Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Melton Classic Dress Cap Toe Oxford

Fits well. Looks good

Wonderful dress shoes, I love the dark cordovan color.

Great looking; great workmanship, and super comfy.

These shoes are great. My first pair lasted 10 yrs. I just had the sole replaced which was no big deal. Love my shoes. Especially since it's difficult for me to get the right shoes being my feet are wide and small. I'd like to get them in a different color.

I like the quality of the Melton Cap Toe, but I think you should have more color options. The light brown color you sell is fine for someone who is looking for that specific shade, but I've been purchasing them and dying them a darker shade. I really hate having to dye them, because some of the dye colors and names seem to be very misleading.

Only show I can rely on for fit, comfort, and style.

The shoe fits well. I am actually a C but the D works.

Good dress shoe, not as nice as aristocraft

Beautiful shoe, unfortunately, slightly too big

Love these shoes - owned several pairs over many years. All-day comfort even with frequent wearing; good arch support and room through the ball of the foot; no heel slip. Solid, strong sole great when standing, walking or dancing. Classic great looks. Quality construction throughout.

Shoes looks great and are overall very comfortable!

The fit is good and they are comfortable, but the sole is extremely stiff.

It's a very attractive shoe and well made.

I purchased these shoes as a gift for my son

My husband owns 3 pair now, burgundy, brown and black! They are comfortable, good looking and excellent quality.

The shoe looks stylish and is great to wear at formal events or business meetings. My feet are wide and fit well into this shoe.

Feel great

Classic all leather (even the sole) men's dress shoe.

I have been consistently wearing JM oxford cap toe dress shoes for over 30 years. This statement should answer any question you might have regarding the quality of their dress shoes. Oh, and I should add, that their Customer Service (Christy and Armando) reflects the high-quality of their dress shoes. Full stop.

Although they were very stiff during the first week, the shoes gradually became more comfortable. If they feel a bit small, they're probably not. It takes some time for leather to expand to your foot and if you buy a pair that are comfortable out of the box, you will end up with loose fitting shoes that are really uncomfortable in the long run.

Very fashionable shoe, but do not have to give up comfort.

Beautiful dress shoes. I wear sneakers and J-M's best when sneakers won't do.. They are comfortable, long-lasting, and always in style. I've been a customer for 25 years.

excellent shoe good fit . Shoe finish too shiny