Customer Reviews KEEN Calistoga

First Keens - After reading all the reviews about comfort and size. I ordered my normal size 10, when I first tried them on I thought they were too small. So I ordered the 11 (which are like boats and sometimes I wear 11). But after having the 11 on, I tried the 10 again and I think that what I was feeling as "small" is actually the way the rubber toe box comes over the top of the shoe. It was worth the effort because I think these are soo cute. Zappos is so fast, it's great!

Excellent shoe - I have been wearing this shoe for a couple of weeks now. No blisters, no pain. I wore socks the first couple of outings, but now go without. I love these casual, cute shoes!

Most comfortable shoe . . . evah! Love these shoes! They were comfortable right out of the box, and my orthotic inserts even fit with no problem. I have "difficult feet" (painful plantar fasciitis and wide forefoot), and have a hard time finding shoes that are comfortable all day long. These fit the bill, and are cute, too!

Great shoe! I get tons of compliments on this shoe and I've had no blisters or irritation as I do with some shoes. I can go all day in it and it's very rugged. The kids are constantly stepping on my feet (I don't know why!), but it has no scuff marks or anything. I got it for those days when you want to be comfortable and stylish and don't feel like flip-flops. My only complaint is that sometimes when I take my foot out of the shoe, the insole comes out with my foot. It always just plops back into place, but it is slightly annoying. I'm enjoying them and not regretting the price!

Great Buy! It's hard to find a comfortable travel shoe that also looks cute. I received many compliments on this shoe although it is a tad clunky looking. This shoe was great for moderate hiking to urban trekking. I do recommend wearing socks if you are thin skinned as they will cause blisters. Overall it's a great and versatile shoe!

Cutest and most Comfortable Shoe - I purchased the Keen Calistoga because I was looking for a comfortable shoe that was also attractive that people would pay attention to. The shoe is adorable and so comfortable! And people ask me everytime I wear them, who makes them and where I got them!

Calistoga’s are great shoes - I ordered red Calistoga’s at 1:30pm on a Thursday, and received them by 2pm on Friday. The shoes are very comfortable- The best part is I can dress them up or down. Keen makes a great product and Zappos has wonderful service. Thanks!

Comfy shoe, a little wide but will be ok with socks. As always great service from Zappos.

Great shoe! This shoe is super comfortable right out of the box! No blisters, no breaking them in!! I’ve been wearing them everyday since I bought them.

Best shoes ever! I think Keen caught on to the size problem that people were talking about because I usually wear between a 9 and 9.5, but 9.5 was sold out so I tried a 9 and they fit perfectly! These shoes are so comfortable and they are the perfect compromise between functional and cute! I absolutely love them!

Zappos you rock!! I cannot believe it, I received these in actually less than 24hours, and I live in the middle of nowhere. Anyway this was my first Zappos purchase and it will definitely not be my last. Thanks! Now to the shoes, I have always wanted to get a pair of Keen's, but I have only really seen the sandals on other people and I was afraid they would make my feet look huge. I just started a waitressing job and needed something cute and comfortable, plus I recently had a baby and I wanted a shoe that I could wear and keep up with her. The Keen Calistoga is my perfect hybrid of cute and functional, I ordered an 8.5 they fit my feet perfectly; I don't even feel like they will really need to break in. If I was to wear socks with them I may want a 9, but I will only wear them barefooted or with tights, so no problems, again thanks Zappos.

Casual Comfort - I really like these shoes!! At first they rubbed the back of my right heel a little. But now I wear them almost every day. They do well when I have to stand most of the day and are comfy to run around in doing errands. They are a dressier style for Keen but are still very casual. I wear them with pants, shorts, skirts, capris, etc. Only negative is that you have to buckle and unbuckle them to get on and off. But I don't really mind that at all.

Love 'em - I love these shoes. Zappos was great. I ordered the shoes at 3:00 in the afternoon and got my shoes the next morning. I bought two sizes because of the reviews that I read about them not true to size. I believe they are true to size and maybe a little bigger than my normal shoe size. It could be because the shoe is a little wider than most of my shoes. I highly recommend these shoes if you want a pair that are comfortable from the first step. The price is well worth it!!!

Perfect! The shoes are great! Extremely comfortable and very chic.

Walking shoes - Keen shoes are the most comfortable shoes. I wore them all over the cobblestone streets of Europe and my feet and legs never got tired.

I read the reviews and based on comments, I ordered a half size larger, in order to compensate for my wide feet and the strap. The shoes, for me feel slightly on the large size, but if I went a half size smaller, they would have been too tight. I am a nurse and the shoes are comfortable and my legs do not ache after working for 10- 12 hours.

LOVE these shoes - I absolutely love Keen shoes, and these are no exception. The fit is great for my wide feet that often hurt. I can wear these to work with chinos, and they are perfect.

Great shoe - I bought these in red, they are adorable and comfortable. I bought one half size larger than I normally wear, and they are perfect. Very roomy toe box and very well cushioned. Received them the very next day after ordering!

Too wide - These are way too wide. I have never had to buy narrow shoes, I just don't think these are made for a "normal" foot. Too bad, they are really cute!

Love These Shoes - Really, really cute and comfortable. Also great for walking.

KEEN CALISTOGA - I just received my shoes (WOW-free overnight) and absolutely love - love - love them!! Finally, a shoe made for wide feet. These shoes are so comfortable. As I had read the reviews, I ordered a half-size bigger (wear a 9 1/2 & ordered a 10) and they fit perfect. Thumbs up to Keen for making this comfortable and cute sporty Mary-Jane.

Keen Calistoga - I am really enjoying this shoe. :) First of all, they are soo cute. :) Secondly, I have short, fat feet, but they accommodate me well in a regular size 5. This is my first pair of Keens and I like them. I usually wear a wide. I did put in orthotic inserts at my husband's suggestion, but that's because I like extra arch support. We are going to Paris and Germany, and I plan to use them for everything (casual and dressing up). I think they will work fine. :)

Love them! This shoe is extremely comfortable and very cute! I can wear them all day long and my legs and feet don't hurt. I work in a restaurant and have a lot of trouble finding shoes...but these are great!

Fun yet rugged... This shoe is very comfortable (as are all Keen shoes in my opinion) but it's rugged while looking cute with skirts too. So, when you've got a lot of errands to run or you're on vacation and you need comfy shoes that look great with a variety of outfits, this shoe foots the bill, if you'll pardon the pun!

Great shoe - I get compliments on this shoe whenever I wear it, which is a lot. Very cute and more feminine than some super comfy shoes, and it is super comfy. Loves Keens!