Customer Reviews KEEN Toyah MJ

These shoes are great in almost every way; the fit, the comfort, and the style. The one negative is the strap. To make it easier to find the hole when you buckle the shoe, they used a piece of elastic as the anchor for the strap on the non-buckle side. It wears out very quickly just from normal tugging. I hope that Keen will keep making this style, but with a hook and loop or Velcro strap instead.

I love these and own three pairs in dark earth, black, and gargoyle. After the birth of my daughter, I went from a 7 1/2 to an 8 in size. I like to have lots of room for my toes and the ball of my foot. I bought a 7 1/2 in these, and it is perfect without socks or with very thin trouser socks. I was worried that they might cut into the top of my foot, but that hasn't been a problem. I had to finish punching the holes (ice pick) in the black pair, and that pair has also had the most stretch in the strap. They are comfortable for walking. I prefer to have knee highs on if I am going very far to prevent rubbing on my little toe and the ball of my foot.

I think these shoes run big. I wear 8.5 in their clogs, but have bought size 9 for their more enclosed shoes. But these are too long and quite loose in the heel for me. Think I'd still have the heel problem with a smaller size. The shoe is a little heavy, also. But, still cute!

Awesome shoe, it seems to run a half size large compared to other Keen's I have purchased.

These shoes are true to size but seemed to run a little wide. Also the color is not a brown-more of a reddish color. For that reason I have to return them. Very little arch support.

Unfortunately I had to send back this pair of Keen Toyah MJ's. They were well-made, but seemed to be loose on my feet. Most Keens seem very true to size, but these seemed to run large.

These shoes were very comfortable. I bought them for lots of walking on my European vacation. I took them out of the box on the way to the airport, no blisters! I wore them with and without socks. While they were a bit clunkier than shoes I am used to, they certainly earned their place as a great travel shoe.

I never know whether to get a 5&12 or a 6. These seemed a half size larger and the heel is loose, but they are very comfortable.

Beautiful shoe, and the green is perfect! However, I have a narrow foot and even sizing down 1/2 didn't do it. Sadly, they are going back.

Great shoe, very comfortable. In general, size 5 is a little too big, but wearable. This shoe in a size 5 was too big, but I wore them with thick socks and it fit OK (but didn't look great).

Rugged yet cute shoe. Unfortunately, it's not as comfortable for me as my regular Keen shoes. Keen shoes don't come in spring colors so I chose this shoe. It's good, but not great. It's a little too sloppy as a Maryjane since it's not as adjustable as a tie shoe.

I like the style, but the fit was off. I realize that Keens run a bit roomy, but my other pair are not this wide. Bummer.

Really like this shoe. But I did find when ordering my typical size I needed a half a size smaller.

Very comfortable shoes but I have to wear them with socks. The front of shoe is wider than it look sin the picture but I still like the look.

So far I like them. Haven't had a chance to use for more than 2 hours. Would like to see more elastic in the strap.

A very good, comfortable shoe. Insole is excellent for arches. The color does tend to rub off onto my big toes. But it is still worth it to have this excellent shoe.

I love this shoe! I was able to wear it right out of the box without any breaking in. The only thing I would change is the gray part on the side, it makes the shoe look a bit goofy and more sporty than I would prefer for a work shoe. It would be nice if it was just all black. This shoe fits pretty loose on my foot, but after wearing Dansko professionals for years, that is the fit I prefer.

These shoes were comfortable right out of the box and didn't need breaking in. Because of other reviews I read, I ordered a 1/2 size smaller and they were right. The next 1/2 size up (my normal size in other shoes) would have been too big.

First of all I have to compliment Zappos on their excellent service again! I ordered these shoes in the evening and had them by 11 a.m. the next day. Unfortunately I found these shoes to be too big and clunky looking. I have another pair of Keens that I love and will try another style.

I'm a big Keen fan - I have 9 pair. These run really large. I wear 8½ pretty consistently with this brand. I had to go a half size smaller and still my foot nearly slips out of the shoe when I walk. I put a pad in and that helped. Really comfortable otherwise.

Super comfortable, Note: they run about a 1/2 size larger than usual. I didn't believe the other reviews, because I have a wide foot, but I did end up sending them back and getting a smaller size. I agree with most of the good reviews. One thing that I noticed that no one else mentioned, was these shoes make my feet kind of hot. Not a lot of ventilation. That's my only downside though. I would order another pair again!

The top of the shoe does not feel high enough for my foot. I have been wearing Keens religiously for 4-5 years, and this one just doesn't do it for me. The leather is very thick, and the shoe is otherwise comfortable, but maybe for my high arches I just need more height in the footbed area. The width feels good.

I usually wear an 8 in Keen but these felt wider then usual. Cute shoe, but not a good fit for me. Think the 7.5 will be too short. Too bad.

I had high hopes for this shoe as a great walking shoe for traveling that was not a sneaker. It has a great sole and is super comfortable and supportive. Unfortunately, it runs super wide, so it was not a good fit for my skinny feet.

This shoe fits differenly than all the other Keens I have bought in the past. I have bought over a dozen Keens. This cut in around the top of the foot and loose around the heel.