Customer Reviews KEEN Toyah MJ

Super comfy for all-day wear. I found the 9 a little too short in the toe, but the 9.5 was a tad roomy, especially in the width, so I added a generic drug-store footbed liner under the flexible Keen liner, and I am set - a perfect fit! Paired with SmartWool socks, they will be ideal for fall and winter - much cuter, warmer, and more weather resistant than regular athletic shoes. After several weeks of wear they have conformed nicely to my foot, and I can slip them on and off as needed without using the buckle each time. I think these will be my errand shoes for the next few years! The only issue is that if you have a very narrow foot, these may not work for you.

These shoes are so comfy and versatile! They do run a bit roomy, but they're still comfortable to walk in even with bare feet. I work in an office, so I'm very happy to have comfortable, sturdy shoes for walking that still pass the dress code. I do believe these are my new favorite shoes!

Love my new Keen Toyah's! This brand name has never let me down so far. Great support and extremely comfortable. I do find the shoes to be a tiny bit loose in the heel, but I have not worn them with socks yet. Keen shoes are expensive, but in my experience, worth every penny! They are like the wonderful Zappos, they just never let you down!

I wear a lot of Keens. These are one of the most comfortable pairs from the get go. Padded just above the heel, so no blisters in the back. Very good foot bed contours. They look like the picture. I am very happy!

What can I really say about these shoes? They are fantastic. I have been touring around great Britain on holiday and these shoes have not given me one blister since putting them on. Whether traveling on holiday or running around the office, these are great shoes.

These shoes are so super comfortable right out of the box - they look great with jeans, skirts, capris, and also go great with socks of any color! I love this reddish brown color for fall - this shoe has great arch support and I look forward to wearing them all winter.

I love these shoes, great arch support, wonderful for standing all day at a job. Cute, good looking shoes. I especially love the red brick color, these are my favorite pair of shoes for work. I even find myself wearing them for casual purposes and just out walking the dog too. They are that good. Keen seems to make a few kinds of shoes: the flimsy, the moderate support and the major support. I'd classify these as the major support kind of Keens (and that's the way I like it).

I loved these shoes, but will have to return them due to size. In previous Keens I have ordered I have had to go up a size, but these seem to run true to the size I usually wear. They are extremely comfortable and I love the look. I will be hoping that these become available in my size.

These shoes are amazing. Loved them the minute I put them on! They are comfortable, fit just as described, and are great for walking long distances. I have plantar fasciitis and need good arch support, which these provide. Plus they are very cute!

I have several pair of keens. I wear a size 8 in all shoes, including keens. These are huge! They are not just a little bit big...they are big! They are super cute and comfy from what I can tell. Why are they so big?? Back to the drawing board.

Okay, so I loved these shoes online. I wear a size nine normally and all of my Keens are nines. However, when I received the size 9 they were way to big. I ended up with an 8 1/2 and kind of think some days they are still big. But an 8 is too small. I wear them at work and love them. I wish Zappos carried them in more different and fun colors. But overall another great buy from Zappos and Keen!

I have wide feet with plantar fasciitis and must wear an orthotic. Its hard for me to find shoes that are cute and comfortable AND that can accommodate my orthotic. These are nice. I wore them all day yesterday and did a lot of walking. They are well made and as usual with the Keen brand, they are made of high quality materials. However, the sizing on these shoes runs LARGE. I wear a size 6. I ordered and received a size 6 and they were huge! i returned them and ordered both a size 5 and 5.5. Ended up keeping the size 5 and even then my feet have a bit of room lengthwise. Also, I have a high instep and while these aren't uncomfortable they could be a bit looser on the instep. also I need a bit more length in the strap. But then again, I have problem feet. Other than that these are great!

Love these shoes, but the 7.5 (my regular size) only fits with really thick socks and the 7 is too short. I wish Keen would be consistent with their sizing.

I love these shoes, particularly since they come up high enough on the top and are wider than average so they don't press against my bunions or hurt the tops of my feet. Most mary jane styles don't work for me and I think this one will. It seems longer than a regular size 6.5 so I just ordered them in a size 6.0 and am returning the 6.5. I gave them 4 stars in overall and style just because they seem much longer than my other Keens in the same size.

I love the color of the shoe. The photo is accurate. I've had these shoes for several months and have worn them daily. The one thing I don't like is there is a stretchy band under the buckle, so now the shoes have to be sewn back because the band has worn out and the shoe is now too loose.

I agree with another reviewer - they run a bit big in the back part of the shoe. My heel slips out. I'm normally a 5.5 or 6. But going to try the 5, which I've never worn in my life but this style shoe seems to be wider than other Keens. They do seem like they'll be very comfortable though!

I basically love these shoes & have bought many pairs. They are immediately comfortable, provide good support for a Mary Jane style and are not bad-looking for walking shoes. The only problem is the elastic on one end of the buckle strap. It wears out fast since you pull on it each time you put the shoes on. Even being as gentle as you can, it will not last more than three months, long before the rest of the shoe needs replacement. Note to Keens: please replace this system with a Velcro strap! Or at least make similar shoes with that option.

For me, after trying several pairs of shoes for upcoming trip with lots of walking and these felt the best - good arch support and comfortable right out of the box. Sporty looking too.

Comfortable shoe. I take a wide width but in the Keen I just take a half size larger and it fits fine. Love that it looks nice & yet is water proof if a wet day.

I really like these shoes in every respect except the foot bed which is nothing short of flimsy. I recently purchased from a replacement footbed by Smart Foot. What a difference these made to my Keens! I very pleased with the resulting comfort.

Extremely comfortable. Cushy for walking and standing around on hard floors. Not ugly; just a bit clumpy. Pretty color; goes with everything.

Love these shoes but am returning them because the color just isn't right for me.

I bought these with high expectations after reading the reviews but they were way too big and the 'gargoyle' color was much darker than the grey I was expecting (more a 'stone'). I have wide feet and buy hiking and athletic shoes a size bigger (like the Keens boots and hikers I've owned for years). I'll try my regular size when I re-order. Zappos delivery at light speed as usual!

I wanted to love these shoes.They were super comfortable but the heel was too loose. They slipped and nothing helped; I hate to return but I must.

These are great shoes, but they run huge. I have wide feet and I usually wear an 8½. I ordered these in an 8 and had to send them back as they practically fell off of my feet.