Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Melton Classic Dress Cap Toe Oxford

Great looking shoe, great fit - a bit more comfortable after you've worn them a few times. Wouldn't hesitate to order these again.

Traditional men's oxford. Well made. Expect many years of use from these shoes.

Best bang for the buck, looks and feels great all day.

Best dress shoe! Durable, I have replaced two times the sole and the shoe continues to deliver both in comfort and style.

Great show. Broke them in within an hour. Run very big. I am a 10.5 I needed the 8.5 in this shoe.

N/A

Conservative design compliments professional dress. Shoes say a lot about the wearer. A $500 suit is discounted when wearing broken down shoes.

I wear these about 2x a week to work. They don't take long to break in and are very comfortable. Quality seems to be good so far.

I am a corporate lawyer working in the entertainment business....I deal with execs that spend much more on their shoes... I own several pairs of meltons... and wear the black and burgandy often... I have them freshly spit polished often and the black shine up like glass and the burgany glow...everyone notices the good looking style and the amazing shine they take...

Wore this at my wedding looked great !!!!!!!

Daily for work

I bought these shoes since I was looking for a burgundy/oxblood oxford to complement my existing brown and black ones. I'm very impressed with the welt construction and the comfort of the shoe in general. I'm looking forward to wearing these for years and years to come. The only drawback is that the sole, true to any leather, is initially very slick and takes a bit of scoring/scuffing in order to get decent traction.

The product is excellent quality, with comfort kept in mind while producing an elegant design.

The ordering and service was great

I wear these for work at least 3 times per week and also when I need to dress for special occasions. The only thing I am not happy with are the laces. The knot will not stayed tied no matter what I do. Other than that they are great shoes.

This shoe is beautiful and classy. My husband usually wears a 15W; however, it seems actually too big. He wants to keep them and add a heel cushion in the back to keep from slipping, but we may have to return them.

Great shoes. Very attractive and comfortable to wear beginning day 1

I bought the Melton Cap toe in both Tan & Black to go with different suits for different occasions. Both pair are beautifully made with quality construction and are comfortable right out of the box, no break-in period required. They also look great dressed-down a bit with chinos or jeans. The black is classic, and the tan is the perfect shade - not too dark of a tan, not too light, looks great with a blue suit and the J&M tan dress belt. I get compliments on these shoes every time I wear them, & I could not be more pleased with my purchase. I highly recommend these shoes!

Great looking shoe. Purchased product to ware to a wedding. Love the shoe !