Customer Reviews KEEN Calistoga

I just bought a second pair of these, after wearing mine out from overuse! These are the best shoes ever. I wear them with socks on cold days, perfect. I wear them without socks on warm days, perfect. I recently took a one-week trip to NY and DC, and these are the only shoes I took. We had rain and wind for a few days, and temps over 80 degrees for a few days. These shoes were perfect for the whole trip.

I bought these same shoes in a turquoise color a couple of years ago and loved them. The purple are really pretty as well. I use them for work shoes where I stand all day. They are very comfortable, great looking, and come in fun colors. I get lots of compliments on them. I did however, buy one half size smaller on the second pair. The larger size felt good but roomy, but they stretched enough for me to try the smaller size. The smaller size are perfect. Cute shoes!

I love these shoes. I bought the same shoes two years ago in green and wore them all the time. These are a replacement pair. I have wide feet, and these are very roomy and comfortable. They don’t require any breaking in. I wear them for dog walking, errands, etc. They are a nice upgrade from sneakers in terms of style, but they are just as comfortable.

These shoes are very comfortable. I love that they have a removable footbed that allows me to insert my orthotics. They are adorable too. I'm a big fan of Keen shoes.

Love my new Keens. We just had some physical therapy and many of the therapists were wearing shoes of this style so I asked about them. The therapists are on their feet all day. They said they are the next best thing to athletic shoes and are much better looking. Mine are very comfortable. They would be really cool(Keen)on me if I were 20 years younger, but I just find them fun and different. I will buy again.

Had to search all over for these shoes, and of course Zappos was the only place I found them in my size :) Love these shoes! The cutest comfy shoes around. Good for folks with wider feet, or bunions. Keens in general are great for these reasons, and good soles. Not much arch support, but still comfy. Wish they still made this style :(

Thanks Zappos for GREAT service, fast shipping and easy, no hassle returns!! First Keen shoe I purchased, recommended from my foot doctor...because I have bunions. Excellent choice of shoes for bunions. Love them. true to size. Moderate arch. Very comfortable. Keen makes great shoes...tried the Calistoga sandal but it was too narrow in the toe area. But this shoe is great for wide feet. I can wear them all day and my feet feel great at the end of the day. Had to write a review because I read a ton of them before buying any of the Keen shoes I did and found the reviews very helpful. Just bought my second pair. LOVE Zappos.com!

Keen Calistoga's are super comfortable and great for work if you are on your feet all day. I am an art teacher and they have washed up nice after suffering from a spill. At first the strap and heel rubbed against my foot, but after a week of consistent wear, they stretched a bit and have not bothered me since. They are super cute as well!

I love my Calistogas-I have 2 pair-it’s like wearing slippers all day-super comfortable. I also love that my second pair came the very next day at no shipping charge or tax charge. The price you see is the price you pay. Customer service w/ Zappos is great! I plan on getting another pair next pay day. I may not wear any other kind of shoe they are so comfortable! At my age comfort comes before beauty!

The Calistogas are my 4th pair of Keens purchased in the past 6 months, and I am a total Keen convert! I previously thought Merrells were the best, with Haflingers a close 2nd, but Keen is my new favorite. Keen's quality and comfort, combined with Zappos excellent customer service and free overnight shipping make shoe shopping a pleasure! I use a walker, so I'm challenged in footwear, but Keens are both comfortable and supportive. The one thing I did notice about the Calistogas were that they did take a bit longer to break in, unlike the Cheyenne Lace and the Ellie Clog-both of which felt perfect right out of their boxes. I should have paid more attention to the reviews regarding size, though. I usually wear a 9, but in Keens get a 9 1/2. The Calistogas were truer to size than the other Keens I wear. But a thicker sock took care of that, so it's all good. Plus, if you have a problem with your feet swelling, it's good insurance to have that extra "wiggle room". I love these shoes - you will too!

I love these shoes. They are very comfortable. I wear them waiting tables…and by the end of an 8 hour shift my feet can swell a little. These shoes are wide and never pinch in any way. The soles are made of a very strong material and will not wear out quickly. I would definitely buy them again.

