a size up!

These are so cute!!! I ordered a half size larger than I would normally wear and they are perfect to put heavier socks in. Wide enough for my bunion. Not much arch but comfy. Can’t speak to warmth or wear yet but exactly what I expected. They look tiny and on sale you can’t go wrong! Buy them! I have a pair of Sorel Joan of Arctic and these are more comfortable for a lot less $

I wear a 7, ordered a 7 and they fit with normal winter socks (Smart Wool, nothing extra thick). I live in the PNW and we don't get ALOT of snow so I am wearing these when walking into town in the rain. My feet stay warm and dry and heck, they look cool too.

I followed other's recommendations to order a half size up, as they run small. Sure enough the fit was very good with room for my thick socks. My size would have been too snug. They are really cute, comfy and warm.

I like these boots a lot. It was hard for me to find a pair of winter boots that could handle New York weather but these have done well so far. My feet are medium width but long and flat so I’m always challenged in finding a shoes that are comfortable, stylish and can handle harsh winters. They are well made too. Hopefully they will last a couple of seasons with proper care.

I bought these for my 24 year old daughter as a Christmas gift. She just moved to Wisconsin over the summer and is facing her first winter there. She needed warm and waterproof boots, but she is super picky with shoes and has a hard to fit narrow and slight little foot. After reading all the great reviews, I decided to take a chance on these. It seemed the only negative reviews were people who thought they ran too narrow for them, but since we needed a narrow boot, it might work out fine. My daughter put these on her feet, adjusted the laces to fit her narrow calves, then has worn them every day since. No issue. Her feet are finally warm, and will stay dry during her treks to and from the bus stop. One happy mama here!