Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

I recently returned a pair of snow boots that were a different brand, and more than twice as expensive. I decided to take a chance on these boots since the reviews were so good. So glad I did! Hands down these are the most comfortable snow boots I've ever worn!! They are very well made, fit like a dream and are nice and toasty warm.

I ordered 1/2 size larger per your guide. They fit perfect & are warm.

I wore these boots in the snow for a week and liked everything about them... comfort, width, warmth, flexibility, weight, and style. Then yesterday I wore them on my morning walk in heavy rain. They are definitely NOT waterproof! My socks got very wet. Either my pair is defective or the "waterproof" label refers to the soles and lower edges, not the tops that encounter rain. (That's not what "waterproof" means to me!) I'll probably keep them because I have Raynauds and they keep my toes from turning white and getting numb. And, in light rain my socks have stayed dry. Is there's a waterproofing spray I could use on the fabric tops.

I have really bad feet, and buying shoes is always major undertaking. I needed a pair of winter boots, and dreaded trying to find a pair that met my needs. I'd never purchased the Columbia brand before, but was happy when I discovered that these boots came in wide widths, and they had removable insoles. I thought that they just might be tolerable. After inserting my own custom orthotics and padding and trying them on, I was delighted that they were not only tolerable, but really comfortable! They are as comfortable as any other pair of shoes I own. I highly recommend these boots.

Very comfortable and warm. Stylish and not clunky. Good grip walking and don’t feel like I am carrying weights on my feet like other heavy winter boots. Light and cute.

These are cute boots, and I had really hoped they'd work out. Unfortunately, although the overall size was fine, the bottom laces pressed on my big toe knuckle, and I knew they'd have to go back.

The size and fit were spot on. True to size and easy to get on and off. They are warm and comfortable without being too heavy. I love these boots!

Great fit, quality, and true to size. I ordered a half size up at first thinking that I wanted enough room for thick socks. That was a mistake as they were too big and uncomfortable to walk in. I returned them and ordered my true size. They fit nicely and I am still able to wear thick socks with them. I just wore them out to shovel and they were very comfortable and warm. Nice tread too walking over icy patches. They also make my size 10 feet look smaller than they actually are, which I thought was impossible for any boot. I got the "raspberry"color but they are mainly dark gray which I prefer anyway.

FINALLY! I have been trying to find snow boots that fit me for about 5 years. My calves are thick and I have a Wide foot. These boots worked! Because they lace up the front they are adjustable around a big calf. If you've been looking for good snow boots, these are the ones! Warm, fit a wide foot & calf.