Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

I bought these last minute for a January trip to Norway, and they worked great! Uber warm. My feet never got cold but also did not overheat when I wore them on the plane (trying to pack light). They were also very comfortable for city walking and touring. I wore them everywhere! True to size and easy to break in.

Too heavy for extended walking.

I had to try on many a boot and these are a WINNER. Great for dog walks, they give enough support and also the waterproofing needed. Very comfortable and cute to boot.

I wear an 8-1/2 to a 9. These were a 9 and my toes touched the end. I returned them

Great snow boot!! Wore them all day in the snow and never felt cold or wet. They were comfortable and warm. Great looking !! Wear size 10 and got size 10

So these came close to being ok, but the wide width just worried me a bit. Rather than feel roomy, they were a tad squeezing the sides of my foot. I also wish they had a zipper to ease taking them on and off, but that wasn't a deal breaker. I just was afraid to keep these and always feel the squeeze. If I knew they would loosen up, I may have kept them. I no longer buy shoes hoping they'll get better. I've had years of disappointments in shoe widths and wasn't willing to take a chance.

I love, love, love these boots. They were comfortable from the moment I put them on. There is plenty of room in the toe, something I often have trouble with. They are cute, warm and the laces stay tied which is a definite plus. I couldn't be happier with this purchase and I am tempted to purchase a pair in a different color.

These boots are fabulous BUT are just too warm for me. Fit is great. The style is awesome and looks great with pants tucked in.

I ordered 5 different snow boots (Sorel, Bogs and Columbia) and these were by far the most comfortable. They are relatively lightweight for a snow boot (which I like) with plenty of room inside for warm socks

I had on thick socks and felt very comfortable in these boots. Insulation in the boots was great my feet were very warm.

Was looking for a pair of winter boots for a trip to Chicago and NYC. I'm planning to do a lot of walking and wanted a pair of really comfortable, yet effective boots to keep me warm and dry. I'm a size 6 regular, but often buy 6.5W so I can place insoles with arch support. I also wanted to accommodate for slightly thicker socks. I purchased a 6.5 regular and 6.5W. The 6.5 regulars are perfect. Walking in these provided the sturdiness, grip, and comfort I was looking for. I even took them on a 2 mile walk during a downpour and my feet were fine. The 6.5W gave me more room in the toe box, but the tongue of the boot was bunching up too much. Based on the other reviews, I'm hoping they'll do well in the snow. I am very happy with the purchase so far.

Only walked around the house in them and they feel great! No wishing for snow but ready if and when it comes.

Normally, I wear an 8-8 1/2. I had to order a half size up and a wide width. I also bought arch support inserts as I have high arches and it helped to make the boot fit better. The 9 medium were too narrow. These boots are great for lots of snow. They are a bit heavy, but are comfortable. The tread is decent, but still be careful on ice.