Customer Reviews Dockers Gordon Cap Toe Oxford

This shoe runs wide (even for a wide) and the leather is extremely stiff and leaves obvious creases just from trying them on to see if they fit.

Just ok

The leather is very stiff, and the shoes are pretty uncomfortable right now. I am hoping they soften up a bit as I wear them.

True to size but virtually no arch support.

Well made and look nice for a young teenager’s first dress shoe. Somewhat stiff and not particularly comfortable. Little cushioning.

The pair looked and fit like they were 11’s. I checked the size twice and they were listed as 10’s. I had to return them. The width (we ordered wide) was fine. Otherwise the shoes looked nice and felt like they were quality.

This is fine for a cheap dress shoe - no question about it. If you just need dress shoes a few times a year, for weddings, funerals, Bar Mitzvahs, this is the shoe for you. For me, I've found that most men's dress shoes require a break-in period. I assume that this one is the same and will get slightly more comfortable the more I wear it - which won't be for a few months now. However, after wearing it once to a wedding, I was happy to take them off and get back into my sneakers. They don't exactly hurt; but they're not like walking on clouds, either.

The shoes were good, but word of warning...if you use them regularly, they don’t last long. Had to replace them in January 2020 after buying them in April 2019 because the outside was peeling on the heel.

EVEN THOUGHT THE COMPANY STATES WIDE IS THE SAME AS ( EE ) I FIND IT UNTRUE... I'VE TRIED OTHER MFR. AND FOUND THERE EE IS MUCH WIDER THEN A SHOE ADVERTISED AS WIDE.

Very stiff shoe. hopefully they will soften some saddle soap treatments

The shoe cracjed on the bend after aprox. 5 wears. Zappos replaced them for me.

It was an appropriate show for the cost. I only wore it for a couple of minutes as the width was certainly not the EE that I have come to expect from other Dockers shoes. The length seemed fine and they were comfortable except for the narrow fit.

This show was comfortable at first. But cannot stand up to my being heavy set. If you are over 280. Consider a different show

I bought a pair of these shoes just last year and they both had cracks in the soles and let water in when it rains. I know they are low-end category, but I wear them mostly indoors, I have bought shoes from Clarks or Skechers in the past and they last much better and for many years. Not a good choice in my opinion.

Stiff, could use a better cushioning. I do not recommend these. There are other shoes out there that are more comfortable.

I had a different style of Dockers dress shoes that were a size 11. I ordered these in a size 11 and could not even get my feet into them. I did a swap for the size 12 (thank you, Zappos) and that was also to tight. I returned them and ordered a size 13W and this pair fits fine. The sizes between shoes is way off, but thanks to Zappos I was able to get it all figured out.

Nice looking shoe but will require a lot of time to wear in. It bends far back from the toe and digs into the top of my foot. Not a keeper.

These shoes looked good online and great when they came out of the box. They fit perfectly and I was very pleased. Until I spent a day wearing them. All new shoes need to be broken in, but the design of these puts a reinforced seam right over the first knuckle of my toes, which was terribly painful and drew blood the first wearing. I waited a week and tried again, with the same result. I really would like to keep these shoes, as they look great, but if I cannot find a way to do so without hurting myself, they'll have to go back!

Very comfortable, but NOT durable. I wear them daily and have worn through the sole in about 10 months. I will admit I am heavy (250lbs) and fairly hard on them - bending, kneeling, squatting, etc.

I have had these for 4 years now, as my daily 9-5 desk job work shoe. They fit well and are plenty comfortable after a short break-in. Biggest problem I had is they do not last long and the build quality is lacking, but I guess you get what you pay for. The first thing I noticed was the loose threads in the seams; no big deal but they look cheap as a result. My first pair split the rubber soles within 10 months, and the replacement pair Zappos sent did the same within the next year. I kept the second pair going (the split sole mostly just let water in if I stepped in a puddle, no other problems) and by 3 years the soles were falling off. This isn't to say these are bad shoes - they are comfortable and cheap and will work for a couple years if you are on a budget.

The "antiqued cordovan" color seems more like dark red than brown. And at size 15, they looked a bit like clown shoes. A coat of black polish helped bring them closer to the correct color. It took a full 2 weeks to get them to the point that they weren't hurting the tops of my feet at the break. They feel ok, but not great to walk long distances. At 3 weeks of limited wear, there's already some fraying at the top and rear of the lining. Even for the low price, I would have expected a little more durability. Over all, not a bad budget shoe. But I have to expect to be replacing them shortly because of the limited life.

I bought these for my "Sunday for church" shoes and found after 7 months of Sunday (only) wearing the heel fell apart. Came as quite a surprise. 7 months x 4 wearings per month = 28 wearings. Doesn't speak well for the product.

Nice looking shoe, quality built for the price. I am not very happy with the interior material of the shoe, however. Very stiff and not very comfortable. Hoping they will break-in with use. I can not wear these for a full eight hour work day.

The shoelaces broke the third day that I wore them. Other than that, they are great. I am still very fond of ordering on Zappos as they have more size 15 shoes to chose from than anyone else on the Web. Keep up the great service!

This has become my default pair of dress shoes, always buying same style for last 7 years, a classic. My last pair I received was same as others EXCEPT Dockers changed sole material from a crepe material to a more rubbery material. No big deal except it squeaks when you walk. May have to find a new default.