Customer Reviews Deer Stags Tribune Comfort Oxford

I've ordered this shoe in years past with satisfactory results. The pair I ordered a year ago fell apart and the replacement is now falling apart as well. They changed something on this shoe for the worst and I will not order another.

Uncomfortable and boxy - Strange unfitted construction, because it was roomy in all the wrong places; felt like I was wearing a shoebox, not a shoe. The sole has a big molded bump right under the ball of my foot, which made it even more uncomfortable for walking in. Also, I will not buy another shoe with SUPRO, the sock has a big built-in foam pillow under the heel which runs all the way through to the bottom of the sole (you can see it in the photos of the sole), so if the sock wears out you have to buy a SUPRO replacement (rather than your insert of choice).

Where did Quality Control go? This is my fourth pair of Deer Stag's Tribune. I was recently informed that they are being discontinued and I can see why. The 3rd pair the adhesive failed at the tip/toe. This pair is of lesser quality and the insert in the left shoe heel popped out. It appears not to have been glued or molded properly. Love the shoes for comfort, the QC is gone.

Fit as desired, size was spot on. Comfortable. Long-lasting, other than the laces, although maybe I tug too tightly when tying them.

The shoes over all are very comfortable around the ankles where there is currently some padding I am looking forward to them a little bit more broken . I wish they breathe a little better.

Very comfortable shoe, my second pair. Great value for the price.

Best shoe deal I've ever gotten. Nice traditional look. Fit is very comfortable. Price can't be beat. Zappo's service is superb.

This is a great shoe. It looks like a very expensive shoe and I get many compliments. The fit is excellent and it is the most comfortable shoe I have had in a long time.

I own very few shoes that aren't tennis shoes because I can never get shoes that fit me properly. I'm female and all I wanted was a basic black oxford that I could wear to work that would be office appropriate, not overly masculine, and comfortable. My foot is a little wide and I can't ever find any oxfords in women's, so I thought ordering the smallest size of men's would provide the width I needed. These are PERFECT. They are incredibly comfortable. I ALWAYS have to put heel liners in all my shoes to prevent rubbing. Nope--not with these. They were perfect after the first hour I had them on. I forgot entirely that I even had new shoes on. When I first put them on, they felt a little narrow. But that narrowness completely disappeared within the first hour. The only thing I don't like is that there is a crease across the top that immediately appeared when I put them on. I wish that didn't happen. But other than that, these are perfect and I highly recommend. I'm definitely going to start looking at this brand for additional options. I bought them on a whim since it was free shipping/returns.

Comfortable right away, light weight. I use them for work and I walk a lot. We’ll see how long they last but for now a great value.

The size was perfect, the material was excelnt, & I like them alot, I have been wairing them for many years.

Great shoe, takes on anything

I work weddings and special events as a DJ and require a dress shoe that will be comfortable, stylish, and durable. The Deer Stag Tribune is a contemporary, wing-tip oxford shoe that is comfortable and conforms to the shape of your foot plus the sole and heel cushioning stands up to shock absorption. This shoe meets the demands of my profession such as standing all day, loading and unloading equipment. The Deer Stag Tribune shoe cushioning and support holds up better than my other $150.00+ brand wing tip oxford shoes. Why? Because the more expensive shoe has a leather insole that does not handle well with everyday wear and shock absorption. The Deer Stag Tribune shoe is the low cost answer for everyday use without compromising that contemporary wing tip style of its more expensive competitors. So if you are in the service industry and need a dress shoe for that demanding job, then this is the shoe for you. For everyday wear, these shoes will last between 1.5 to 2 years and for the price, it is well worth it. I just bought a second pair of these shoes for backup.

Good price. Good shoe.

Very nice shoes. The sizing is larger than normal.

Deer Stags were the 'perfect swag' for my son's first formal dance and first pair of men's dress shoes!

Very nice shoes.. They're very comfortable.. I wore them for the first time for a wedding, had them on all day and nite, no problems or painful feet at the end of the day.. Very good looking shoes.. Went very well with my suit.. Ordering was super easy.. Next Day free shipping when ordered thru the Zappos App.. I'll order again from Zappos!!! :-)

Good looking. Traditional styling. Great price. Excellent fit - particularly for my extra wide feet.

Very nice shoes for the price!! Ordered these for a wedding I was attending, and they were comfortable for the long hours involved. I love the classic wing tip style, and these completed my outfit perfectly. Don't be afraid to pick up some for a wedding or for casual as well.

Not the most fancy wingtip you could buy, but an excellent value in these shoes! I wear them every day and they are excellent!

Great Shoe, very comfortable!

Retired Disable Combat Marine and I usually don't reply to review requests; however, this is an exception. I ordered 3 dress shoes and all 3 fit and arrived a day earlier than expected. That's service!

I am 14EEE and needed a dressy shoe. Most dress shoes are very uncomfortable and since I wear them to work in (I am on my feet when I do jobs as a musician). I needed something that looked dressy but was comfortable. These shoes while a traditional wingtip not necessarily high fashion do look dressy in a classic way but they have lots of padding and rubber soles and heels which make them very comfortable. Sort of like a fake dress shoe!

These are comfortable for those long walking commutes. They are not the classiest looking shoes but they definitely will fit into any business attire; not business casual. They work great for my accounting job which I wear these everyday.

I received the shoes quickly. I love them. They are very classy, I hope they fit my stepson, his birthday is in a few days and he will be 18. He loves wing tips, go figure. My husband loved Deer Stags. They are a good price, and now i can order my shoes as well. My husband is asking for work boots, so I told him one pair at a time. You made it easy to shop. My husband tried them on, said it was like walking on clouds.