Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

I had major foot surgery and needed a quality supportive boot that I could get my swollen post operative foot into during the winter months. I have a high instep and the tongue on the boot was wide enough that I could easily slip my foot in then lace up and have my foot fully supported to walk and shovel snow. Very happy with my purchase.

It is good. No Complaint.

I ordered these in wide, but they were still too narrow. The insole was removable, so I was able to put my own arch support in. They were cute and seemed like they'd be warm. But being too narrow for a Wide boot was a deal breaker. I had to return them. I found a pair of mens Merrell insulated boots at another retailer that worked. If you don't have a wide foot and want to add your own insoles, they'd be worth a try.

I loved this style and the quality was excellent. I have some anomalies with my left foot. Unfortunately, the toe box on this shoe is too tight, so I can't wear them.

My toes hurt

Just got back from a 3 mile walk through a 1 foot deep, wet, heavy, slushy, snowy walk. These boots performed amazingly well. Highly recommend! They look good too. And very comfortable as well.

Fit and size were okay, but the boots felt stiff and uncomfortable, with very little cushion or warmth. This is a common failure of many, many boots.

Roomy and easier to walk in the snow, but my feet get very cold even with appropriate socks on.

The wide option is not the best boot for someone with a wide foot. I imagine the regular is great for someone with a narrow foot, and the wide is best for someone with regular foot width.

Very comfortable, i wear an 8 ordered 8.5 so i could wear wool socks works perfectly and still have room to wiggle toes.

This could be a really comfortable boot if I order a half size larger. It isn't bad, and maybe if I wear them in they'll be fine but I think 1I2 size up will work better. I have wide feet and it is sometimes not clear how that works with different shoes or companies.

Cold and snowy winter days don’t keep me inside with these boots on my feet. I wear them for winter work out walks, casual outings and running errands. These boots are practical and stylish. I’ve had these for a couple of years and they are my go to boots. Warm and dry feet are a must in our cold, snowy weather and these boots are perfect. So comfortable too!

I returned (my first purchase ever, of Columbia) Ice Maiden™s because I'd ordered "D - Wide", but when received: the box, and the tags did not have "-W", or any indication of Wide width. Trying them on, I could feel that they were not Wide width. Box tag does not include USA size 12. [If I'd've known this was a EUR shoe, I wouldn't've purchased;—EUR Size 43 is too snug on my 12 USA size foot; (and size 44 is too large).] Low arch support.

The soles are very stiff and the inside surface is very very firm. I'm going to get some fuzzy insoles. Overall the boot is nice, but the comfort level is not what I was hoping for.