Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Petty

Great fall shoe! Looks good with jeans and skirts!

Ordered in putty suede. Loved the style of the shoe, color was a bit different than what's online. Returned for a different color. Can't wait!

These are great! Perfect height to give you a little lift but not make you TOO tall (if you're tall and hate wearing heels). I'm still breaking the shoes in so they're a bit stiff, but I expect they'll be more comfortable down the road. I thought the pebbled leather would bother me but they look smoother when you're looking at them on.

Very cute bootie, goes with everything and great for fall. I recommend using suede stain repellent.

These boots are great to wear under wider cut slacks or with Jeans. They're very comfortable to wear to work. Be forewarned, though, that they have no cushioning so they're not great for hiking around for long periods of time. The Tumbled leather is good quality, sturdy, lightweight and with some waterproofing can be taken anywhere.

I first bought in Putty Suede and loved them. They go with everything, and are stylish and comfortable. I was looking for a pair of black booties, and couldn't find anything I liked better than this style. Unfortunately, black was sold out, so I went with the Slate Grey. It is MUCH lighter in person, and is really not a substitute for black. I don't love the Slate color, but I kept them anyway, because they are comfy and an unusual color for when I want something different.

These booties are very cute and reasonable quality for the low price. But there are tight in the toe box compared to other styles/brands. I do not have a wide foot but found these to be too tight. I tried sizing up, but that didn't solve it. So if you have narrow feet, these should be great for you.

These boots are fairly basic, but cute and comfortable. They took a little breaking in, but they are pretty comfy now after a few wears. The low heel height is comfortable!

Love these but they are just too wide. Very nice leather and style. Wide heel too.

Cute botties, but they rubbed my ankle in the front when I walked. Seemed to just hit the wrong spot.

I really wanted to like these booties, as they've been on my wish list for a long time, but I have to say I'm pretty disappointed in the fit. I own several pairs of Sam Edelman shoes - including regular boots - and I've consistently and comfortable worn an 8.5 in all of them. These booties, though, definitely seem to fit more on the narrow side. They were very snug around the middle of my foot - very uncomfortable when I first tried them on, but they did seem to loosen up a smidge with time. Returning to try out a wide size instead; the regular did not fit well, and I would probably not recommend to anyone with wider feet like myself.

I decided to buy the wide width for my normal feet because I've heard they run narrow. I purchased my usual size in length and added a cushioned insole for extra support. These were comfy right out of the box - exactly was I was hoping for!

I have these in 3 different colors. One suede (Putty) and then the 2 leather options--had to grab those when the sale hit. The suede are easier to break in and are a little softer than the leather, but I love all 3 pairs. I wear them almost daily and they remain comfortable throughout the work day. Extremely versatile and the perfect height when you are not heel girl. I did go down from a normal 6.5 to a 6 in these. The 6.5 was too big but the 6 was great after a little break in time. They do stretch out some when worn.

I love Sam Edelman boots, and this will be year four for my last pair. I bought the booties in the same size, but they're very narrow in the heel. I have to use a shoe horn to get them on, and I'm hoping they'll stretch out. I'm wondering if I should have bought them in a half size bigger. Zappo's customer service is outstanding, and I love their Jokes of the Day!

These are beautiful booties. They have a cowboy boot vibe. I ordered the moss green suede because they came up in my search for brown booties--and they looked brownish-green on my monitor. But no...they are a neutral moss green. The insole is not as padded as I would like, but the construction looks good. These would rock casual Fridays.

This boot is made with a beautiful leather, but I ordered a 7 as it is my usual size, they are about an inch too long.

Very comfortable and stylish. Perfect with skinny pants and dresses.

I had high hopes for this boot. Very cute. I went with the slate grey suede. Figured I would try a bootie style, since after gaining weight, have had problems finding tall boots that would fit my now-wide foot and large calf. Gave these a try, but just a tish too narrow (even buying the wide width). Kind of cut into the front of my ankle, although probably would have stretched with wear, and had a struggle getting the back over my heel. The sole is a little slick, if that is a concern. Figured if I was paying $140 bucks, I didn't want to have to fight to make them work, although, dang, I wish they had worked! Unfortunately, had to send back, but if you have normal feet these would be awesome. Would look great with dress pants at work or with casual clothes.

Love these booties. They are popular for a reason. Super cute and come in a great variety of colors. Love that they come in wide. They are NOT comfortable for walking for long periods of time, however. Minimal support. I'm still happy with them for the price.

I usually buy Aquatalia boots which are double or triple the price of these so maybe my expectations are a little higher than they should be. The blue suede was lovely, style great, bottom and heel a little cheesy. Heel is plastic fake of stacked wood and bottom is super slick plastic. No traction whatsoever. Not uncomfortable, but by end of the day was sure wishing for more padding inside. For the price, not bad.

This is a great, go with anything bootie. I have them in tan leather and have enough room that I can fit my orthotic and wear them all day. Loved the black suede but am returning as I would have preferred a black sole. I have a narrow heel and wide toebox and they fit just right. They may be loose on someone with narrow feet. Doesn'tr have arch support but does have a padded foot bed.

Love these booties! I have them in two colors.

These shoes are comfortable! They do run large. I usually wear an 8 but need a 7.5. I don't really like the look of the Black Brahma--personal preference. The texture is too "hairy" for my taste. I might re-order in putty.

I love this shoe, but the 7.5 was too small (I'm normally 7.5) and the 8 was too big. I may try one more time for the 7.5W. Also, there is no traction on the bottom if that's a concern for anyone.