Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

My first pair was very comfortable but not waterproof so I bought a second pair hoping to exchange. The second pair was too tight/uncomfortable so I returned them chosing comfort over waterproofness. I am sorry I can't get both comfort and the waterproofness advertised, but don't want to waste time ordering a third pair!

Cute boot but too small.

Love these!!!!! So comfortable and warm!!!

I tried these on several times and with my socks I just couldn't get the fit . Sorry I had to return them.

I really liked the look, the height, and the warmth promised by these boots. Furthermore I read several recommendations and these were on every list. I have worn them several times and they are warm, and my feet get cold easily. Only problem was I needed to order them a half a size bigger to accommodate medium weight socks, Plus the toe bed was narrower than usual despite how they look on the outside. The size I normally purchase pressed on my big toes and made the boots very uncomfortable. Ordering a half a size bigger solved that problem, but they feel a bit too big on my feet. I can easily solve that problem by pulling the strings tighter before tying them. Overall, I love these boots.

Bought for my sister Xmas present. She loves them. She wears them to and from work, when driving in the car and when walking the dog. She claims they are the best boot ever. She has an average foot. Didn’t need wide or narrow but she likes arch support and she got it. I’m happy not to hear her whine about lack of good boots on the market. Totally surprised her.

Great boot, especially for the price! I live in west Michigan and these kept my feet warm and dry. I've had boots that performed the same as these (or worse) but for double the price. I did remove the insoles and instead put in a sheepskin liner (UGG) which I highly recommend doing (not because these are bad, but I do this to all my boots). It accommodated the liner which was important because while I don't have a wide foot, I do have a high instep. I will say these have average tread grip, but I find that to be true of a lot of brands (ice is ice) and I'm used to putting on Yaktrax. Happy with my purchase!