Customer Reviews Cobb Hill Cobb Hill Alexandra

I have a similar boot from Cobb hill and it’s like they don’t use the same sizing at all. The wide wouldn’t surprise me as an average or even a narrow. The heel felt weirdly wobbly like it wasn’t under the right place on the foot.

Beautiful boot, but too narrow for my foot. Usually Cobb Hill fits well in medium for me. Out of stock in wide and larger size.

Just received the blue pair this morning. The comfort is great, as advertised. What is NOT as advertised accurately is the color. They are not remotely blue/teal, but definitely a medium/dark green. The color is so different that I will have to return. I've bought many pairs of shoes from Zappos and have never had this issue before.

I purchased this brand because they are known for great support and comfort. I am disappointed to find out that they do not support my arch well enough, and do not cushion the balls of my toes. My feet hurt for a couple of days after just a few hours in these. Also, because of the style, there is very little (or no) ankle support. After wearing them around the house for 4 hours to break them in my ankles were hurting. The next day I had bruising on the inner sides of both ankles. Since I needed them for a special event and didn't have time to do any more shopping, I went ahead and wore them. For that reason I have not contacted Zappos about the possibility of returning them for a refund.

These are AMAZING! I held out for months in buying them because I was convinced that I could find less expensive boots out there to fit my wide width feet...HAH! Trust me, blow your wardrobe budget on these babies. Comfortable, arch support, gorgeous teal color, and I can wear them all day long. They *do* scuff easily, but I neglected to treat them before wearing, so that might be part of the problem. Really, I'm going to scuff them anyway, so it didn't bother me.

These boots are pretty comfortable but my heel is very narrow so they slip a lot. However; the narrow width fits well across the toes. The length is good. The rounded toe makes them appear very casual in my opinion, which is neither good nor bad. I would not consider them dress boots. They have better support than many of today's shoes, still what I would consider moderate. I've worn the boots about a dozen times and have learned not to wear them for if I plan to walk a lot. I think it's the support issue and certainly the width issue. But, I love them for going out to casual events.

These are beautiful boots and I esp. like the heel that adds a dressy touch. However, they do not fit my high arch and I must return them. I appreciate the good service and the selection from Zappos!

These are very attractive boots, and I love the teal color. The sophisticated style looks good with jeans, or skirts I ordered my normal size, and they arrived too small. Hooray Zappos, because I was able to seamlessly exchange for a half size larger. At first I thought the 8.5 was still too small but I wore them a few times and they seem to fit all right.

These are gorgeous. The wide was not wide enough though. Hoping that half a size larger will work!

Normally I really like Cobb Hill shoes -- they generally fit me like a glove from the second I put them on. I already had three styles of Cobb Hills, and ordered three more in this order. These booties and a pair of boots that for some reason were way narrower than all the others.

So comfortable at the ball of the foot but so stiff in the heel. I could tell immediately I would get blisters. Sad because they are very cute and the front half super cushy!

Good looking. I wear a 8.5W true to size. I ordered 8.5W and 9W. The 8.5W was too narrow and too short in the toe box. The 9W I am contemplating...they are okay with regular socks; I don't think winter socks would work with them. The zipper is in the inside part of ankle. 1 of the boots (right side) the stitching for the zipper rubbed a sore spot (raw) in my ankle within 2 hours. Otherwise quite comfy. Trying to decide how to fix or if I send back. I think these would work with skirts, pants, perhaps longer shorts or super short shorts, but a knee length short looked odd. I think they can be worn fancy (office type) or casual. I do not know if they would work elegant...it may depending on outfit. They were shiny as depicted. Despite ordering wide and many reviews stating they are true to size or even wide... I found the to box to be narrow. These were not a slip my foot in and they are instantly in love shoe. Comfy for a day, but need to be broken in. Not sure if they will break in or not. Although I ordered a wide size I do not have a super wide foot, and in fact the heel is very narrow. The heel part fit perfectly if not a tiny roomy. I hope this helps.

I bought these shoes in the color described as blue/teal. Unfortunately, the color is closer to green/greenish teal. Comfy and stylish, just didn't work with the colors I have.

These boots were true to size and seemed very comfortable with a decent amount of cushioning on the insole, a rarity these days. They really look great from the side but from the front, with the folding of the leather and the wide opening, they looked like cankles - elephant cankles. For the money I want to be wowed and these were good but not perfect, so back they go.

Happy with the style, these shoes don't look too big on your feet. Low heel makes them very comfortable. However, the right heel doesn't feel very stable, probably just this pair though.

Great boots. Wide enough and fits my high arch well, but the teal color was more green than blue... and I needed the blue.

This shoe felt very narrow through the sides to me. Looks great, length fits fine. Arch support seems good.

These boots felt great straight out of the box! They were just slightly narrow toward the toe of the boot, but as I wore them throughout the day they felt better. I am not sure I want to try to wear them all day yet but I think once they are broken in a little more they will be comfy to wear all day. They look great with pants and I think they will look great with leggings or tights too. MUCH better fit than Naturalizers and well worth the extra $$! I think I will try other Cobb Hill wide shoes in the future!

I ordered wide in my usual size, and absolutely swam in them. I decided not to exchange them for a smaller size, because they are way too roomy around the ankles, like Robin Hood shoes. And I didn't like the styling that much. But the footbeds were quite comfortable.

I have noticed that Cob Hill shoes run very narrow, especially for a comfort brand. I ordered these in a wide width although I rarely wear wide-width shoes and they still felt a little narrow. However, these do break in quickly. Very cute with leggings or skinny jeans. Low heel makes them look dressier but you can still walk for miles in them.

I wanted this boot to fit - it is so cute. But the medium was too large and the narrow was too tight. Plus the heel seems to offset my balance it is almost set too far forward on the boot. Purchased a different lowered heeled boot instead from Cobb Hill. I love Zappos customer service that always receives five star!!

I really loved the way this boot looks. I can wear a 10.5W or 11W in most shoes. The 11W in this boot was way too big and unfortunately Cobb Hill does not make this boot in a 10.5W so it is going back!

The style is super cute and these feel like heaven on my feet. Very well cushioned! The picture of the blue/teal looked like the exact color I wanted (a blue teal shade). Alas, what I received was a very green teal which won't go well with my wardrobe so I'm going to return these or possibly exchange for another color.

The booties are cute..I wear a 9 wide. Fit well except the ankle area of the boogie felt really too big and loss. I will keep them though. The zipper on top of the boot tends to snag so I might return it for a replacement.

These boots look nice on but for a person with bunions and hammer toes, they are not the thing. I have other Cobb Hill shoes which fit great but the medium on these are tight. They provide great support but I had to return them.