Customer Reviews SOREL Cumberland™ II

I really liked the versatility of these shoes, they are relatively lightweight (compared to the Caribou) and warm. I usually wear 7½-8 and ordered a size 8. The overall fit was good, however, my big toes were touching the top of the shoes, so I knew that it would be uncomfortable if wearing them for any length of time. They will be returned.

I bought these boots based on the reviews and although I find them to be very comfortable and stylish, I bought them for warmth. I had a trip in zero degree weather and needed something to keep my feet warm. These boots were rated for -25 so I thought they would be perfect. With 2 pairs of socks and foot warmers in the toes of the boots, I could not keep my feet warm. I am pretty disappointed given the wonderful reviews. I will probably be looking for another pair of boots...again.

Just bought these boots and I'm not impressed. They are entirely too casual for anything besides walking the dog. They are waterproof, I will give them that, but they get dirty fast and are impossible to tie snugly due to the inconvenient lacing system. Worst of all, they are no better than regular gym shoes on the ice, which is what I was counting on them for. Overall, while they are not horrible, I would not buy them again.

My right foot is a true size 9, my left foot is more like a 9.5. With some boots it doesn't matter; with these, it did. The left boot cut into the top of my foot right where the rubber joins the leather.

Love the looks of these boots on my feet, but they are narrow and slip quiet a bit in the heel. I think a size bigger would make them too clunky. Have to send these back. :(

These were too big for me. I normally wear an 8 but have narrow ankles and they were huge on me.

I was sad to have to send these back. I normally wear size 5, which is the smallest available, and they are quite big; lots of heel slippage. Yet they are also too tight on the top of the foot where the laces start, so wearing thicker socks would not be possible. Too bad, I really wanted tall boots. I just received the Columbia Summette and those seem better (but too small). Why isn't there universal sizing? This would be a lot easier.

Heel kept slipping - I really wanted these boots to work out for me, but the heel kept slipping. This caused my sock to bunch down around my ankle and foot - so annoying. I tightened the laces as far as I could and it did not help. There's no way I'm spending $90 on boots only to have my heel come up with each step and sock bunch down uncomfortably. Other than that, the boot fit perfectly. It is well made, lightweight, warm, and true to size. Also, the footpad in the boot was very flat with little arch support, and the boots did feel stiff. I would've kept them though, if my heel did not slip.

These boots are cute but that's about it. Bought them to have a stylish pair of warm boots based on the product weather description and reviews. I've heard great things about Sorel but I'm very disappointed. Wore these on a 30 degree day with two pairs of wool socks, a 30 minute walk on dry pavement and my feet were frozen solid. These definitely won't cut it for winter in the Midwest but I had to wear them outside to figure that out so I'm stuck with them.

These were disappointing. I was hoping that I had found boots to keep my feet warm. I wore them for the first time this morning to shovel snow, and my toes were frozen. I would return them, but have worn them so doubt I can do that. Don't waste your money on these.

These boots are VERY heavy, they are not good if doing anything other than a short distance in the snow. The color is not the soft white as shown, it is more of a muddied grey/white. Returning.

The Shoe felt wide and overall, big. It also felt very heavy.

I must not have been in my right mind to keep these boots. I obviously did not realize what a good shoe feels likes. These shoes have no arch support and no ankle support- awful for hiking. It's like wearing gigantic loafers. Never again will I buy boots from this brand.