Customer Reviews Frye Carson Lace Up

I bought these shoes in an 8.5 and they were really huge! I am a true 8.5. I returned them for a size 8 and they are still quite roomy. They are however, a lovely pair of shoes and I will purchase them in black also!

Fits perfect, no breaking in period needed. True to size.

Have owned these for about a month and they're now my favorite pair of shoes. Ridiculously comfortable. The break in period was pretty short - maybe 2-3 wears - and now I can walk for miles and miles without the slightest pinch or hint of rubbing. Stunning shade of brown - they look great with just about any outfit.

I bought these shoes to wear to work and wow I was beyond impressed with my purchase. These shoes are timeless looking and go with everything. You can dress an outfit up with these rather than wear combat boots. Overall its a great purchase. The toe is long so the sizing could be a problem for some people who are inbetween sizes.

I fell in love with these in Atlanta while on a trip and kept coming back to the store to try them on. They are incredibly comfortable- fit like a glove and give excellent ankle support. I usually wear an 8.5 but went with an 8 as the rounded toe is a bit long so I'd size down a half if you're considering. I agree the bottoms are slick but I think in time, with wearing them outside, that will toughen up a bit. I've worn them with jeans, leggings, and a dress- they work for every occasion! Love the vintage look but modern fit.

These shoes are really beautiful and incredibly comfortable right out of the box. I'm usually somewhere between an 8.5 and 9.5 so I was a little nervous about what size to get. I went with the 9 and they are perfect. Plenty of room for my toes if I don't wear thick socks. But all of the other reviewers are right. These are crazy slick! I slipped and fell the second I walked outside and scuffed them up a bit. But they are so great that I could not bring myself to dock a star for it.

These shoes are perfect. The only caveat is that you MUST get rubber put on the soles and heels. Otherwise the soles are uncomfortably slippery AND they will wear through (rather fast). This will cost 40-50 bucks. Once you had done that you will own the most comfortable pair of shoes that have every been made. They are the perfect height, the perfect softness, the perfect breathability. I have walked 25,000 steps a day weeks at a time all over Europe (many times) and my feet feel absolutely fine the entire time. I couldn't do half that in any other shoe I have ever owned (running shoes included). I really feel invincible in these shoes. Make sure you get the right size. I am 8-8.5 and I initially though I was an 8.5 because they felt so great but then realized the 8s were even better.

I just got these for my birthday and I love them! They're a little long (which I've found in all frye boots) but I'm still obsessed. I wanted a boot that was like a combat boot but not as tall and these are perfect! Great with jeans and dresses! I got my normal size ( a 9) and i can wear a pretty thick sock with it.

Just received my Carson lace up Bootie shoes and love them right out of the box!..These shoes are another very well made Frye shoe .. they are made of a beautiful quality, soft leather. Design wise and I would describe them as very currant with a play on vintage.These Carson lace ups are very comfortable so far and I know in time they will break in even more and compliment the feel and look of the shoe...I ordered them in my normal size of 7 1/2 and I would say they are a nice fit for a medium width foot with a warm sock and still room enough for comfortable movement when walking.. I also feel as though they can accommodate a wider foot as well given the soft leather. I like that for a semi pointed toe, there is Plenty of wiggle room for your big toe:) Cant wait to wear them with jeans or a dress as I find them to be rather versatile. Overall very happy with my purchase and now I want them in all the available colors:)!