Customer Reviews KEEN Toyah MJ

I have incredibly high arches, and it's hard for me to find shoes that don't hurt. These Keens are so great - they already have a nice arch support, and combined with an additional Dr. Scholl's support, they're just perfect. Yay!

Rugged yet cute shoe. Unfortunately, it's not as comfortable for me as my regular Keen shoes. Keen shoes don't come in spring colors so I chose this shoe. It's good, but not great. It's a little too sloppy as a Maryjane since it's not as adjustable as a tie shoe.

I needed a comfortable shoe that I could wear with jeans or dressier pants. I have foot and back problems so I can't wear heels. I also have a small lift and orthotics so I'm always looking for shoes that will accommodate those. Keens usually fit the bill because of the removable insoles. These fit the lift just fine but if I have the orthotics in, my foot comes out a little when I walk. They are comfortable and look good. The only negative, besides the orthotics thing, is that they smell of leather so strongly for such a long time! It doesn't go away! It smells like I walked in a leather shop every time I have them on. Hopefully they will air out eventually, but it's been several weeks. I'd still buy them again though.

I like the style, but the fit was off. I realize that Keens run a bit roomy, but my other pair are not this wide. Bummer.

The Keen Mary Jane style backless clog I loved is no longer made, so I tired these instead, but have returned. These are not the same quality shoes that I was accustomed to. Why do they have to stop making first the styles I enjoy, and then secondly, why has the quality declined so. I owe several other Keen models, and hope they will last a long time.

It is very helpful for me to be able to order 2 sizes in a shoe that I think will work for me! I no longer drive so getting to a town that carries Keen shoes is difficult. I have spastic paraplegia and my toes drag. Tennis shoes are okay but the toes wear out fast as my toes drag when I walk and the toe protectors on the Keen shoes are great. One feet is a half size smaller than the other, so I'm never certain what size to order. Thanks for making it easy to try on shoes in the comfort of my own home without having the inconvenience of traveling.

These are one of the most comfortable shoes I own. I have big problems with bunions and need to wear orthotics. My orthotics fit in when I take out the liner and I am in total comfort. Love these!

In my experience, Keens run a little wide, which is good for me and my wide feet. The heel bed of this shoe is just a little bit too loose, but manageable. Other than that, these shoes are very comfortable.

This is a comfortable shoe. I liked the arch support, and it felt sturdy and cushioned, like a good walking shoe. There were two things I didn't like: the edge of the toe cap cut right across my bunion and it made my feet look enormous. Too bad, as I think it would it would make a comfortable walking shoe for anyone without bunions.

Love them! Very comfortable for all day wear. Stitching is not as red as it appears in stock photo.

These shoes are the bomb! I have several pairs of Keen shoes and I love them all. These are truly grey, which is so hard to find and they are very comfortable. They fit true to size and I will probably order them in another color soon. Zappos is the best.

Zappos has such good customer service. These shoes were sent so fast! The shoes are very comfortable, slightly heavier than expected but very stable and tough because of it. The soft grey color is beautiful. They are comfortably wide and have pretty good arch support. I ordered up half a size (normally take size 7, these are 7 1/2) and am happy with the fit.

They are very comfortable and easy. They are a slightly roomy 7.5 but that's fine because then you can comfortably wear comfy thick socks in the cold.

I teach, therefore I walk! Toyah MJ are pure comfort for my feet. At choir practice a friend came over asking about my neat shoes! These are steps up from the old tennis shoe. I can hardly wait to wear to school! The grey will go with everything. I ordered these (and another pair) in he afternoon and the giant Zappos box was on my front porch the next day! How do they do that?

Extremely comfy right out of the box! Only issue I have, I wore them without socks and they stained my toes black. ;) totally worth the comfort though! Love my Keens!

Physical therapists tell me that, because of my flat feet and over pronation, I need to change the kind of shoes I wear. I picked these because they have some level of cuteness, my Sole orthopedics fit in them, and they comply with other guidelines I was given. I bought them to wear on a trip (walking trip!) to Ireland and they were perfect! They are as comfortable as tennis shoes but have a dressier appearance. Because they are all black, I don't think they have as clownish an appearance that I feel many Keen shoes have. I wear a size 8 or 39 in European sizes, yet I wear a 7.5 in this shoe.

Really like this shoe. But I did find when ordering my typical size I needed a half a size smaller.

Very comfortable shoes but I have to wear them with socks. The front of shoe is wider than it look sin the picture but I still like the look.

So far I like them. Haven't had a chance to use for more than 2 hours. Would like to see more elastic in the strap.

These shoes were out-of-the-box comfortable. I received them at work, put them on and worked a full day in them. I only want to wear these at work. My feet say ah when I put them on. They are true to size.

I'm a huge lover of Keens. They fit my wide forefoot very well. This style was adorable and runs a bit larger than most Keens. I usually wear a 6 in a closed Keen with laces, but settled on this one in a 5. I was tempted by a 5 1/2 because, like all Keens, the forefoot runs wide, but not deep, so sometimes your toes will hit the top of the shoe. If it's a soft shoe, it's okay, but this is not. This shoe is substantial with lots of support. The fit in the heel is a little wide, but the up and down movement doesn't bother me a bit - it reminds me a little of a closed Dansko in that regard, but not as rigid or loose. I look forward to using it as my spring walking shoe, for occasions when a sneaker isn't entirely appropriate.

Comfy shoes, took a little breaking in, about a day or so. Only big issue, they leave the bottoms of my feet black! The problem is getting better with more wear, as the dye is wearing off onto my feet. I have a brown pair with light colored insoles and do not have this problem.

I wore my last pair of Keen mjs until I wore through the sole. I had to break that pair in pretty extensively, but not these! I have wide, high volume feet, and I can't remember the last pair of shoes besides running shoes that I could wear out of the box. I am literally considering buying all three colors.

Fantastic shoes! Comfortable and dressy, I can hike in these shoes and also wear the with a skirt...great arch support, excellent styling. I love Keens!

This was my first time ever ordering shoes on-line. But felt reassured when I learned of the Zappos return/replace policy, free shipping/365 days. There was no need for any of the above. The shoes arrived, the fit was good, the looks were great, just what I wanted. Thank you, Zappos.