What Our Customers Are Saying
from Arlington, Virginia
I ordered 9 pairs of black pumps. This was the last pair I tried on. They are amazingly comfortable. I haven't worn them for any length of time yet, but they are already ahead of my other options. I think they are true to size, but many of the other pumps felt about a half-size small, so others may find that they are a half-size big.
from Upstate New York
Gorgeous, gorgeous boots - even better in person. However (oh, how I hate that word sometimes!), they were way too narrow for me. I guess I have to admit it to myself that I just have to buy wide shoes!! Back they go....
Reviewer: Alicia S.
from Jersey City, NJ
These shoes were absolutely gorgeous and even though the heel was higher than I usually wear it wasn't the high heel that was the problem. I had to squeeze my foot into it and it really pinched my toes. I wish I had read more carefully that these seem to fit a half size small. And now they don't have a larger size anymore. Really sad! But I love Zappos! Bad fits happen I guess.
from Palos Park, IL
I really liked the look of this shoe. I ordered it in 3 different sizes and could not get a good fit. I have a wide foot and need more room in the toe box, when that fit it was falling off my heel. Very cute shoe so I am disappointed I have to send it back. Of course Zappos is always quick and efficient with returns.
from Denver, Colorado
I got these attractive boots in both colors because they are so comfortable! I recommend them highly! They felt slightly snug when I first bought the black ones, but the leather soon conformed comfortably to my foot and I wear them all the time now.
Reviewer: Linda Stewart
Very pretty shoe, but the heel is just too high for my wide feet, so I'm slipping down into toes and have 1/2" space at heel, cannot walk in them.
from Alma, KS
We just got our first snow here in Kansas and my granddaughter was freezing when she came over. Ordered these for her for Christmas, but there's no way we're waiting until then to give them to her. Such great quality and they were here before I knew it. It says that they're cold rated to -20 degrees, since the wind chill is two degrees, we're going to test that out right away.
Reviewer: Khoi N
from Wheaton, IL
I'm only 5'1" so wearing this boot was quite uncomfortable since it keep hitting the back of my knee! I wouldn't recommend buying these boots if you have short calves like I do. Also the way that they sewn the top part of the boot was crooked. It's only noticeable if someone else is with you when you're trying it on. I'm afraid that after wearing these boots for awhile they might give me feet problems so I'm returning these. Also I recommend order half a size larger so you can insert insole into these for a more comfortable wear if you do decide to buy them!
from Pacific Northwest
After tirelessly searching for the perfect Frye boots to fit my athletic calves, I found the Shirley Riding Plate. Love the rubber outer sole for traction. The shaft shape is just what I was looking for - straight like a tue riding boot. Gorgeous leather is durable but soft. The hammered copper color actually looks darker and less orangey in person. Will likely be buying in more colors... Can't beat Frye quality and Zappos service!
from Colorado Springs
Like all the reviews before, these shoes are prettier in person. I got them in a 6.5 and had to buy the heel stickers, my feet did slip out a little. With the heel inserts they fit perfect. Not super comfy shoes but beauty is pain in my book. These are seriously princess shoes and make any dress beautiful.