Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Petty

Beautiful grey-beige neutral color. Like the sleek, smooth styling, with nice stitching --almost piping--covering the side seam on the non-zipper side. Love the color. The fit is uncomfortable for me, fitted in front, heel slipping up in back. Can't keep it for that reason.

These have been a staple in my closet for years! I’m pretty rough on my shoes so the only reason o purchased a new pair again is because my other pair was much too “well loved.” ?? My favorite pair of booties!!

The toe area is too narrow for my feet and minimal arch support.

I have somewhat narrow feet, and have never bought shoes that were too narrow for me until now. I got these boots in my regular size, 7.5, but they are too narrow to be comfortable with socks on. Even so, my heel slips if I try to wear them without socks. There is no padding in the bottom, so I would need even more room to put in a removable insole. They are an attractive color and versatile style.

Very cute bootie. However, they are very narrow and the right one seems a bit more snug and cuts my circulation off some. Didn’t realize it til I wore them on a trip/thru an airport. May return them as I have to leave the little zipper down on the right one(my feet are same size)

Cute, classy boot. Bought for my daughter in a 7.5 W- she was happy to have a shoe that fit so well.

Unfortunately, these boots did not fit my foot. I ordered the 6, which fit like a 6.5. Sad to send them back.

I loved the style but the inside felt like stiff cardboard! I can’t believe there was any padded material used. Very disappointing and I returned the,.

Love these! I got them in both the black faraj tapestry (so, so cute) and in black leather (classic and chic). I can tell they run a little narrow, but the shoe stretches to accommodate my foot with no discomfort. They’re really comfortable and so stylish. I can’t speak to how long they’ll last, because I’ve only had them for a few weeks. But so far, I’m pleased!

This was way too wide and was just clunky looking on. I have purchased the "Petty" in other colors and leathers, same size and they were fine. I was very dissappointed in this item!

This shoe is my very defintion of pain. I tried them on, and because they were so cute, I thought well, they just need breaking in. After one wear, my feet are done. I am always a standard 10 B, and these were so narrow I could not believe it. Also, there is so litlle cushioning on the bottom that my feet were throbbing after 1 hour of walking. Pretty shoes, but killer on the feet.

i love this shoe, however the left shoe was shorter than the right shoe, which fit perfectly. i am trying a different color to see if it fits properly.

This is a beautiful shoe, but I felt it fit about 1/2 size too small (I wear a 9.5 wide). There is no cushioning, so I don't think it would be very comfortable to wear for long periods of time.

Nice looking but couldn't get a good fit.

Nice shoe but slightly too big. Ordered a half size up to be able to wear socks but still too big. Need them for out of town trip and did not have time to get a smaller pair before the trip.

Beautiful boot, but the nap on the suede was a little course and not the same on both boots. The leather strip that covers the zipper was wrinkled and didn't seem like it would lay out. Sadly, they are going back.

These booties are extremely comfortable out of the box. The toe box is ample and the low heel is attractive and comfortable.

This shoe is sooo good-looking!

Pinched my toes. Not quite wide enough and my foot is often happy in a normal width though I ordered a wide to I could wear thick socks. No way could I last even half a day in the classroom in these.

I have had these booties now for about two years and absolutely love them. So many reviewers said they are uncomfortable but I find them extremely comfortable. I walked 11 miles around NYC one day on a recent trip and they were perfect. The leather and heels are holding up great. Planning to get them in another color.

Very narrow and I don't have wide feet.

Loved the styling of this boot. However I have a narrow foot and an even narrower heel and it just did not fit. I thought I might be able to make it work with a double sock BUT the main reason I am returning is the boot felt like I was walking on concrete. It has no padding whatsoever. It was rock hard. It was uncomfortable to try it on so I cannot imagine walking in these or standing. So the hunt continues.

These boots are cute but even the wide runs narrow. I sized up and even so they were uncomfortably tight. My feet aren't even that wide!

I can get my foot in and wear them for a short time, but they are not comfortable at all. They are very tight unless I wear super thin socks.

Just what I was looking for, beautiful! I don’t usually order a wide but figured it couldn’t hurt cause it’s has kind of a narrow toe, I’m glad I did because it still pinched my toes while wearing them. I think the regular width would have hurt to bad to wear them. They sit nice and low, didn’t rub on my head and have nice cushioning inside. VERY HAPPY ??????