Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Petty

This shoe fits like a glove but unfortunately did not have enough arch support for what I need. I had to return them.

I ended up not keeping these shoes. Although they look quite snazy, the soles are very hard with very little cushioning. In addition, I found the toe box to be a bit too tight for me.

These are good looking boots. They seem to run a tiny bit small, but not small enough to order a size up. I hope they stretch a little bit. They are not a "soft walking" boot. They have a hard sole and a hard heel - so they click when you walk. I don't know if they are good for walking in all day, but they are a stylish boot and would be be good for short walking periods - and probably going out.

These booties were not comfortable right out of the box as other reviews had indicated. I do feel like they will break-in in time, and they are very attractive, so I'm keeping them. It's really hard to find navy boots.

I am usually a size 10, these boots were small in the toe and because I have a high instep. I could barely get them on. I re-ordered in a size 10.5. Hopefully they will fit because the style is great.

I was so excited to get this boot as the reviews were marvelous and the boot is EXACTLY what I've been looking for. This shoe is one of the most uncomfortable boots I've ever tried on. I actually went back to make sure I had read the reviews about the right boot. It feels like I was walking on hard cement and the bottom is very slick. Extremely disappointed!

Go with anything style. Super casual to everyday dresses and skirts. The navy is a rich shade that goes well with navy tights. I usually wear a 5.5 in Stuart Weitzman. These 5.5s fit perfectly.

This is so cute and would have worked well for me. Sadly, the sole is too hard, and it makes my heel hurt even when I add a plantar fasciitis insole. The top of the boot rubs my ankle and bothers me.

Comfortable and easy to walk in. I wear a 9.5-10 however, these 10's were really too big, so i returned for a 9.5 & fit good. Nice boot, well made.

This is a beautiful bootie, and it fit fairly well. I liked everything about it except the toe box was too narrow. I wear a M, but the stylish toes were a bit too pointy and narrow. Alas, I must return them.

I ordered these in the saddle leather. I loved the color of the leather, however I ended up having to return the shoe because it didn't fit right. I think the shoe ran a little big and it's very wide at the ankle. Loved the look of these booties, but just not on me!

Gorgeous color and quite comfortable. I didn't love where it hit my ankle with the two skinny jeans I own. I would have to roll my jeans and then my ankles may get cold. Wanted to love them but just not quite the style I was looking for (based on how they worked with my jeans)!

Extremely cool looking boots. Love them. But what were they thinking by leaving the bottoms completely smooth with absolutely no non-skid treading? They're slippery as heck on the carpet so I can only imagine what they would be like out side. They look too good to return so I guess I'll only wear them when the weather is perfect.

It looks like a great boot, perfect size heel. I thought it would work for me because some reviewers said it ran narrow. If you have a true narrow foot, narrow in the heel especially, this will not work for you, as it did not work for me. Sad to send it back.

I found a navy pair at a hotel boutique and fell in love with them. Good price. Narrow enough. Wore them all day first time--so comfortable too. Searched and found leopard on Zappos and had to have them.

Like the boots! Except for one thing: the size. I normally take a 7 in Hunter, Ugg, Frye, Franco Sarto, Enzo Angiolini, sometimes a European 37. These are too tight for me in the arch and toe area, but I had worn them too much to send back. So I keep wearing them anyway and trying to stretch them out. I am on my feet almost all day. They are wearable, but I would have tried a half size up if I had been in a store.

I'm a 7 medium, and these fit well, though not quite well enough. The shaft sits higher than I had hoped it would, and maybe it's just my bony ankles, but they rubbed in a way that was just uncomfortable enough to send them back. Otherwise, good quality and sturdiness!

These are great looking boots. I have three other pairs, but unfortunately, I have to return the second pair of these blue ones as the 9 was too big at the ankle and heel, and the 8½ was too tight in the forefoot - darn! Other colors have been just fine. I love this blue suede color and wish that I could have kept these.

I think these are great neutral booties that will work well in a warmer winter climate where tall boots and snow boots are not necessary. I like the clean lines of the boot and relatively low heel since heel heights are sky high these days. I found the width to be on the narrow side which absolutely works for me because I am a true narrow and will order narrows when available. But how does this work for medium width feet? I'm not so sure. I thought quality was above average but not great. I think for great quality you have to spend around $200. I liked them enough to keep both the Putty Suede and Saddle Leather colors. The Putty Suede is more comfortable but I think they both will break in nicely. As usual, Zappos has awesome service and a great selection.

I really love the style of these boots. They look great with skinny jeans. The leather seems nice quality. But they bend just behind the toes and it pinches my foot. I'm a little torn because I really like them but I'm not sure they will be comfortable. I'm hoping as I break them in they won't keep pinching. It's a little bit on the narrow side with a pointed toe. I really like the low heel, reminds me of a cowboy boot.

This is a great looking shoe that can be dressed up or dressed down. They are comfortable to walk in and well made. They are very small and narrow, though. I go between a 6.5 and 7 generally, and the 7 is so I can wear orthotics and/or thick socks. The 7 in this shoe was too small even with very thin socks and no orthotic, so I had to return and size up to a 7.5 and I think even the 8 would have worked except I think they'll stretch. They are also very narrow, and I have narrow feet. I would have exchanged for a wide if it was available.

These are great boots! I love the color and the fit, though I usually wear a 9 1/2, but sized down to a 9. Can't wait to wear these with my skinny jeans!

This shoes are very stylish and good-looking. The heel is low and they are pretty comfortable, so they are a good every day wear. However, there is a point of creasing between the flat part and the ankle part, and that has begun to pinch a bit as the crease deepens.

I have wide "Asian feet", so the medium width was a little too narrow for my feet. I didn't understand the comment about sizing down if you have wide feet. If anything, I would size up by a half. In the pictures, the new tumbled leather looks like regular leather to me. However, the new tumbled leather is supposed to be somewhat broken in (like jeans). I wanted a very sleek, polished leather, but the regular leather is not the super smooth kind. For that, try to find the Peter ankle boots (apparently discontinued but available with some online retailers with old stock or on eBay). There's also cloth piping along the side seams and top, which, imo, looks less refined, more low end. I've never seen that kind of piping on high end boots that are > less. Also, along the zipper and on top where the zipper rests at the top, the leather is cut and the leather isn't finished; I can see the raw edges. These are small details that show where they cut corners in the manufacturing, which I would expect for boots that cost less, not this cost. Despite that, the shaft is lower than most ankle boots, and the style is more minimalist than most, f which I prefer. According to the sticker on the sole of the boots, the exterior is leather, but the lining is synthetic leather and textile, it feels soft, so I get how some people may mistakenly think that the lining us leather. I wore out another pair of ankle boots because the inner lining was fake leather and got torn up. The sole is also synthetic, per the sticker. They are made in China. At this price, I would have appreciated a genuine leather interior lining. And clean, stitched leather rather than the naff piping around the edges.

Gorgeous - soft suede. Except that mine arrived already marked up and I had to return. Also the heel is kind of cheesy.