Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Petty

Nice looking shoes, but I found the even the wide to be a bit snug.

Still too big--although it's a half size smaller than I usually wear. Please make smaller shoes for petite women.

I have the tan Petty, and they're pretty cute and comfortable. Black suede version is cute, but not so comfortable. I can tell they're not going to break in and conform like my other leather Petty. I've worn them twice, and my toes have gone numb. No traction on the bottom of the sole either...which I could fix with grippers, if I loved these bootie enough, but I don't, so back to Zappos they go.

I really really wanted to like this boot! I have same boot in caramel - light brown leather. But this one was not at all as good as that one. The suede was touchy and fought and not soft. Padding inside the show was basically non existent. Overall shoe looked great but was not comfortable. Sadly going back.

You'll definitely need to size down. I'm normally an 8, but could slip the shoe off my foot even when it's zipped!Besides that, the Petty is a solid basic bootie.

I have been searching for a pair of cognac colored leather booties for about 4 months now. I am extremely picky and also want a quality pair of shoes that will last. I just received these and I am honestly blown away on how adorable and sleek they are. Exactly what I wanted for a great price! I am a big Sam Edelman fan and although these are not as comfortable as my other two shoes by the same designer they far surpass my expectations! They seem like a good go to shoe in a rush to run errands. Exactly what I wanted! My only real complaint is that they are a tad narrow in the toe area. But I believe they will stretch with time.

Beautiful grey-beige neutral color. Like the sleek, smooth styling, with nice stitching --almost piping--covering the side seam on the non-zipper side. Love the color. The fit is uncomfortable for me, fitted in front, heel slipping up in back. Can't keep it for that reason.

This is a beautiful shoe, but I felt it fit about 1/2 size too small (I wear a 9.5 wide). There is no cushioning, so I don't think it would be very comfortable to wear for long periods of time.

Beautiful boot, but the nap on the suede was a little course and not the same on both boots. The leather strip that covers the zipper was wrinkled and didn't seem like it would lay out. Sadly, they are going back.

These boots are cute but even the wide runs narrow. I sized up and even so they were uncomfortably tight. My feet aren't even that wide!

Just what I was looking for, beautiful! I don’t usually order a wide but figured it couldn’t hurt cause it’s has kind of a narrow toe, I’m glad I did because it still pinched my toes while wearing them. I think the regular width would have hurt to bad to wear them. They sit nice and low, didn’t rub on my head and have nice cushioning inside. VERY HAPPY ??????

These boots were very cute, but they didn't fit me well. They were too tight across my foot and too loose in the heel.

Walked right out if this boit, there's to much excessive room in the heel.

Loved the look of the shoes but ran much less wide than the average wide-sized shoe. Beautiful detail on the exterior. If your foot does not run wide, these could be to your liking.

Ordered these in black suede....style wise they were everything I wanted. Opened the box and was not disappointed, until I tried them on. Honestly some of the most uncomfortable shoes I have ever had on. Soles are hard as rocks and have no "give". Very disappointed and returning.

This shoe runs very small. I had to return to order a full size larger than I normally do. But very comfortable and I like the material.

Shoe Is very attractive. Because I need a wide the shoe feels fine on one foot but then too wide in the heel for both feet. I would have kept if not for this reason.

These were not as fashionable as I was looking for and run large. So back they go.

Cute. Still breaking them in. Not great for a long walk in mall but comfortable enough.

I am a size 11 and wanted to love these b/c they are very cute in person...alas, too narrow for me and I don't seem to have that problem w/other shoes, so I checked that they "felt narrower than marked." Good luck!

Ordered this shoe in both 8 and 8 1/2 since I run between sizes depending on brand. The 8 was waaay too tight in the toe box. The 8 1/2 was a tiny bit large but with a thin padded insert fit perfectly. They are a pretty stiff shoe so I imagine they will be much more comfortable with the insert. Putty and Moss Green colors are gorgeous; I had to return the moss green (which fit) because it had a lump that ran along the center of the shoe which i know shouldn't be there. Thank you Zappos for your free returns.

I was excited to get these shoes, but they didn't work for me. I have wide feet and small bunions. I wear an 8.5 wide in many brands (ex/ clarks, naturalizer, etc.). I ordered an 8.5 wide in these shoes, and while they seemed to fit in width, they were half a size too long and my foot was sliding around in the shoe. I exchanged them for an 8 wide, and while the length fit me, they were far too narrow for my foot. Cute pair of shoes, but they are unfortunately getting returned.

Love these boots! They look great with jeans or tights and a skirt and hold up well in the rain. Overall very comfortable although I added inserts for more arch support.

I wanted to love these boots because I've been looking for a cute pair that come in a wide width. Unfortunately, even the wide width in these boots is too narrow for my feet and causes pain. I haven't found a good replacement yet, but hopefully I can find something that looks as nice as these do.

These were supper cute, but were just a bit to tight for me. I am a bit wide through my instep, and the taper on these was to tight.