This is probably the best shoe I've ever owned. I have a wide foot in the toe area with a narrow heel. I also have a high arch, so the adjustable strap is nice. I like them because they are feminine but very sturdy. The only negative is that the black ones I just ordered seem to come up much higher on the top of my feet than the other colors I have--can't explain this because they are all the same style. However, this has not really been an issue because they stretched after a few wearings and feel just fine.

Love these shoes! They live up to the Keen reputation I've been hearing about for years. They are comfy enough to walk for hours and offer a little more fashion than my usual running shoes.Based on size reviews, I bought a half size bigger than I normally wear and they are perfect.

Overall, I love these shoes. I researched a lot, looking for a comfy pair of mary janes that I could wear with anything, that weren't too 'girly' and that would help my back pain after toting and running after toddlers all day. These shoes are just perfect on all counts. I bought the Port Royale color, which is pretty accurately depicted in the picture as a burgundy-purple. They are a bit darker than the photo, which is fine. And the color seems to match everything in my hippie-style earth-tone wardrobe. Too, they look great with everything from cargos to capris, and I could see them looking great with funky-styled skirts or dresses too. I'd hesitated to buy these because some of the negative reviews, particularly concerning the top of the shoes above the toes and the back of the shoe being sharp/rough. The area on the top of the shoes, above the toe is not as spacious as the width of the shoe seems to demand. It felt odd the first couple of wears, but this area does stretch within the first few days to a comfortable level, or at least it did for me. My feet are tending toward narrow in every dimension. If your feet are unusually shaped, or wider at the top I can definitely see where this area might not stretch enough to be comfortable. The heel of the shoe is not perfectly soft and does not have cushioning. If these shoes were to fit tightly, this could be irritating. I am between a 7 and 7.5 size-wise, so ordered a 7 based on other reviewers comments. I probably could have gone smaller, but I think comfort would have been a sacrifice. The 7.5, which is more my normal size, would have been too big in this shoes; they do run at least half a size big in my estimation. The shoes fit me very much like slippers, they feel like slippers too, and they slide on without being unbuckled, because of the extra room in them and the wide width. They are very lightweight, are comfortable for taking walks around the neighborhood, and chasing after two toddlers outdoors. At the end of the day, the back pain I was experiencing with my old shoes (Birkis) is no longer there, so they definitely have a great deal more support than the clogs I'm used to wearing. If you're looking for comfort and versatile style, and if your feet don't typically demand specialty shoes, I don't think you could go wrong with these. My only gripe is that, like all things, they are made in China.

These shoes are way too comfortable. The first time I ever wore them I walked all around New York City without any problems. I have numerous foot issues, including plantar fasciitis, and these Keens afford me much comfort. They are true to size and very roomy in the toe area.

These shoes are great. I wear them all the time. I ordered the same size as my "oxford" type Keens and they fit well. They are a little wide, but that is to be expected with Keen. I had been looking for Keen: Mary Janes and these fit the bill.

I'm wearing these all the time! They have a pretty neutral footbed, which works for me because I'm wearing them with orthotic arch supports. My feet feel really secure in them, they look good and the soles are super on my icy driveway! Really great for wide feet; my feet are really wide and there's tons of room. I don't think people with narrow feet would like these. I bought the pink ones; got tired of black shoes. Happy with the choice. I'm definitely going to buy some more pairs of Keens.

Awesome, good looking comfortable shoe. Especially for wide feet. Usually wear WW in other shoes. But the B-Medium Keene Calistoga fits just fine. Very short break in period with the upper rim of the shoe on top of my foot. Was comfortable and no problem after a week. Well worth the price. But then, any Keen shoe usually tends to be a good deal.

These are the best shoes I have ever found! I have them in almost every color. They are super comfy and wear well. I have worn this style for 5 years now. I feel they have a wider toe bed than most shoes. They are worth every penny.

My purchasing - exchanging - purchasing experience has been so simple with Zappos.com. Great customer service. Very friendly and trusting. I love my new shoes. They look good with almost any kind of pants and are very comfortable right from the start, no break-in time. I also appreciate the width of the shoes while still looking stylish.

These are great shoes! They are really comfortable, as Keen shoes usually are. They are particularly good for me, because I can take out the liners and they fit my orthotics without being tight.

These are very comfy and cute! I ordered a 6.5 but usually wear a 7. They fit great and really are a fun color.