Customer Reviews KEEN Toyah MJ

I was hopeful about these shoes, but they ended up feeling extremely stiff, clunky, and felt a half size to a full size too big for me. I ended up returning these.

Bought these because I developed plantar fasciitis from all those cute but cheap flipflops over the summer. So far, I love them. I had to return the first pair in my normal size because they were too big. Got them in a half size smaller, and they're fine. Still a bit big, but livable. Comfortable and good for my arches. They do require socks - they tend to rub in strange places, falling higher up the ankle than most shoes. Be warned; the shoes are more reddish-purple in color than brown.

These shoes are so super comfortable right out of the box - they look great with jeans, skirts, capris, and also go great with socks of any color! I love this reddish brown color for fall - this shoe has great arch support and I look forward to wearing them all winter.

I love these shoes, great arch support, wonderful for standing all day at a job. Cute, good looking shoes. I especially love the red brick color, these are my favorite pair of shoes for work. I even find myself wearing them for casual purposes and just out walking the dog too. They are that good. Keen seems to make a few kinds of shoes: the flimsy, the moderate support and the major support. I'd classify these as the major support kind of Keens (and that's the way I like it).

I loved these shoes, but will have to return them due to size. In previous Keens I have ordered I have had to go up a size, but these seem to run true to the size I usually wear. They are extremely comfortable and I love the look. I will be hoping that these become available in my size.

I had high hopes for this shoe as a great walking shoe for traveling that was not a sneaker. It has a great sole and is super comfortable and supportive. Unfortunately, it runs super wide, so it was not a good fit for my skinny feet.

I bought this shoe based on reviews here and because I'm in desperate need of comfortable shoes with a lot of "give" in the material. I'm sorry to say, these shoes are not it. While the toe box for these shoes is wide, the material is hard and it presses on the top part of the foot, making for throbbing pain even while I'm sitting down. I'm returning mine.

I am a teacher and suffer from a heel spur which can really be painful after a day at work in shoes that provide no support. I ordered 3 pair of Keen Mary Janes and these were the ones that I kept. No break in period and no pain at the end of the day! I plan to order another pair in brown. Thanks Keen!

These shoes are amazing. Loved them the minute I put them on! They are comfortable, fit just as described, and are great for walking long distances. I have plantar fasciitis and need good arch support, which these provide. Plus they are very cute!

Very comfortable, felt very similar to my Venice H2 sandals (that I have lived in this summer). They do seem to run a tad big, but I always wear my M-J's with socks -- so it was a win for me.

It was instant love with these shoes. They are cushy, has great arch support (something I need help with) and is wide enough for my wide, wide feet. Also, unlike many other Mary Jane styles out there, the top part of the shoe was deep enough so it wasn\'t too tight and the straps are in a comfortable position. Finally, a pair of Mary Janes that fit my wide feet!

Very supportive shoes, good for standing all day or walking a lot in. Kind of clunky though, not a dainty shoe but comfort and support wins for me. If you get these and a part of the leather rubs you, just massage the leather and it will soften up. Also the original Murphy's Oil Soap, the thick kind, is a great leather cleaner and oiler, I grew up with horses and we always used it on our tack, mind you it will darken the leather. But it will also protect it.

I sell footwear for a living, and I also suffer from tendinitis in my left foot. So I am incredibly picky when picking out shoes for myself. That said, I love Keens, always have since I bought my first pair years ago. And these shoes do not disappoint! Keen has sort of revamped their classic style with the kind of big black toe cap. On this particular shoe it is smaller and more feminine looking. There is also a slight bit of a raise in the heel, which is actually good for your feet. The straps on these are stretchy too so you can slip them on without having to undo the buckle. They are very comfortable shoes, although they do run a bit big. I recommend them!