Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Petty

Color is more on the gray side, not the beige/tan as shown. However, it is a nice looking bootie.

Really nice boot and stylish. Not wide enough if you have a bunion!

I agree with others that this is a pretty bootie in the putty suede color. Looks a little green next to some colors, but tan against others. It does run a bit narrow and I sized up half a size and am glad I did. It is comfortable enough, but I don't think I could walk in them all day- they are still a bit narrow for that, even going up a 1/2 size. My foot is usually a true medium width.

These boots are so cute and the exact heel height I need but sadly...they squeak when your foot rubs against the side. Have to return.

Really cute boots. I'm probably going to buy them in other colors. I ordered a 6.5 and they're big but I'm not sure how a 6 would fit. They don't rub or cause discomfort and I'd rather them be a little big than snug.

Nice booties. Reasonably comfortable. I wear a 9.5 but order 10 in boots, as the toe box is often narrow (and my toes are blunt, as wide as my feet.) These slip a bit w/out boat socks, and are a tiny bit snug with the socks, but I can live with it, b/c my feet are odd. The color is good (I bought the putty) and it seems well made. I have worn Sam Edelman’s shoes since he was half of Sam and Libby in the 80s, and they have always been good quality.

Cute booties, fit pretty well out of the box - a little tight on one foot across the ball of my foot. They have however cut up the back of my heels over the past 4 times wearing them (with a few days spaced out between wears). I know my heels will toughen and the shoes will soften up, but until that happens - OUCH. :(

Beautiful shoe, but unfortunately ran large and had to return.

These are absolutely beautiful booties and I wanted to love them, but they didn't work for me. I have thicker ankles, and the edge of the bootie rubbed the back of my heel when I walked, and the left show rubbed against my big toe. It's possible they would have stretched out, but due to the solid stitching around the shaft, I didn't want to risk the future blisters. They were also a but heavy, and the smooth bottoms would not serve me well in Midwest winters. However they are gorgeous leather, a cute and simple style, and true to size. That said, I got my normal size in a wide. I have slightly wide feet and these were plenty spacious. Thick socks would have worked fine (either short to hide or tall if you want them to go above the boots). Overall, wish they had been more comfortable!

Great Booties. Love the Black/Brown contrast with the suede and heel. They are my go to shoes. Wear them with all of my outfits!

Great Booties. Simple style. Love the Black/Brown contrast with the leather and heel. They are my go to shoes. Work with all my outfits!

Liked it, but not exactly what I was looking for

Loved the look of these with the grey leopard print but the fit was just too awkward for my skinny little ankles.

Smaaalllll! I wear between a 9 1/2 - 10, and since I read they were narrow I ordered a 91/2 wide. They are so uncomfortable! Too short AND too narrow. But the grey leopard is beautiful and unique, so i ordered the 10 with the hopes it’s a size and not just a comfort thing. For that price I will be returning them again if the larger size is still uncomfortable. ??

Cute boot - but - the wides are wide and the medium widths are narrow. Bummer

I really wanted to keep these shoes. The fit was fine, but the edges were hurting my ankle bone. I felt the leather was a little stiff. Probably they would have loosened up, but I wanted them to take on an upcoming trip. I generally wear a 7.5 and the length was perfect. I have very narrow ankles and prominent ankle bones and the top edge was just uncomfortable. I did like the style and the reviews all said they were so comfortable. Perhaps if my ankles were not so bony. I had to send them back.

I go back and forth between a 9.5 and a 10. The 9.5 was a bit too tight so I am returning for the 10. I wear a 9.5 in running shoes... So if you are on the fence, size up... Love the grey coloring!

I love the style of these booties and so wish I could keep them! The foot bed wasn't comfortable at all and lacked the cushioning needed for all-day wear. These are incredibly stylish and will go with everything in your closet if you don't stand on your feet all day.

Very cute and comfortable but a little slippery so scratch up the bottom before you wear out!

Color is a lot lighter than on line.

I ordered 4 different pairs of very similar boots. Same color (taupe), same style, different brands. I wanted something reasonably flat that would go with both jeans and shorts. I loved all 4 of the pairs I ordered which made choosing between them very difficult. Ultimately I'm returning these because the suede feels more like fabric and the style is less interesting as the other three. The padding inside is not as supportive as I would like either. Still great boots. Looked good with everything I paired them with. Might actually buy them in black...

Horribly uncomfortable. I don't think I could walk more than 5 steps in these. Hard as a rock, no cushioning.

Love the color and the feel of the shoe. I wear a regular size 8. These are very tight. Also they have very slick bottoms.

I have been looking for a stylish pair of leather booties for over a year now. I love these because they can be super casual (think running errands with toddlers in tow) or cute and stylish (think laid back date night with significant other). My only real complaint with these was that they needed to be worn in a bit (about 1-2 wears) to stretch them out. Initially, when I first tried them on I thought I would need to exchange them for a half size bigger. However, I read a review where someone also commented on how they stretched out and I am glad I kept my original size. Love these and would definitely recommend them!