Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

Since I have a narrow foot, I should have ordered my usual size. I sized up from my usual 9 to a 9.5 and they were too loose even with a heavy sock. So unfortunately, I had to return them.

can wear a big cushy pair of socks with these

go a full size up if you want a pair of warm socks on for sure

I wasn't sure if I was going to keep these because the arch support was non existent. You would think it would feel like it does walking on a hard floor without shoes, but it managed to be worse. I kept them because they are very warm and stylish. If I wear them with a thick sock, then they don't seem to bother me so badly. I do not spend a great deal of time in them though. The wide is wide enough, which is hard to find in a winter boot!

For the price these boots are amazing! I did get 1/2 size larger so I can wear thicker winter socks and that was a good choice. They are extremely comfortable, no breaking in, not good arch support but so far it has not bothered my plantar fasciitis which is good. Definitely recommend. Bought this after returning Sorels that were giant and uncomfortable.

This is a beautiful boot, but too narrow and too small for me. They didnt' have wide width, which would have helped. Sending back.

Lightweight not clunky. Easy on and off. Grippers fit over these boot as easily as they go over sneakers. Waterproof in soggy southeast Alaska. Comfortable enough to wear inside.

Sadly, the boot felt half a size too small and the medium was very narrow across the mid-foot. They felt so uncomfortable, I couldn’t even tell if the arch might have been right or not. There is no way I can stand or contemplate walking in them and will return them. They were out of the wide width and I wouldn’t know whether getting a W would fix the half size too small feeling as well. Too much hassle to keep ordering and returning till it’s a good fit. On a bright note, they are pretty!

I really like the styling And I absolutely love how the laces move so easily through the loops. This makes for a very quick time to put them on! They are very sturdy and good quality.

Comfortable enough for long walks, and they keep me feet dry. I like my pair so much that I bought this pair as a gift.

These are a x-mas present yet to be tried on and worn but appear to be true to size and width

These feel great on my feet. They are light enough that I don't feel like I'm clomping around. They keep my feet toasty warm.

I got these to keep my feet warm and dry in winter. Where I live there's not much ice or snow, but winter cold can be miserable anyhow. Cold feet are no fun. I'm thinking that wont' be a problem any more, plus I can find somewhere with snow and visit without having to buy more clothes. I went up a half size just to make sure I'd have room for thick socks.

The boots were as advertized and fit perfectly. Unfortunately I misunderstood and thought the laces were elastic and they were not. I really wanted slip on boots so I am returning these.

These boots live up to the description. I am super happy with them. They’re warm and of good quality. I would definitely recommend these for winter. Oh! And they’re cute! ?

These are the warmest, best fitting, and most supportive winter boots I’ve ever owned! They are very lightweight with good “grip” on wet surfaces (I haven’t tried icy surfaces.) Very cute too!