Customer Reviews Dockers Gordon Cap Toe Oxford

Decent show, especially for the price. Runs wider than most shoes I buy, so you might want to think about buying a size smaller then you normally do. Laces where especially long and I had to replace them after a month.

Very nice shoe for the price. Good quality and have, so far, noticed no problems. The shoe runs a bit narrow, which was not a huge problem once they were broken in a bit, but I would have ordered a size wider had I known.

I've had this shoe for quite sometime now and its still just as comfortable as the day I got it. The color has not faded and has held up. Quality shoe for the price.

These are inexpensive shoes and it shows. Very stiff leather. Not much arch support. They look good but scuff easily. If you can afford to spend more you should, but for the price these are fine for occasional use.

I am surprised these shoes are so popular. I have worn them for one day at work and they hurt my feet. I would hate to wear them to walk outside. I can't imagine wearing them for a long distance. They are stiff and cut into my feet. Maybe the size isn't right...regardless - they look like a mediocre pair of shoes one would find at Target or Payless.

I bought Dockers based on a past purchase of a very comfortable shoe. This shoe is very stylish, however, the quality is not the same. They have gone cheap and left very little padding from the toes to the arch. What makes it decent is the heel support made out of a hard rubber gel. I have tried several other shoes. This was the best I could find. Buy the right padding and its still worth the price compared to other expensive brands.

Good looking narrow shoe - A very attractive shoe, but inadequate width. I hope these break-in but presently can be uncomfortable. I had ordered an EE width and received W, which is all they had to offer. I felt this was deceptive, but I kept them anyway.

Comfortable but heavy and squeaky. These are as comfortable as Rockports, but the soles are different. They are a soft rubber that's quite heavy and a bit noisy. Nice look, though. Simple, and with normal shaped (not square) toes.

Dockers Gordon - Leather rather stiff when received, stretched out well. Still not the most comfortable shoe I have had, but acceptable.

Very stiff, hard to break in.

Very hard toe box....seemed like a steel toed shoe. My husband did not like the feel at all

Nice looking shoe. Bought two pairs in April 2017. The black pair is now busted on one side. The brown one's sole is cracked. I thought shoes would last longer than 1 year. Caveat emptor

I have worn Dockers Gordon shoes as my exclusive dress shoes for more than 10 years. They look good, fit well. But. The quality of the sole has deteriorated over time. My weight hasn't changed in 10 years. I wear them the same amount of time every work day. And yet the soles wear out very quickly. My most recent three pair are five months old. I don't expect much from a $50 pair of shoes, but three pair should last a little longer than that.

It's a very nice looking shoe but my son said that it hurt and didn't fit him well. Unfortunately I have to return them.

Shoe lasted about 5 weeks before the heels gave out. Back of foot sinks into the air spaces into the heel and the seam between the heel and the upper tore. I'm a big guy, but I've never had a shoe fail this soon after purchase. Happened to both shoes. Won't be buying another Dockers shoe again. I did get compliments on how they looked, which was nice.

The soles look a little chunky when worn with dress slacks. If you're wearing them with chinos or jeans, they look better. After a few months of week-day wear, the outsole on the right shoe split open on the bottom of the shoe. This may have been fluke, but I probably won't be buying these again.

Though these shows fit and feel fine when standing still, they are unwearably uncomfortable when walking. Because I didn't find this out until I had worn them out and about, they are not eligible for return, so I'll likely just be donating them to Goodwill. I cannot wear these shoes; they are just too uncomfortable. They look great, and for their price seem to be of fine quality.

I like Docker pants, but hated the shoes. This site lists them as "Full Grain Leather" but they are NOT. They are "Corrected Leather" which was peeling in less than 1 year. The worst part was the soles have no durability, worn thru to the pad in less than 1 year.

The right shoe was extremely uncomfortable and painful even after a week of wearing. My foot across the top (right shoe only) was extremely blistered, and at times slight pus and blood thru the sock could be seen. I contacted Zappos and advised them, the customer svc rep was outstanding, he refunded my money (even though I was just going to throw them in a garbage can, the pain was to much, and be out the cost) but Zappos rep said don't worry, we are refunding it. So because of the great customer service, I then proceeded to buy another pair (different brand) for a replacement. It was truly a great experience from the customer service from Zappos.

This was a miserable experience. I went through two pairs in about three months. I only wore them to work, so I would guess that they got something in the neighborhood of 15 miles a week; if that estimate is correct, both pairs failed within the first 100 miles of use. In both cases, the insole peeled away from the sidewall and collapsed into the (hollow) heel. The rubber outer soles of the first pair (both shoes!) also cracked, allowing water to seep inside. After one pair, I assumed it was a fluke; after two, I will not be buying a third. They were, in their defense, comfortable until the insole failed, so if you are going to wear them once a month, they might be fine. But I would not recommend them for daily wear.

I have purchased this same style shoe for about 3 years. I purchase a pair every 6 months due to wear. This year, on both pairs I purchased, the souls of the shoes cracked within months of my purchase allowing water to get into the shoe from the bottom. It's been a great run but these shoes are off my list.

Comfortable, but poor quality. I bought a pair of these shoes to wear for work in a restaurant. I found them to be quite comfortable, but after two and a half months both soles cracked all the way through, letting water seep through. They were good to me while they lasted, but if you have an active job and plan on wearing them every day, I would look elsewhere.

Putting a "Real Leather" banner across the base of the laces makes it real hard to remove, unless you try to cut it. Of course, I did and now need a new set of shoe laces. Not user friendly!

I bought these shoes for work about a year ago and they look great. The color is perfect to go with khaki or lighter colored pants, however they were extremely uncomfortable and stiff. The leather was almost like hard plastic and never really softened up,even after a year. I also wore a hole in the sole where the flex point was and they would leak when the ground was wet. I don't recommend them because they lack durability and comfort, even at this price. Keep looking.

I bought two pairs of these dockers in the beginning of May 2014 and as of November 2014 one pair is already unwearable and the bottom has come out of it and the other is getting there, forcing me to now spend even more money to acquire new shoes that I'm praying last longer than 5-6 months. When I first received them they were very stylish and quite comfortable but the quality is crap being the sole came out of the bottom while I was at work less than six months into owning them and wearing them a few times a week alternating between my other two pairs of work shoes. I'd recommend you don't buy these and pay the little bit of extra money to get something that will last you. I'd personally recommend Allen Edmonds for ultimate quality being I bought one pair and wore those practically every day for several years in fact I didn't replace them with these dockers until about six years down the road and heavy pavement pounding being I sell cars for a living. If it wasn't for the low quality and my heel/sole giving out so quickly, I would've given them 5 stars.