Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

Only worn these one time but I was excited that I could pull out the insole and insert my full and pretty high orthotics in! Used it to shovel snow, didn't really go out for a walk or anything. I am not sure if the sole will be grippy enough for WI weather based on the one experience, but, they are cute. I have thin ankles and even with tightening the laces as much as possible, the ankle shaft felt loose and did not grip by ankle as well as I would have liked. I don't think the average person will have that problem though. So far, so good.

Cute boot but it pinched my wee toes. I will return them (thank you Zappo's for your awesome shipping) and continue my search.

They are lightweight, super warm and very comfortable. They also look nice. I am very happy with the way they fit. I walked over a mile along a snowy sidewalk when I first wore them. They felt like sneakers! I have wide feet and the medium width in my regular size fit well.

Great boot, easy to put on, and excellent support. Saw all the great reviews, and they are true. Attractive enough for going into town, not just mud chores. Boot fits true to size. Glad they were on Cyber Monday sale!

I have the Ice Maiden slip on boot and love it so I thought I would try this style in a different color. I love this boot also. It looks cute, is pretty light for how rugged it is and is super comfortable. I only wish the soles had a little more grip like a hiking boot for slippery conditions. I ordered my regular size in a 9 and I thought it was a little tight with thick socks. So I exchanged them for half a size bigger and they fit perfect now. Great boots!

I love these boots! They are super cute. I wore them to work for about a week after I got them because it was cold and rainy. My feet stayed dry and warm but not too hot. They fit a little big. But I’m size 7-8 depending on the shoe. I got these in 7 1/2. I think the 7 would be too small. They’re a little stiff on the bottom. I kind of feel like I’m clomping a bit but they are comfortable for all day wear and don’t hurt my feet. I have plantar facititis and these boots don’t bother me which is really nice. I have been wearing them with regular crew socks so I think with thicker socks they would be more snug. I think they actually fit like they’re supposed to. From where my toe hits. They stay tied. These are great winter boots. I’m glad I bought them.

Ready for winter! These boots look great and feel comfortable.

Very comfortable boots! My daughter loves them and I got them for an excellent price.

They fit true to size and the material and construction feel sturdy. So far, they’ve also felt pretty supportive in the ankles. Super-soft on the inside! My only complaint, though not a prob for me, would be the lack of arch support.

These were at a good price on black friday and couldn't resist. They are comfortable and very warm in the Minnesota winter. I ordered a half size larger than my normal shoe size and they fit great.

Tested these out yesterday in a Buffalo snow storm. They were perfect! I went up a half size based on experience with other snow boots - I prefer to have them a little bigger so I can wear thick socks. They are a great fit! Not too big. They are really lightweight which is nice. You don’t feel too clunky walking around in the snow.

I love these boots. I took the advice of the other reviewers and ordered a half size up, and they fit perfectly. Very comfortable, no breaking in required. I got them for a trip to Michigan in winter, and they kept my feet warm (even with normal socks) and kept me from sliding around in icy, slushy conditions.

Love these -- I need to add an insole, as the support isn't quiiiiite there for me, but that's a small complaint. Great style, great comfort.

I usually wear shoes with a size of 23.5cm, and I thought I chose the right size. But actually it was much larger than I thought. So I decided to return and exchanged it with the one with a half size smaller (= 6.5). And it worked!

I ordered the cordovan color, which I though had a rust tinge to it on my screen. Well, not in reality! They are squarely brown. They are easy to put on or off. I was able to insert my orthopedic soles, which made them more comfortable. They are a little big bigger and stiffer than I had hoped but a good value and I decided to keep them.

Really cute, warm boots. Unfortunately, they hit me at exactly the wrong spot on the ankle bone. They bothered me just standing there, let alone walking. Sadly returned. I'd still recommend these boots to others if you don't have bony ankles! Don't forget to order a half size up.

These boots are great. Comfortable, sturdy, and warm!

Love this shoe...one of the best shoe decisions I have ever made...they are warm, comfortable, easy to slip on or off overall a Great purchase.

First ordered a 1/2 size bigger since I like to wear thick socks in winter but they were too tight and narrow. Returned and ordered a whole size higher and they still feel a little on the snug side. These seem to run small and narrow. Very cute and feel warm though. Wearing them around the house now to see if they feel ok before wearing them out. They’re so adorable but they are still pinching my pinky toes. If they stretch they should be ok... oh what to do!

I read the reviews and ordered one size up which let me insert my orthotic and the boots were perfect size and width ( I have a narrow foot). I wore a medium weight sock and my feet had plenty of room, support and warmth. Boots are cute, durable, warm, and waterproof too.

Loved the style, though they looked and felt cheaply made. The sizing was off. I'm usually between a size 9 1/2 - 10. The 10 was so big when I got up to walk around it slipped right off my foot. I was even wearing thick socks. I returned these for a higher quality boot.

I wear 8 or 8 1/2 and the 8 was a perfect fit. My feet are average width. I took these boots brand new to CO and walked about 10 miles in them, including 4 miles in the snow. They were comfortable, warm, and kept my feet dry. Definitely happy with my purchase.