Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Dobson Cap Lace Up

These shoes are very comfortable and look really smart. I have extra wide and long feet (my wife says a clowns feet) and so its hard for me to find the right shoe. These are really great and look well.

These are some of the best dress shoes I have ever worn, they are sleek and go well with my black and gray suits. They seem to be very durable and extremely comfortable. They also come in most every size including my 14 wide. an Awesome Shoe, you won't be sorry.

Another good looking and super comfortable Johnston and Murphy shoe. Fits right.

Nice shoes. The finish is more brown than the picture shows. Was expecting more reddish. Kind of disappointing. Overall good quality shoes. Size is perfect for wide feet.

Nice shoe but the medium width was to narrow. I never have had to buy a wide shoe before. As they are made of leather over time the shoe will stretch some and hopefully be a good shoe.

Needed a dress shoe to go with business dress attire as well as classy casual when out with my wife and kids. These J&Ms look great and are comfortable. Occasionally I need to stand for extended periods of time, and these shoes perform well. However, if I need to stand or walk for several hours on consecutive days, I need to switch to another pair as these are heavy and solid and my feet need something lighter. But for everyday wear, they're excellent. Good looking and masculine.

These shoes are the ideal balance for the daily suit dress code and comfort. Flexible and comfortable - yet durable. Cap Toe adds a touch of additional style.

While I'm resistant to dressing up, I really liked this shoe. It's not groundbreaking, but the style is clean and contemporary and the shoe is well padded. I felt the shoe was a little narrow - my outer toes sit hard against the sides which causes discomfort after a few hours. I would have returned it for a wider size because of this, but the leather parts of the sole were damaged after walking around my house. After 15 minutes, my concrete and stone floors absolutely wrecked the toe's leather. If you want to walk around in these at all before you're sure, it might be best to cover that part of the shoe.

This is my 3rd pair. I like these shoes. They are very comfortable with a minimal break in period. They look good for any business occasion and the interior leather stays buttery soft forever. The problem: DURABILITY! I am on my third pair because they wear out so quick. I clean and polish monthly so I take care of my shoes and I don't go running around in the snow or salt with them in the winter but I can't get a pair to stay together past 16 months. The leading offender is the heel separating from the sole of the shoe. This happens on both eventually. I would also say the comfort wears out over a years time as well but this is easily fixed with a tin insert. For the price I expect better quality but I keep going back to them because you stick with what works and what is comfortable...

The shoes look great and fit good but after only a couple of months of limited wear (a couple of days of week and not much walking) the sole is already separating from the shoe. I expected better from a pair of shoes at this price.

Great shoe, light weight, supple leather, sharp looking. I have a pair in Brown that is perfect. Apparently, not so much in Black. My first pair lost a heel in mid step (at an airport). Of course, Zappos promptly send me a replacement pair at my destination hotel. Sadly, the replacement pair had the same issue - the heel fell off again.

Loved the style and the footbed was comfortable. However, it was much too narrow and had to exchange it for a wide. The wide was too wide and had to return that too. If either the medium or wide had fit my foot, I would definitely have kept them.