Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

The sides of this boot were digging into my ankles just above the ankle bone even with thick socks. It was super uncomfortable and since its plastic round the heel and not just fabric there’s no way to break that in. Disappointed considering all the rave reviews. Will look for a diff brand.

Great value for a cute, waterproof boot. Wore in New York in the rain, walked for miles in comfort.

Perfect combination of style and comfort. Just waiting for the snow!

These boots fit true to size and are cozy and comfortable.

Purchased for my daughter who is a fussy footwear person. She is quite pleased with the fit, comfort, and aesthetic of this boot. She claims these keep her feet toasty and dry in the worst of conditions Chicago has to offer, and that is saying a mouthful considering the climate here .

The boot seems real warm and waterproof but I put them on to walk around the house and the sides of the boot dug into my ankle as i walked, even with thick socks. This is a bummer because the boot has such good reviews. I can't see this being resolved by wearing them more and I live in NYC so would have to walk in them a lot. Back to the drawing board.

Good basic snow boot, easy to put in and off. I wish they were a couple of inches taller for Mi. winters.

I LOVE these boots, even prettier in person (elk/black is gorgeous). They are really comfortable with excellent support and cushion and warm. They are lighter weight than they look. Highly recommend.

Best winter boots I have ever owned! I walk to work everyday and was looking for some comfortable but warm waterproof boots that were not ugly last winter when I found these boots. I bought the black last winter and wore them all winter. I got a lot of compliments on them as well. They always keep my feet warm and dry and are comfortable enough to wear for the entire day. I loved them so much that I have bought a new pair in khaki for this winter, even though my pair from last winter are still in great shape. Great boots!

I love these boots. I have problem feet and these felt great! Good support and fit. I love the fact that they can fit around my pants and lace up tight. Very warm. First day walking the dog in below zero temps and my feet stayed toasty warm.

Think these will be great for an upcoming trip to very cold weather! Not bulky. I first ordered my usual size as recommended but returned for 1/2 size up. I ordered a half size up and they seem to be just fine!

Think these will be great for an upcoming trip to very cold weather! Not bulky. I ordered a half size up and they seem to be just fine!

These are adorable boots, a GREAT value, and SO WARM! I ordered them a whole size too big (even with heavy socks) - my mistake, as I think a half size up would've been just fine if you are wearing thicker than normal socks. Buy these boots!

I like the boots fine. They are a good basic boot. I wish they were a couple of inches taller for MI. winters.

So, I bought these just to shovel the snow and take my little dog outside, but was pleasantly surprised when I tried them on at how cute they are. I was really looking for something with a zipper that I could easily slip on, but if I leave the laces loose, that shouldn’t be a problem. I take a 9.5 in a regular shoe/boot, but got the 10s so I can insert an insole (I have lots of foot issues) or wear thick socks. I will put these to the real test when I go to Poland on vacation in February. I would definitely recommend them based on comfort/appearance/fit, though.

Just got the Ice Maiden ll yesterday so I haven't really been out running around in them yet. I have a pair of tan Sorel Angels that are okay for warmth but I wanted a black pair of boots that are waterproof for when we go UTV riding this winter; as well as for everyday running around in the snow and cold of Wisconsin. I typically wear a 5 - 5.5 and ordered these in a black 5.5. I tried them on with a medium thickness sock and they fit perfectly. Upon walking around the house they felt very comfortable and light weight. My Sorels are heavier and compared to these new Ice Maidens ll were never this comfortable either. These Ice Maidens are really cute looking on and if they keep my feet toasty warm I'd say they will be a grand slam. Will update my review after I have had a chance to wear them in the snow and cold.

True to size, a little rough at the seams on the inside but feel overall very comfortable once on. Looking forward to our first snow

These are very comfortable in the toe box and around the calves, and this is coming from someone with wide feet and fuller calves - about 15" around. I am size 7.5 wide and I was able to fit comfortable in these in a size 8.5 regular. I am just not sure I like the style, and I also prefer taller boots for being out in the snow. Still debating but these are a good option for wide feet. There are very few choices among actual wide size snow boots that are waterproof. So, there is hope for people with wide feet with these boots.

Perfect fit - super comfy and a steal for the price!!