Customer Reviews Allen Edmonds McAllister

These are really nice, everything about these shoes is perfect... I absolutely love them.

A must have, bought this pair after my 10 year old ones finally are needing to retire

My husband has these in the walnut color and liked them very much. I ordered the black color, but didn't realize there were two different sole options. Customer service did an exceptional job of exchanging for the dainite sole. He's pleased with the appearance and the comfort and fit of the shoe.

I'm glad I purchased these dark Chili McAllisters, they look good and feel great when I wear them I got the dainite sole on mines and wear them with pride, they look good with multiple outfits Thanks Allen Edmonds for making a premium pair of men's shoes.

Previously owned an Allen Edmonds pair of wing tips in D width. They initially were a little tight but eventually worked out OK. I had 30+ years. This time I ordered E width and they are incredibly tight and hurt my feet.

Best shoes made in the US, more of an investment than shoes. I have strangers look down and admire my shoes? Crazy. Some even say " Allen Edmonds?". They look great, fit great. They speak for themselves.

Second pair of AE shoes ordered on-line. This one and previous order fit well with my size that I have had for decades. A little darker brown than indicated in the pictures which is good for me. No discomfort during break in.

Great shoes and very comfortable. I certainly appreciate the quality of Allen Edmonds.

This is one of dozen of Allen Edmonds I bought since I was 25 yrs old. This is the second McAllister I have (suede was the first one) and I love it: perfect fit and no problem even on the first day.

Always love Allen Edmonds shoes. I have to wear a EEE wide shoe and currently AE is the only manufacturer that offers this product. All other shoe manufacturers have gone to only an E wide or you have to order a size bigger, and the shoe never really fits. Thanks AE for a great product, and wonderful service

Great style as always. Which is the only reason I return....absolutely horrendous quality control. Variance with hand made items is fine. But large color variance, crooked parts of shoe are all very noticeable. I have to order 2-3 at once to pick the "least problematic" of them. Please listen to your customers, i'm not the only one calling this out.

The only thing I regret about these is not buying the oxblood version when it was available, but that's ok because I got them in dark chili instead! Enjoyable wear anytime

I have been wearing Allen Edmonds shoes for 30 years. AE is among a very select few shoe companies still making their products right here in America. Top quality, and when it is time to renew them with fresh soles, heels, laces and a good cleaning, shine and polish, it is so convenient to just go online and submit the appropriate recrafting order before dropping them off at FEDEX OFFICE. I did just that before my present trip to Florida and I already have an email saying that they are ready to ship back to me. Always an excellent job well done and on time.

It is a proud, classic design. I recommend your classic shoes to others. I will order more over time.

I expedited a great deal more. Clearly when I ordered a wide pair of shoes they did not deliver. Not even close to being right. The ship time was poor and was the refund time. Dude t CD even come close to my awesome Johnson Murphy's.

The size isn't close to the correct size. I order width E but they were very narrow.

I've had these for several months now. They have broken in well and take a great shine. I'm please with the quality of the leather and the craftsmanship. I bought these on the Allen Edmonds website and got help through their chat to determine my proper size. They fit just fine. I keep them shined up and I look for opportunities to wear them whenever I can. Thank you for a great shoe.

I bought my shoes in 1985. I don't wear them everyday but I will say this is the most comfortable shoe that I own and they still look new.

Bending at toes when I walk so it creased. Low quality product and I'm not happy.

Love these shoe, they are very comfortable and extremely stylish

Wonderful dress shoe. Excellent quality and can be dressed up or down!

Will not shine. Stays dull, even after high gloss polish.

Made in the USA. Can be resoled. Real craftsmanship. Classic styling that will never looked dated. Wide sizes available. What's not to like?

Beautiful Shoe! Love the color, love wingtips, and feels like a quality product that will service me for years to come!

A beautiful, well constructed shoe. I had to get it in another color too!