Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

I'm a true size 10.5 wide. It's frustrating for me to find shoes and boots because oftentimes the half sizes run out after size 9. This is my second pair of Columbia boots and I have enjoyed both purchases.

Oh my gosh! I was pleasantly surprised how comfortable these boots are! I love them and they keep my feet super warm!

Comfy right out of the box! I will probably add arch support because of my very high arches, but the boot seems to have modest arch support as is. I usually wear a 9.5 in Keens, and after reading reviews, ordered a full size up and wide width in these boots since I have never worn this brand before. With the thick socks I intend to wear for winter cold, the fit is perfect.

Very comfortable and not a heavy boot

this boot size 7 was too small with thick socks. I usually am a size 7 or 7.5

I bought a size 9.5 because I planned to wear the boots with thick socks, but they were so wide that I could not tighten them enough to keep my foot from moving around. I liked the boots, and thought about trying a smaller size, but I get tired of returning things.

I normally wear a size 8. After reading reviews I ordered 8.5. I think an 8 would fit as long as I only wore thin socks. The 8.5 is great. Comfort level for these boots is a 10!!!! They are cute. It hasn’t been cold enough for me to test the warmth factor. So so happy with these boots. Highly recommend them.

Great boots. I wear orthotics, and I was able to fit them in to the boot. Super comfortable and able to lace up so that snow doesn't get inside.

I had to replace some sorrels that are warm and waterproof but rubbed the crap out of my right foot. I tried everything and decided just gotta bite the bullet and replace. I decided on these based on reviews, price and was super excited to see a winter boot available in half sizes! I wear a 6-6.5M just for reference. After I ordered 6.5M realized that it fit just perfect but without room for uber-thick socks-I am a total crybaby when it comes to winter. I ordered half size up in the olive which is super subtle but a nice change from my usual black. I have room for socks without feeling clumsy or heavy. Only dilemma now, I have always had boots with side zippers and wondering if I am gonna regret laces other than that super cozy!

I wanted an insulated, waterproof boot that looked good, and this fits that bill. I ordered a wide width, but found that the right boot was still a bit snug on the side. I will keep them and wear thinner socks.

They fit great! I have proven that they are waterproof, they're warm, and they have a good tread. I have a high value for practicality and these boots met my standards. I have a somewhat narrow foot, and the laces allow me to make the boots fit nice and snuggly. They are definitely true to size--I got a 7.5 so that I would have room for thicker socks, and I usually get a 7.

Small

The size feels roomy, the fit a bit narrow, and the arch support is quite minimal, not to say non- existent. However there will be room for adding a sole inside the boots, and that is needed. They are not heavy, easy to lace, warm especially around the ankle, but not so much the toes, flexible when walking and add a bit of height with their thick outsole. Now for their looks, at first I thought the wrong model was delivered: I wanted the one that was clearly bicolor brown and ' grapefruit ' yet received an entirely brown model... Taking a photo, some pale pinkish hues appeared in the right spots, so I guess this model is one of those 'not as photographed' items. As these shoes are needed now, I will not return them but am disappointed--- or maybe perplexed if, with use, the bicolor scheme I wanted eventually appears. I think that with thick socks and an insole, they will be satisfactory, if not for the color scheme. Durability TBD -- just received.

Hurt my ankles as soon as I tried them on. These are impossible to walk in for a few feet to try out - instant rubbing against both side of ankle bones. Too bad as they are super cute. Also no support whatsoever.

No arch support, not very comfortable

GF wears 8.5 in shoes , got 9 and 9.5 and she says the 9.5 fit perfect . So I recommend going a full size up. They look way cuter in person, pictures don't do justice.

Based on the positive reviews, I really thought these would work for me. But I found them too clunky and not comfortable in part because my heels slipped in the wide width.

Terrible fit. I ordered these in WIDE and they were STILL too narrow. I ordered another pair that was a half size larger in regular width, and they were too large. Super weird sizing issues, which was really unfortunate because these boots seemed very warm with good support.