Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

This boot was AMAZING! I was going on a trip where I would need some strong snow boots and these met the challenge, I would not take them off. They were warm, comfortable and gave a lot of support for my feet. I am totally in love with them. HIGHLY Recommend them.

I purchased these boots for my trip to Utah in December. I was concerned about buying a new pair of boots right before a trip because I knew we would be doing a lot of walking in the cold and possible snow. I was relieved to find that the boots were sturdy, had good support and also looked super cute. The were so comfortable, it felt like I was wearing slippers. Although it did not snow a lot, I did walk through some snowy areas and a very long walk at night in the cold weather and it was no problem, as my feet were warm and toasty. I did need to size up 1/2 size in order to wear them comfortably with heavier socks. Happy I purchased these!

The size is a little big, however the width is fine. The outer side keeps feet dry. The inside is toasty warm and fuzzy. They handle well in the snow. Good grip on the snow, didn't slip on the snow.

Columbia was a new brand for me and the only big boots I have to compare them to are 23 yo LLBean boots. The Ice Maiden II is not particularly attractive but had they fit, I'd have kept them. The 8W was a little too long and a little too wide even with heavy weight Smart Wool socks. They were also a little awkwardly high. They just didn't work for me.

I bought my regular size, but had to return it because it was too tight in the toe box even though I had the wide version. I reordered half a size up, again in the wide and it fits perfectly. I love the laces for a custom fit for wide calves. I haven't had a chance to test them outside yet, but I'm looking forward to wearing them this winter. They are much less clunky than my previous winter boots.

I added my high arch insole that I bought separately and now it is perfect. I ordered 1 size larger than what I wear in a regular shoe because I wanted to make sure I had room for insole and thick socks. feels roomy and I can walk for hours without pain.

These boots are so cute, but there is something in the boot that digs into the (outside) side of my ankle and it's very painful.

The boots are too small and I was terribly disappointed!

Fits great, just what I was looking for

Fits great

These boots are absolutely adorable! Ordering up 1/2 size was good advise. The only problem, there is no arch support. Moderate support would be acceptable, I don't need much. I'd need to purchase insoles and for a product in this price range and quality, I'll return them instead.

These boots checked all the boxes - warm, good traction, lightweight and cute. Didn’t feel clunky or like wearing moonboots. Unfortunately they were too large. I’m usually a 9.5 but have ordered a 9 and hoping they will fit.

they were very comfortable and was easy to get on.

I thought the fit was perfect and they looked great ... as in the pics ... I did return them because I'm usually buy a higher end boot with more support and I under-spent and felt the difference in comfort ... I have another pair of Columbia boots that are great but a half size too small.

Disappointed. Style is what I wanted but fit was too wide and not firm, supporting. Laced up as much as possible but left room for my foot to wander in the shoe unlike my Oboz.. Sorry Zappos, sending back.