Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

Got a pair of these several years ago & just wore them out! They are great in the snow & big enough to wear with heavy socks. Waterproof, durable, great for snowblowing & other outdoor activities. These are a must-have for cold snowy locations.

These are very nice boots! However, they have a metal placket that runs down the front where you lace them up to provide strength and it runs right over a bunion I have on my big toe. Felt great on my right foot!

I am thrilled with this purchase. The boots are good looking and very comfortable.

Toe box very narrow

I haven't wore them yet (no snow), but trying them on they feel really good, I can't wait to wear them in the snow!!!!

I live in Minnesota and was looking for a boot that was going to keep my feet warm and give me support/traction on my multiple daily walks and when I need to shovel. These do not disappoint! I have plantar fasciitis and these give me great support. The tread is perfect and my feet do not get cold! I was just on a walk in 5 degree weather and couldn’t be happier with these boots

I didn't keep the boots cause they're a touch too heavy for what I need. Buy this is a gorgeous shoe, well made, and a great price given the quality. Ideal for locales with real weather and snow. I would certainly buy a light boot overall from Columbia.

These ran a bit small / narrow but the main issue was that the stitching around the lace holes felt rough when wearing the boot. Size felt slightly short

Love these boots. Wore them for a week solid on a trip to northern Canada and they felt great the entire time. Was in light snow and cold temps and feet were cozy and warm. Wore them with ski-type knee socks. For our trip, I did not have to use the outfitter's boots because mine were so perfect. Also got some nice compliments on their appearance. Nice pick for this Florida gal who does not have much winter boot-experience.

These boots are super stiff and small-feeling to me. I have to return them because they are so uncomfortable. I am surprised because I usually love Columbia boots. I am bummed because the style is super cute. I wish these worked for me. I am usually a 6.5, but they are really tight.

I have to say, this is my first order with Zappos, and it's a disappointment. The boots themselves? Cute! Skinny jeans and leggings tuck into them nicely. The height of them is nice for us larger-calved folks, they're a little shorter than halfway (I'm about 5'4", for reference). They felt cozy. If you're someone who needs a supportive arch, you'll need to add an insert (they're pretty flat). However, after seeing the "fits true to size", and ordering my usual size (6.5), I was disappointed that they seemed to fit on the smaller side. I should have ordered a 7. Doubly disappointing that they have gone out of stock in the 2 days since I ordered mine, and Zappos customer service can't even tell you IF they're going to be ordered again (I didn't even ask for a when, just some sort of confirmation that they still plan on carrying them. "just add your email to our notification list so we can let you know" isn't a helpful response). Any other shoe store I've bought from can at least check their system and say, "yes, this is a current style, which will be reordered." The only thing I can appreciate was the quick shipping and delivery with Zappos VIP/Prime. So I give the boots themselves 5??, but the zappos experience 2??.

These are very nice, but they were too small for me. Too short in the toe as well as too narrow and they were a wide with. I have to return them.

Just got them so I haven’t officially tried them out in inclement weather, but the feel was great. And they are very cute; hate to think about messing them up and snow and slush!

Very comfortable. Keep feet warm without making them sweat. Stylish. Good for walking. Appear to have good traction. Pleased. These are available in a wide width.