Customer Reviews Allen Edmonds McAllister

About two months in and it has become my favorite color and fit. If you are on the fence, go ahead and put these in the closet. You won't be sorry.

I have had Allen Edmonds shoes through the years and these continue to live up to their great heritage. Smart looking and comfortable!

I bought these a few weeks ago and I absolutely love them. Can't go wrong with Allen Edmonds

Well made and comfortable. No need to break them in. Love them

Great shoe that I've come to expect from Allen Edmonds.

I have had brown McAllister wingtips about 8 years and I just purchased this pair in black. They are both excellent and true to size.

I can say that I am very happy with this shoe. I have been sized for AE products at the SF brick and mortar location (great, friendly service there), so sizing was very easy. I have worn these all day and walked quite far in them with no pain. The color is very attractive and matches many outfits.

I've been wearing Allen Edmonds shoes for over twenty years and I have to say they are the best shoes I've ever owned. I wanted to update my wing tip collection and the McAllister was my go to choice. This shoe was first introduced by AE in the mid-fifties and has stood the test of time. I can't resist timeless classics. The shoes are pretty comfortable right out of the box, but get even better after several wearings. I've had no issues with the fit or comfort with these shoes. Another reason I like AE is because of the wide range of sizes and widths. I have a narrow foot and it's almost impossible to find my size in most other brands. I can always count on finding my size that fits perfectly and a style I really like at AE, the McAllister is no exception. Finally, the fact I can have the shoes recrafted is a definite plus. I've had several pairs recrafted over the years and find the service to be top quality and greatly extends the life of my shoes. These shoes are well worth their cost in the long run. I highly recommend AE and McAllisters.

I ordered these expecting them to be a Tan or British Tan with brown burnishing on the toes, but they came as a solid medium brown. When I tried them on and they fit perfectly and were very comfortable. However, the color doesn't match my style so I ended up returning turn.

I own two pair of McAllister wingtips and love them. Bought this pair for my grandson when he graduated from college. He loves them.

First time wearing felt like I'd been wearing forever! Great shoe!

The quality and craftsmanship is great. Best value. Highly recommended

Love these shoes they truly are beautiful high quality shoes. The craftsmanship is amazing. If you only own one pair of shoes I would definitely recommend these McAllister's wingtips walnut shoes. You can dress them up or down. I'm so glad I bought them.

Absolutely beautiful shoe. That's is very well made with great craftsmanship. I'm so happy I bought these shoes. They truly are great quality shoes and the price is perfect. I would highly recommend these shoes.

I have a half dozen McAllister wingtips. I enjoy everone of them. I probably would not have purchased as many as I have but I love the Dainite Rubber Sole. This is a sole they did not offer to the best of my knowledge when I purchased many of my older purchases. I live in the midwest and they are fantact winter shoes. We ride motorcycle in the summer and the Dainite Rubber Sole is fantastic for stability when holding up a 900 lb bike. Just to give you an idea of durability some of my leather sole shoes are over 15 years old and people still say things like COOL SHOES .

A classic and with comfort. Shoe I ordered was walnut in color and is comfortable. In fact, I put it in third place behind the Jefferson and Harrison - the two best Allen Edmonds ever made. They are that good.

I purchased the walnut color and received so many compliments on their appearance. They are gorgeous shoes and worth the price. I passionately recommend getting these shoes. They go great with a suit or wear them with a light-wash pair of jeans to dress them up.

These shoes are phenomenal. The fit is amazing, and walking in them all day feels great. Definitely a must have!

I own a pair of Strand cap toe oxfords that I really love. But when the time came for me to buy another pair of dress shoes in a different color, I decided to branch out and try another Allen Edmonds' style (the McAllister wingtip oxford in chili). The McAllister is a nicely made shoe, but I couldn't get over how much longer they looked than my Strands (that are the same size), and I didn't like that the perforations on the wingtip extended over the end of my toe all the way to the welt - it lessened the appeal of the aesthetic from my perspective. Since I ended up exchanging these for another pair of Strands, I'd say it's obvious that I'm still an Allen Edmonds fan. I guess I'm just writing this review with the hope that it might encourage Allen Edmonds to consider a few new additions to their great lineup of dress shoes.

I love Allen-Edmonds but these shoes are not quite to par with my other ones. The sole has separated from the shoe in the toe section.