Customer Reviews Allen Edmonds Nashua

I wish they fit, they looked good, i'm hard to fit and -- they didn't feel right.

This like other third world mfg is ok but I normally buy ur Italian shoes hope u expand the availability of these models

Not the sam as other two colors in same style. Much larger.

I currently own and love the primary black with brown accent NASHUA TASSEL LOAFER. I acquired this second pair that is primarily light brown with black accents. I ordered the shoes with the exact same size that I currently own and unfortunately it felt longer and wider and fit too loosely to keep. I did not exchange it for a different size because the look isn't as classic as my currently owned one. The brown is much brighter and lighter than I had expected.

A very good shoe , but i found it rather heavy compared to the Johnson and Murphy equivalent.

This is one of 3 pair of shoes that I ordered on line. One in each color and this shoe is bigger than all the rest. Did not realize it till after wearing them for a evening. Would suggest buying them in a store.

Great looks. However, I can't wear the shoe . It is too wide in the heel. My heel comes out when I walk. All AE shoes I have are too narrow in toe box; this Nashua loafer not as much as others.

I am a dedicated AE wearer. The Nashua is a comfortable casual loafer. It ran long compared to other loafers. My favorite loafers are my Woodstocks, Maxfields and Codys. The Nashua is not in the same league as these, but I didn't expect them to be. A good, less expensive, causal option which works well with jeans.. Comfortable right out of the box.

This particular product was not up to the usual AE caliber. Last was uncomfortable and the shoe did not feel true to size.

AE does not offer this shoe in EE width and while EEE is a bit loose while new and a period afterwards, in a fairly shot time of wearing it stretches to the point it is difficult to keep on. Because I like the shoe, I bought another pair of E width, but no amount of stretching has made it comfortable to wear.

I own a pair that I really like. When I decided to purchase a different color I didn't notice that they didn't have the leather piece between the lower part of the shoe and the rubber sole. This severely changes the look and style of the shoe. The pair I have is one of my favorites and I'm sorry to see this change as I won't be able to replace them in the future. I returned the second pair.

i purchased 3 pairs of these shoes online only to find that each fit differently and none fit the way i pair i had purchased a year ago fit. i am now trying a completely different size and width to see if they fit any better.

too tight and too small sizes differ from former orders. Only wear AE shoes! had to send them back

I own 15+ pairs of AE shoes (obviously I am an AE fan), including a pair of Nashua's that are about 2 yrs old. I bought another pair of Nashua's in a different color recently, but they do not fit as well as my first pair, and the quality does not seem to be as good. I exchanged them once, but the replacements are no better.

All of my AE purchases have been for a 10.5 E in loafers. While the quality of this shoe appears to be excellent, this 10.5 E is absolutely the smallest of any AE shoe that I have ever had. Customer service was absolutely tremendous in resolving the issue.

If you are looking for dressy, this is not what you want. I was trying to replace a pair I had from 15 years ago that went well with jacket and tie. These would be more suitable for jeans and shirt.

I own two pairs of these shoes. The first fit me like a glove and were extemely comfortable, but the rubber sole began to delaminate from the toe. The second pair is extremely disappointing. Marked as the same size as the first pair, they are simply too large to fit by a wide margin. The sole at the widest part is at least a half inch larger. I have bought several pairs of AE shoes online from AE. This has been a big disappointment and I have little confidence going forward with online purchases from AE.

THE PROBLEM IS THE TASSEL!!!! Why would AE make these shoes which are excellent until they put these tassels on them that flower like a weed and the shoes are virtually ruined, they look so bad. I love these shoes but please put tassels on them that hold their shape. Why do I even have to suggest this. How can a shoe manufacturer put such a tassel on an otherwise high quality shoe. I would not recommend these to anyone because of and only because of the TASSEL

The soles on these loafers are noticeably thinner and softer than the previous generation Nashua loafer. They are almost like driving moccasins. I feel every pebble and sidewalk crack.

I purchased the same shoe in black. They were perfect, comfortable, good looking, well made. I chose to purchase the tan version of the same shoe - same size. They run much wider than the previous pair. I'm having difficulty keeping them on! I recommend the shoe, but beware of the difference in the same shoe between colors.

I've owned 3 pairs of the Nashua. Extremely comfortable and good looking. Unfortunately, however, the rubber sole has come apart (at the toe) for my last 2 pairs .... the last one in less than one month. Truly unfortunate, as the shoe would be extraordinary otherwise. Others have noted the same problem. AE should promptly resolve to save the shoe.

You will only realize how AE has changed for the worse if you compare to those shoes you purchased 5 years ago. The Nashua has changed for the worse.

Slip-on conundrum bit me here - 10.5 is normal size, but these were two short after a few years. Foot had flattened out but when I tried to move to an 11, the heel slipped off. My misfortune.

I could not recommend this shoe because of the difference in the fit of other shoes of the same model.

Generally enjoy the brand overall, this pair just fell short of expectations.