Customer Reviews Allen Edmonds Nashua

This is my first pair. I was a little disapointed in the fit . Time will tell.

All of my Allen Edmonds or size 10 Nashua shoe was touching my toe and slipping off my heel

I bought the shoe expecting it would be supportive on the feet no support on both, no shank support. Great leather surrounds your feet but too soft for wearing all day long.

This is the fifth pair of this exact shoe I have purchased. It is not the quality of previous shoes. First, it came it scratched on the back heal. The shoes do not have the consistency of size from previous purchases. I am hopeful this is not what I will experience with other products.

The left shoe was fine (9W) but the right was not wide enough and pinched my foot. I returned them for a refund. The shoe looks great and comes in a Wide. Fewer and fewer shoes do come in wide!!!

I am a fan of AE shoes. Own 10 or so pair. This one however, squeaks loudly when walking. I believe it is my socks (cotton) rubbing against the inside leather? Not sure. I suspect with use it will subside - but for now its annoying.

I am an AE fan. Have several pairs. Overall quality of the shoe measured up to your high quality standards. However, the MOC seam inside the toe of the shoe was very rough, so much so it made the shoes very uncomfortable and impossible to wear. Chafed top of my toes. I had to return. I'll be back, still a fan! Thanks for listening, Bud Swanson

I have owned AE shoes for over 30 years, and still wear my Park Avenue and Grayson's among others. This is the second pair of the Nashua tassel loafer I have owned. The right shoe is fine. The left caused my 3rd, 4th and 5th toes to be squeezed together to the point that the shoe is too painful to wear. I am currently trying to stretch it out with a wooden shoe tree. The Sequoia I bought about a year or so ago is still tight on my feet. Prior to these 2 shoes, I never had a problem with your shoes.

Before I ordered the Nashua loafers, I noticed that they weren't USA-made. However, I figured I'd overlook that fact because the shoes appeared to be exactly what I was looking for. While the styling was just just what I wanted, I found the craftsmanship was not up to par when compared to the other Allen Edmonds I own. The stitching was sloppy and there were some deep scuffs that appeared to be somehow inflicted during the manufacturing process. I care how my shoes look and how they are constructed, and that's why I buy Allen Edmonds in the first place. These were a complete disappointment and I promptly sent them back. I'll stick with the made-in-the-USA styles.

I really love how these shoes look and they are great for walking short distances. I have broken them in and they are soft and comfortable. However, there is very little cushion/cork and if you walk on a hard surface like a sidewalk for more than 10 minutes, you are really going to feel it!

I've purchased numerous Allen Edmonds shoes and had consistently good experience with new shoes fitting well -- nearly right out of the box. I have EEE width, which has always been part of my motivation to buy here first. I even bought this same shoe in black/brown a couple of years ago with good luck. BUT, when I received these shoes, they were unusually tight in width and toe length. I tried wearing them multiple times thinking they would give a bit, but no luck. I went to the local retail store today, and they're going to try a half-size up to see if that improves things.

Sizing has changed. Where I could always wear a 10 C (last 15 years) I now have no good idea and am afraid to order again. Inconsistent sizing.

Shoes look a little bit outdated and old, which is not necesarely a problem. Quality is good: nice leathers, hand stitched, well constructed. But they are quite unconfortable and noisy. My first -and last- Allen Edmonds.

Received the 10.5 size shoes and they were very nice looking. But when I tried them on my feel would slide. They seemed over all too large. Although they were just what I wanted to wear on rainy days I had to send them back. I don't think a shorter shoe would have fit any better. In the past in have been able to wear a 10.5 in Allen Edmonds lace ups but these shoes just didn't fit very well.

Second pair of Nashua's that I own. Loved first pair in brown so purchased second pair in black. Wear a B width and first pair fit perfect. Second pair are tight, which is unusual for me. I am hoping they will stretch out over time.

I own 3 pairs of 8.5 wides (two Rockports, one LL Bean) which are very comfortable. This pair of 8.5 E are very tight and going back. I can't comment on anything else just yet except that they are nice looking and look well made. I can't tell if they are too narrow or too short.

Special ordered a pair of these as I have two sized feet. 10.5C left and 9E right. When i received them they were so tight I couldn't wear them. I took them back to the store to have them stretched but still can't wear the right one. Great looking shoe though

I purchased these shoes about 8 weeks ago in the English Tan Dublin. This color was not in stock at the store so I had them order the pair for me after fitting. The shoes came in and the color was very orange, odd for something called English Tan Dublin. Also the fit was a bit long and the sales person suggested I put an insert into the shoe. I was a bit skeptical about the solution but no offer to order a smaller size. Generally I have found that very good shoes with good leather stretch and fit to the size and shape of you foot during the break in period, obviously not the case here as the size was already larger than needed.

First off when I was measured for this shoe, the salesperson recommended a half size larger, this has turned out to be a mistake. I have normally found loafers to expand to fit your feet -- this shoe came to large from the start. I should have taken them back when the order came into the store and I tried them on but I did not. Secondly I do not particularly care for two tone shoes so I opted for the English Tan Dublin, should be called Orange, second mistake. Finally the soles are wearing out very quickly -- third mistake.

These shoes' heel is slightly high and seems to cant the foot downward in the shoe. Maybe some additional arch support would make them more comfortable.

Most awful shoe from Allen Edmonds. The sole is stinky cause its cheap Indian rubber. I immediately had to add another insole so I can stop feeling the unevenness. Horrible shoe for the money.

This is the fourth pair of this shoe that I have purchased. Every one of them fails at the top seam. It took 10-12 months for that failure to appear on the the first three. The last pair failed within 2 months.

I have worn this shoe on a daily basis for 30 years. I rotate a couple of pairs and occasionally have the original r rubber sole replaced. As the leather sole base of one of my pairs (at least 30 years old) has developed cracks in the leather sole base I just received a replacement pair ordered directly online. I now see the shoe does not meet the quality of the past or as is depicted in the company website photos. The welted leather sub-soul is GONE and the rubber soul is glued to a thin plastic sub-soul. The comfort of the thicker sole is gone and the rebuild capability seriously compromised. This is the end for this shoe and my confidence in Allen Edmonds shoes. I would return them but now duty paid in Canada it is not worth the additional wasted money.