Customer Reviews KEEN Calistoga

Love these shoes - I am so pleased with my order. Not only did they arrive the very next day; they were everything I wanted. Cute, supportive and comfortable. Thanks!!

Cute and Comfy - Finally! A cute Keen. As usual they run on the wide side and I have a narrow foot. But this doesn't bother me. I am a pretty standard 8 but have found that Keens, in the past, are not long enough and my big toe always bumps up against the end. But not this time. There is plenty of room in the toe box.

Comfortable from the start - A funky Mary Jane. I was able to wear them all day the first time I put them on...with medium weight socks. Nice bounce in the heel and plenty of toe room.

A great shoe for wide feet - Recovering from ankle surgery, my right foot is wider than my left and finding shoes that fit seems impossible. Plus my foot has always measured a whopping EEE width anyway. I highly recommend this shoe for high instepped women as well. It's low enough in front to not cut. It breaks in quickly and I get lots of compliments. I have two pairs.

Keen Calistoga - Keens are wonderful! Super comfortable and easy to wear. This pair is no exception!

Best shoes ever! This is my third pair of Keens. I have bought different styles and I have been extremely pleased with all of them. What a great comfortable, cute shoe!

Formidable Woman - At 55, one is (hopefully) a fully grown bear. My new red Keen Calistoga's help define my image and protect my feet. They say I am mobile, fit, strong, a cool Granny, and a fun lover, a woman who will get to where she out to go, perhaps on foot. A woman who can out run you, or stand and deliver. The red signals my nonconformist heart. I wear these shoes to meetings with the Rector at my Episcopal parish, to late lunches with the love of my life at that little French place, and when I am eating chocolates with my jazz piano-playing grandson. They match my red lipstick, and make it look even better, because when my feet are comfortable, I smile more. A lot more.

Great shoe! I received my little red Calistoga’s in the usual two days and wore them to work the next day. No discomfort or breaking in period. This is my umteenth pair of Keens and I love them!

Loved it, but... It is so cute! I loved the way it looks, but, I have to wear hard insoles that take up a lot of room. The insoles that come in the shoe are removable, but they didn't feel as comfy without them. The shoes insoles are really cushy. I would recommend them for anyone who doesn't have to add special insoles. Also, I think they look cuter than in the picture.

Another winner from Keen! First I would like to say is that order your NORMAL size in this style of Keen. I normally wear a 9 medium to wide. I took the advice of other reviewers and ordered a 9 in this style and it fits perfect! I have several other Keens and they are 9 1/2 & 10's. So these run true to size. I have only worn them a handful of times but had no problems and my feet never asked to be free of shoes anytime during the day. They are a very cute comfy shoe.

Mary Janes with Spunk - I loved these Keens; they were perfect out of the box. Enough room in the toe box. I tried ordering 1/2 smaller with the Zoes and they fit well and I have no complaints. These I ordered in an 11 and they are more than perfect. I can't wait to get my husband a pair of Keen Sandal this summer.

First pair of shoes I have ever purchased that fit perfect and didn't hurt my feet at al the first time I wore them. They're great!!!

Love my Calistogas - Love these shoes. I have other Keen's and these are pretty true to the fit of my others. Love the style. Only negative I have is that they don't have the arch support that my Sydney's have - so may not be as comfortable a walking shoe over distance.

Great shoes - Beautiful shoes but not at all for narrow feet. I can't use them without socks. Very comfortable for long walks. Felt true to size. I still Love them!!!

I bought two pairs! I bought two pairs in carneilan and driftwood. I got them 1/2 size bigger, but I had to return them and get the regular size. They're comfy, but since I have a very high arch, I don't really feel the arch support. I am thinking about buying them in black also.

Ssuper cute Keens - These Keen mary janes are great. One word of advice though - definitely order your true size in this shoe. Usually I have to go up 1/2 size in Keen shoes, so I ordered a bigger size. They were huge! I ordered another pair in my regular size and they fit great, so stick to your regular size for this style. They feel super comfy and look adorable.

Another great Keen Mary Jane - I love this shoe. It will be my new favorite, I can tell. My only thing I would change is the color of the Driftwood, almost too light for me. Other than that, the detailing is adorable and makes my shoes a little bit more feminine.

The Most Comfortable Shoe Ever - These shoes far exceeded my expectations. They are extremely comfortable (most important) right out of the box and I get tons of compliments on them. I have nothing negative to say about these shoes! :)

Keen Calistoga - So far, I have found these Keen's to be the most comfortable. And that is saying quite a lot since I have almost all styles.

Keen Calistoga - I first heard of Keen when I saw someone in a store wearing them. After searching online, I decided to buy them at Zappos because the customer service was very helpful. I read many reviews about other Keen shoes prior to purchasing. Most of them said to size up. I have a little wider than normal feet and have difficulty fitting into most medium widths. I did not have to size up at all in the Keen line and have plenty of room for my feet. Absolutely love these shoes and am going to buy a sandal for summer. Thanks Zappos. Also, the delivery time is very fast compared to most merchants. I have bought 3 items from Zappos in the past couple of months and have been impressed with the service and delivery time.

Keen Calistoga - This is a great Keen shoe. I ordered my usual "half size up" that I usually do in Keens, and found that was too big. I decided to check if I was just imagining it, and took the footbed out and saw that it was indeed a half size bigger than my Bronx and my Sydney--so Keen changed it's sizing for this shoe. It was too wide and too long on my foot. I returned it and got my normal size (8.5) and it fits perfectly! I am super picky about comfort, and this is one pair I am keeping! It is very cute with the little cut out flowers and embroidery, and has a much more feminine look than other Keen shoes. Looks cute with jeans and Smartwool socks!

Great look - These are the cutest shoes! They are comfortable, although not as heavenly as most of my other Keens (I have many pairs). The arch support is not as good as the Seattle or Sydney, and they fit looser. I haven't worn them too much yet, so can't speak to all day comfort, but I'm sure they will be fine. I do love the cut out design on these. They seem more true to size than my others, but I ordered a half size larger anyway. I might order my true size for comparison.

Another cool Keen! These are the Mary Janes of my dreams...sporty, comfy with cute detailing, and they look cute with jeans or skirts. I do think they run a little small (I bought Saratoga’s and thought the same thing). Half a size up from the usual worked just right.

I bought these shoes for an upcoming trip to Europe, so I\'ve been wearing them in over the past month. I have wide feet with a normal arch, and these shoes fit those parameters very well. My only complaint about them is the fact that the leather has a rough edge that rubs the top of my feet raw by the end of the day. I wear a clear band-aid over the area to prevent discomfort and am optimistic that this problem will eventually go away. Other than that, they are extremely comfortable to stand and walk in, so I\'m quite pleased with my purchase. The color is faily true to the picture and they look cute with casual clothes (especially jeans).