Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

I love this boot. I had to return for a half size bigger but love the boot. Not too bulky for. Y 5' stature. Highly recommended!

Very comfortable, true to size! Can't wait to see how they hold up in a NY winter.

I liked the gray color with the pop of fur at the top. They looked good on me. But they are stiff and the construction feels cheap. I think they are a good value for the price. But I chose to return them. I am looking for something to wear walking my dogs during the winter, and I didn't think they would be comfortable on a long walk.

Really loved these, and would keep them but I think I would get too warm in them. I wear thick socks and usually have hot feet. These were just too stuffed to begin with.

I generally wear a size 10 in a wide, so I went up to 10 1/2 in these since they are medium width. They feel like a comfortable size 10W. I can wear average thickness socks easily, but the super thick woolen socks may create a snug fit for me. I got the Shale/Dark Raspberry-- which is just an allover gray with a dark pink logo on the tongue in front. These boots are surprisingly lighter weight then expected. I've been wearing a pair of Timberland Womens Mt. Hope Mid boots for the past several winters (which are great looking, nice quality & warm but have always been too narrow, even with them being labeled wide!)...but those Timberlands are heavier in comparison. These Columbias are my first ever, they are really cute and freakishly warm. I do have a fuller, muscular calf then average, but these look and feel quite nice on them. I can tuck jeans with ease into them, or wear leggings.

Because of the other reviewers, I ordered 1/2 size larger. Glad I did, lots of room for toes and thick socks. Really cute and warm, waterproof, too.

These are lightweight and comfortable, and as an added bonus, they are quite cute! I usually wear a 10 and ordered a 10 1/2 after reading the reviews, I am glad I did because the 10 1/2 is perfect. The height and shape of these perfectly accommodates my large calves, as well. I think these look nicer than the slip-on version without the laces, but I suppose if you were going to wear pants over them, the one without laces would be fine. I want to show them off so will wear them with pants that can go inside the boot, plenty of room for that, nice loose (and also adjustable) top. Don't hesitate, these boots look really nice and are well insulated for the cold months ahead! Nice sticky treads, too!

When I received my boots I was at ahhhhh! The fit was perfect and I would recommend people to shop at zappos.com. I wouldn't change using them. I am looking for my next purchase now.

I received these boots the other day and was really pleased with how cute and comfortable they were. I ordered .5 size larger than what I normally wear and that was definitely a good decision. When I wear them with thick socks they aren't too tight but when wearing them without they aren't too big. Perfect. They didn't come up as high on the calf as I was expecting, but that's okay. I can't give a review on how they are actually in the cold and snow, but the other reviews say that these boots worked out well in the elements.

I live in Rural Montana and love Zappos for delivering right to my porch.... Always quick service....for these boots I hope the snow doesn't fly too soon but I will be loving these boots when it does :) Have worn them around the house , feel,good! I am always a 9.5 in shoes and I ordered a 10 and am thankful to the other reviewers for suggesting that.... A cute boot!

I needed a pair of boots to replace another pair from a well known outdoor apparel company that literally fell apart this past winter. After doing a bit of research I chose the Columbia Ice Maiden II. They are comfortable and stylish and easy to slide on with a normal weight pair of socks. I think I am going to be very comfortable this winter in these boots for dog walking and getting to work . The tread seems like it will grip well in icy conditions , heavy snow, and cold which we can experience during a typical New England winter.

I am disappointed that these didn't fit. They are a half size too small, and while I can exchange them easily (thanks to the wonderful Zappos service!), they didn't have enough arch support for me. But they are lightweight, clearly warm, and good looking so I'd recommend at least trying them.

Light in weight, very comfortable and warm. Fits my orthotics well and can wear with a thin or thick sock and still comfortable. Thumbs up for me!

Boots run true to size. I generally wear a 9.5, and I ordered these boots in a 9.5. I have just enough toe room to wear thick socks, though the boots will fit great with thick or normal socks. The boot is a little bulkier than what I thought it would be, but they are still attractive enough, especially for snow boots and the price. Seems like these boots will be great to walk through heavy snow during winter, though I haven't yet worn them in icy/snowy conditions.

Love them- durable, cute & comfy. They are a bit clunky- not too clunky but sometimes they are too warm in the winter. Def waterproof though which is an advantage in the pac now! :)

I absolutely love these! They are comfortable and very warm! They are also cuter in person. I ordered a half size larger because I knew I'd be wearing thick socks. They fit perfectly with the thick socks! They keep my feet warm and dry in the rain and snow. I ordered the brown and would order them again!

I love these boots! Warm, comfortable, and cozy. Maybe a little big but I wear thick socks with them and no problem. Nice looking, too.

I could not possibly recommend these boots more! They are absolutely the best. They are cute, comfortable, and waterproof. They are exactly the boots that I needed. I am plus size so I have wide calfs, they fit no problem. The face that they come in half sizes is great, because I am a true 10½ and wide footed. I have worn these since November, in every weather condition in Michigan that you can imagine. My feet are comfortable and warm all day. I wear them all day long in the office. I love these boots!

Very comfortable and very warm. I wanted a boot that would go with anything and wasn't too over the top with varying colours and textures. I really like the style of these boots and they fitted within my price range. I have large calves, so I needed a boot that laces rather than zips. The laces are long with room to wrap around your ankles. If I want to funk it up a little, I change the laces to store bought 45" or 60" red or purple laces. Or whatever color I feel like!

Wow, I got these yesterday and put them on to make sure they fit, and I didn't take them off! They are so comfortable and warm. They look cute and aren't big and clunky, like most good snow boots. Plenty of room for thick socks and the laces are great for custom fitting the boot. Haven't tried yet but it looks like I will be able to drive with them on which is really important to me. Can't wait to give them a real test, it just needs to snow again!

For this price these fit better and are just as warm as some of the boots I tried on that cost twice as much. They look pretty cool as well (no pun intended). I have a wider foot and they feel great. Would recommend to others.

I am so happy that I purchased these boots! I normally wear an 8 1/2. That is the size I ordered originally but then I had to return them and get a 9. They fit perfectly now. In addition, the process of returning my boots and getting the correct size through zappos was absolutely stress-free and convenient. I love this company and love these boots! They are warm, comfortable and practical.

Very comfortable, I've had no problems walking in them for any length of time. They keep my feet quite warm as well. I haven't had any problems with the arch support that others have commented about either.

These boots are easy to "break in" and comfortable all day long! They withstand weather and puppies too.