Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

I normally wear a size 8. After reading reviews I ordered 8.5. I think an 8 would fit as long as I only wore thin socks. The 8.5 is great. Comfort level for these boots is a 10!!!! They are cute. It hasn’t been cold enough for me to test the warmth factor. So so happy with these boots. Highly recommend them.

They fit great! I have proven that they are waterproof, they're warm, and they have a good tread. I have a high value for practicality and these boots met my standards. I have a somewhat narrow foot, and the laces allow me to make the boots fit nice and snuggly. They are definitely true to size--I got a 7.5 so that I would have room for thicker socks, and I usually get a 7.

GF wears 8.5 in shoes , got 9 and 9.5 and she says the 9.5 fit perfect . So I recommend going a full size up. They look way cuter in person, pictures don't do justice.

good fit very warm and looks great

This shoe is great. Fits true to size and width. Make sure if you have wide feet to get the wide width - I am usually an 8.5 in regular shoes and 9 in sneakers, and I tried 8.5 wide, 9 wide, 8.5 regular, and 9 regular, and the 8.5 wide fit perfectly. If it helps anyone who has a similar size foot, my foot is 4.25” wide. These shoes are very soft inside and comfortable. I wore them to VT in December and walked around for 5ish hours every day, and my feet were so warm. I can’t speak to the comfort of the existing insole though because I took them out and put my own. Overall, highly recommend

The fit and size are great. A little tough around the ankles, though, so perhaps wear a thicker sock.

My only complaint would be that the color said dk raspberry. The box arrived and says dk raspberry for color but the boots are all grey. Other than that, good service as always from zappos. I have wide feet due to bunions, but these boots feel wide enough and are very warm. I've been wearing them and am very pleased.

What a cute boot! It needs a little arch support so I would recommend buying something decent, especially if you have high arches like I do. Overall / I love the boot it’s very comfortable and super cute!

I love this boots they are great and warm. Size fits perfect. Zappos is great! They deliver on time and solved everything I asked for. Love Zappos ??

Cute, super comfortable and warm! Love them

These are very nice boots! However, they have a metal placket that runs down the front where you lace them up to provide strength and it runs right over a bunion I have on my big toe. Felt great on my right foot!

I have to say, this is my first order with Zappos, and it's a disappointment. The boots themselves? Cute! Skinny jeans and leggings tuck into them nicely. The height of them is nice for us larger-calved folks, they're a little shorter than halfway (I'm about 5'4", for reference). They felt cozy. If you're someone who needs a supportive arch, you'll need to add an insert (they're pretty flat). However, after seeing the "fits true to size", and ordering my usual size (6.5), I was disappointed that they seemed to fit on the smaller side. I should have ordered a 7. Doubly disappointing that they have gone out of stock in the 2 days since I ordered mine, and Zappos customer service can't even tell you IF they're going to be ordered again (I didn't even ask for a when, just some sort of confirmation that they still plan on carrying them. "just add your email to our notification list so we can let you know" isn't a helpful response). Any other shoe store I've bought from can at least check their system and say, "yes, this is a current style, which will be reordered." The only thing I can appreciate was the quick shipping and delivery with Zappos VIP/Prime. So I give the boots themselves 5??, but the zappos experience 2??.

Boots were easy to pull on once laces were loosened,. I have wide feet and the wide fit great. I normally wear a size 8 but I bought an 8 1/2 so I could wear heavier socks. This worked perfectly.

Lace up boots, but if you keep them laced loose, you can easily slip them on and off. Perfect for when I was really pregnant! Very cozy and comfortable--and I'm very picky about comfort.

The Columbia Ice Maiden™ II boots I ordered very comfortable & easy to wear. I love them! I would recommend these

Fast delivery! Great fit.

Be specific about your likes and dislikes. How was the fit and size? What does the material feel like? How awesome (or not) do you feel wearing them?

BEST winter boots ever! My feet stayed warm, dry and comfortable all day!!

The BEST boot I’ve ever owned! It’s stylish and looks great with leggings and they rock in the snow as my feet stay warm and dry.

Love these!!!!! So comfortable and warm!!!